Development and implementation of a novel approach to scaling the Meeting Centre intervention for people living with dementia and their unpaid care workers in the community

Nathan Stephens, Shirley Evans, Chris Russell, Dawn BrookerResearch Square 2024 · DOI

Abstract

Background: In the UK, there is a post-diagnostic support gap for people affected by dementia. Effective interventions must be replicated at scale to meet demand. This study systematically reports a novel county-wide approach for scaling the Meeting Centre intervention using an adapted reporting framework.

Methods: An adapted version of the Template for Intervention Description and Replication (TIDieR) checklist was used, incorporating items for complex social interventions and scaling programmes.

Results: The adapted checklist effectively reported essential criteria, including components, adaptive implementation, and modifications.

Conclusions: This research aids the translation of evidence into routine practice and highlights the role of programme leadership in driving systems change.

Introduction: Addressing the Post-Diagnostic Support Gap

In the UK, individuals living with dementia and their unpaid carers often face a significant "post-diagnostic support gap." While various non-pharmacological interventions have proven effective in controlled pilot settings, they frequently fail to transition into sustainable, large-scale practice—a phenomenon known as the "pilot-to-practice" trap.

The "Meeting Centre" (MC) model is a social club approach designed to help families adjust to the changes brought by dementia. Historically, these centres spread through "spontaneous diffusion," where individual actors initiated local sites independently. This paper examines the Worcestershire Meeting Centres Programme (WMCP), a strategic effort to move from isolated sites to a robust, county-wide infrastructure while maintaining the intervention's core integrity.

Methods and Framework Adaptation

To evaluate this complex scaling effort, researchers employed a qualitative, pragmatic approach. A key methodological innovation was the use of an adapted TIDieR (Template for Intervention Description and Replication) checklist. While standard TIDieR is clinical, the authors extended it to include:

  • SUCCEED items (Standards for Reporting Trials Assessing the Impact of Scaling Up Strategies).
  • "Voice" components to capture stakeholder perspectives.
  • Contextual adaptations necessary for complex social interventions.
The adapted TIDieR checklist used to systematically report the scaling programme.

The study's dataset comprised 34 semi-structured interviews with a diverse participant group, including members with dementia, unpaid carers, volunteers, staff, and health professionals. This was supplemented by "in-situ" observations at three MC sites and routine programme data such as attendance and wellbeing scores.

Key Components of the Scaling Strategy

The scaling process involved several distinct components, ranging from resource distribution to training and monitoring. The University of Worcester acted as a "meso-level" leader, bridging the gap between national policy and local delivery.

Detailed components and sub-components of the Worcestershire Meeting Centres Programme scaling strategy.

Implementation Insights

  • The Meso-Level Leader: The university's role was pivotal. Their perceived impartiality allowed for a "pincer movement"—securing NHS referrals while supporting third-sector providers.
  • Complexity Differential: The programme had to constantly evolve, adding new components like promotional videos and workshops to navigate environmental challenges.
  • Fidelity vs. Feasibility: Scaling revealed that some "essential" pilot features, such as rigorous data collection, became burdensome for local staff, leading to simplifications.

Results and Impact

The WMCP successfully established 10 new Meeting Centres across all six districts of Worcestershire. Key metrics include:

  • Efficiency: Centres typically opened within 3 to 8 months of receiving funding.
  • Capacity Building: 73% of staff and volunteers completed the specialized "Adjusting to Change" training.
  • Framework Utility: The adapted TIDieR checklist proved to be a replicable tool for documenting the "how" and "why" of scaling.

Discussion and Future Directions

While successful, the programme highlighted the risks of "top-down" implementation and the potential for "monopoly power" among large charities, which can stifle local community feel. Future work should focus on determining the "optimal" scale—balancing population needs with resource sustainability—and conducting rigorous Social Cost-Benefit Analyses.

Ultimately, this study provides a blueprint for translating dementia support evidence into routine practice, emphasizing that the environment is often as complex as the intervention itself.

Summary updated

Abstract

<title>Abstract</title> Background In the UK there is a post-diagnostic support gap experienced by people affected by dementia. Effective post-diagnostic support interventions, therefore, need to be replicated at scale to meet demand. Reporting an intervention is key to this process because it can support the translation of research into routine practice. Describing the intervention is a key area of reporting recommended when developing, implementing, and evaluating complex health interventions. The objective of this study was to systematically report a novel county-wide approach for scaling the Meeting Centre intervention for people living with dementia and their unpaid carers. Methods An adapted version of the Template for Intervention Description and Replication (TIDieR) checklist was used to describe the programme. Adaptations were made to consider items specific to complex social interventions and scaling programmes. Key programme stakeholders contributed to its development. Results The adapted TIDieR checklist was an effective way to systematically report essential reporting criteria for the complex scaling programme. Criteria included the components and sub-components, how these were adaptatively implemented, and the modifications made because of complexity. Discussion Key findings suggest essential features of the intervention may not be feasible at scale; highlight the critical role of the programme leader to drive culture and systems change; and emphasise the use of scaling science frameworks to determine optimal scale. Conclusions This research reported the programme’s development and implementation that can aid the process of translating evidence into routine practice. Further research and theory development should include testing implementation outcomes so that we can understand if the intervention is a scalable solution to the gap in the post-diagnostic support for people affected by dementia.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{stephens2024development,
  author = {Nathan Stephens and Shirley Evans and Chris Russell and Dawn Brooker},
  title = {{Development and implementation of a novel approach to scaling the Meeting Centre intervention for people living with dementia and their unpaid care workers in the community}},
  booktitle = {Research Square},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-3996329/v1},
}
Figure