Development and controlling factors of shale lithofacies cycles in a continental rift basin: A case study of Es4u in the Boxing Subsag of Dongying Sag, Bohai Bay Basin, China

Zhengwei Fang, Liqiang Zhang, Cunfei MaFrontiers in Earth Science 2023 · DOI

This study investigates the complex interplay between global astronomical forces and local geological conditions in shaping the rock layers of ancient lake systems. By examining Eocene-aged shales in China’s Bohai Bay Basin, the researchers demonstrate that while Earth’s orbital wobbles (Milankovitch cycles) drive much of the sedimentary rhythm, local factors like tectonics and sediment supply play a much larger role in continental basins than they do in the open ocean.

TL;DR

Researchers identified that shale cycles in continental rift basins are governed by a "dual-control" mechanism: ~55% is driven by global Milankovitch cycles, while ~45% is dictated by local paleogeological conditions. This finding challenges the traditional orbital-only models used for marine shales and provides a more accurate framework for predicting "sweet spots" in shale oil exploration.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In the quest for shale oil, geologists look for "lithofacies cycles"—predictable, repeating patterns of different rock types that indicate where organic matter might be concentrated. In marine environments, these cycles are primarily driven by Milankovitch cycles (periodic changes in Earth’s orbit).

However, continental rift basins (ancient lake systems) are far more sensitive and "fickle" than the open ocean. They react sharply to local tectonic shifts, changes in sediment supply, and regional climate variations. The gap this paper addresses is the lack of a comprehensive model that accounts for how these local "noise" factors interact with global astronomical "signals" to create the complex vertical stacking of shale layers.

Methods

The team focused on the Boxing Subsag of the Dongying Sag, specifically the upper submember of the fourth member of the Eocene Shahejie Formation ($Es_4^u$). They utilized a multi-proxy approach:

  • Core and Thin Section Observation: Analyzing physical rock samples to identify 22 distinct lithofacies (rock types).
  • Well Logging: Using Gamma Ray (GR) and Resistivity (R4) logs to identify large-scale patterns.
  • X-Ray Fluorescence (XRF) Scanning: A high-resolution technique to measure elemental concentrations (like Rubidium, Strontium, and Copper) directly from the core.
  • Spectral Analysis: Using the Acycle software, they performed power spectrum analysis on the elemental data to identify periodicities and match them against known astronomical cycles (eccentricity, obliquity/slope, and precession).

Datasets

The study relied on data from Well FY1, which provided:

  • A continuous core from 3,245 to 3,440 meters.
  • 753 core samples and thin sections.
  • 2,334 high-resolution XRF data points.
  • The La2010d astronomical solution was used as the benchmark for theoretical orbital parameters during the Eocene (approx. 39–44 million years ago).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The 55/45 Split: The most significant insight is the quantification of control. Roughly 55% of the stratigraphic record is controlled by astronomical climate forcing, but a substantial 45% is driven by local geological conditions.
  • Scale-Specific Drivers: Different orbital parameters control different scales of rock cycles:
  • Long Eccentricity (400 kyr): Drives large-scale cycles (~35m thick).
  • Slope/Obliquity: Drives mesoscale cycles (~5m thick).
  • Precession: Drives small-scale cycles (~0.4m thick).
  • Climate Decoupling: Interestingly, the "theoretical" climate predicted by Earth's orbit often contradicted the "actual" basin climate (indicated by Rb/Sr and Sr/Cu ratios). This suggests that local factors—like mountains blocking rainfall or tectonic subsidence—can decouple a lake basin from global climate trends.
  • Short Eccentricity Anomaly: Unlike many marine records, the periodic change in short eccentricity correlated poorly with the lithofacies cycles in this basin, highlighting the unique sensitivity of continental rifts.

Key Results

  • 22 Lithofacies: Identified across environments ranging from shallow lakeshore slopes to deep-lake zones.
  • Three Cycle Scales: Confirmed small-scale (0.4m), mesoscale (5m), and large-scale (35m) cycles.
  • Predictive Modeling: By understanding the 55/45 control ratio, the authors suggest that geologists can better predict the distribution of high-quality shale reservoirs by looking for where astronomical "highs" overlap with favorable local geological conditions.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that their findings are specific to the Boxing Subsag, a relatively stable "gentle slope" area. In more tectonically active parts of a rift basin, the "local" control percentage (45%) might be even higher, potentially drowning out the astronomical signal entirely.

Future research could apply this dual-control analysis to other shale-rich horizons (like the $Es_3$ formation) or other continental basins globally to see if the 55/45 ratio is a universal characteristic of lacustrine rift systems or unique to the Bohai Bay Basin. This would further refine the accuracy of horizontal drilling and hydraulic fracturing designs in the shale oil industry.

Summary updated

Abstract

The shale of the upper Es4 formation (Es 4 u ), deposited during the Eocene in the Boxing Subsag of the Dongying Sag, is a typical set of lime-rich lacustrine shale in a continental rift basin. Through logging data interpretation, core and thin section observations, and geochemical elements [obtained by X radial fluorescence (XRF) mud logging] analysis, the development and controlling factors of lithofacies cycles of Es 4 u shale were analyzed. The results show that 22 types of lithofacies with typical characteristics are developed in Es 4 u , indicating the sedimentary environments, such as lower lakeshore (LL) slope zone; upper, middle, and lower shallow-lake slope zones; semi-deep-lake zone; and deep-lake zone. Lithofacies cycles in three scales are recognized in Es 4 u : small-scale lithofacies cycles indicated by alternate development of two lithofacies, mesoscale lithofacies cycles indicated by the repetition of lithofacies associations or regular variation of multiple lithofacies, and large-scale lithofacies cycles indicated by regular variation of well logging curves, which have the average thickness of approximately 0.4, 5, and 35 m, respectively. According to the vertical variation of astronomical parameters and lithofacies cycles, the periodic change in long eccentricity has a close relationship with the large-scale lithofacies cycle, the periodic change in slope is closely relative to the mesoscale lithofacies cycle, and the periodic change in precession is closely related to small-scale lithofacies cycle. However, the periodic change in short eccentricity correlates poorly with lithofacies cycles. The climate change reflected by long eccentricity and slope is quite distinct from the actual basin climate reflected by the paleoclimatic parameters (e.g., Rb/Sr and Sr/Cu), indicating that the basin paleoclimate was greatly influenced by the paleogeological conditions. For shale in Es 4 u of the Boxing Subsag, approximately 55% of the shale stratigraphic record is dominantly controlled by the astronomical climate and 45% by the paleogeological conditions. Affected by the paleogeological conditions, large-scale and mesoscale lithofacies cycles are different in lithofacies types and superimposition patterns, and just small-scale lithofacies cycles are found repetitive vertically. These findings suggest that the lithofacies cycles of shale in a continental rift basin are a product of astronomical driving mechanism (Milankovitch forcing) and variation of local paleogeological conditions, which is apparently different from the sedimentary record of marine shale that is evidently controlled by the Milankovitch cycle. Therefore, the lithofacies cycles should be comprehensively analyzed under the background of actual basin paleoclimate.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{fang2023development,
  author = {Zhengwei Fang and Liqiang Zhang and Cunfei Ma},
  title = {{Development and controlling factors of shale lithofacies cycles in a continental rift basin: A case study of Es4u in the Boxing Subsag of Dongying Sag, Bohai Bay Basin, China}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Earth Science},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3389/feart.2023.1136012},
}

Loading related content...

Figure