Development analysis of American directed energy maneuver short-range air defense program

Yi Heng-yu, Suo Xingwen, Yi Xinyi, Qi Yu, 军事科学院国防科技创新研究院,北京 100071, 复旦大学 化学系,上海 200438Journal of Applied Optics 2024 · DOI

Abstract

The US Army's Directed Energy Maneuver Short-Range Air Defense (DE M-SHORAD) program is a high-priority modernization effort aimed at countering asymmetric threats like drones and rockets. This paper analyzes the program's development, from 2-5 kW experimental prototypes (MEHEL) to 50 kW combat-ready systems (MMHEL) integrated onto Stryker vehicles. Performance modeling indicates that increasing power to 50 kW extends the effective range against drones from 0.77 km to approximately 4.8 km.

Introduction: The Asymmetric Threat

Modern battlefields are increasingly plagued by "asymmetric" threats: cheap, mass-produced drones (UAS) and rockets, artillery, and mortar (RAM) fire. Traditional air defense systems rely on expensive interceptor missiles that can cost hundreds of thousands of dollars per shot—a losing economic proposition against a $500 drone. The DE M-SHORAD program aims to solve this by providing "infinite" ammunition and a low cost-per-shot through directed energy.

Program Strategy: From MEHEL to MMHEL

The US Army adopted a two-phase development strategy to mitigate technical risk and accelerate deployment:

  1. MEHEL (Mobile Experimental High-Energy Laser): A 2 kW to 5 kW system used as a technology demonstrator to develop tactics, techniques, and procedures (TTPs).
  2. MMHEL (Multi-Mission High-Energy Laser): A 50 kW combat-ready system designed for actual deployment, integrating industrial fiber lasers and precision beam directors onto the Stryker platform.
The Stryker vehicle serves as the mobile platform for the DE M-SHORAD system, providing protection and mobility.

Technical Performance and Integration

By utilizing "off-the-shelf" industrial fiber lasers, the program significantly accelerated its development timeline. Performance modeling using unified far-field power density formulas reveals a massive expansion in the defensive capability as power scales. The effective range against composite-material drones increases from less than 1 km with the 5 kW MEHEL to nearly 5 km with the 50 kW MMHEL.

During field exercises like MFIX-16, early prototypes demonstrated high lethality, successfully neutralizing 21 out of 23 rotary-wing drones. The system successfully integrates a 50 kW laser, multi-spectral targeting systems, and Ku-band radar into a single mobile unit.

The DE-01 prototype demonstrates the integration of high-energy laser systems onto a tactical vehicle.

Future Challenges and Scaling

While 50 kW is effective against drones, destroying incoming mortar shells and rockets (RAM) remains a challenge due to their high speed and hardened casings. Future iterations, such as the Indirect Fire Protection Capability-High Energy Laser (IFPC-HEL), aim for 300 kW power levels. Additionally, the lack of advanced adaptive optics in current tactical units makes them highly susceptible to atmospheric turbulence, which remains a primary limiting factor for laser effectiveness at ranges beyond 3.2 km.

Summary updated

Abstract

美国定向能机动近程防空(directed energy maneuver-short range air defense,DE M-SHORAD)计划通过击伤、摧毁或压制旋转翼无人机、固定翼无人机以及火箭弹、火炮炮弹、迫击炮弹(rockets, artillery and mortar,RAM)等威胁目标,为机动部队提供伴随防空,对抗新兴威胁,属于美国陆军防空反导现代化的优先项目之一。首先介绍了DE M-SHORAD研制计划;其次详细分析了系统结构,并由系统参数评估了系统的作战性能;最后梳理了系统的研制进展。通过综合分析可知,DE M-SHORAD系统采用最佳组件,通过快速原型方法实现激光武器系统在装甲车上的集成;为降低技术风险,该计划在发展方式上分为两个阶段,首先集成、测试2 kW~5 kW机动实验型高能激光器(mobile experimental high-energy laser,MEHEL),然后再研制50 kW级的多任务高能激光器(multi-mission high-energy laser,MMHEL)。经计算可得:MEHEL和MMHEL对无人机的最大射程分别约为0.77 km、4.8 km。
BibTeX
@article{hengyu2024development,
  author = {YI Heng-yu and SUO Xingwen and YI Xinyi and Qi Yu and QI Yu and 军事科学院国防科技创新研究院,北京 100071 and 复旦大学 化学系,上海 200438},
  title = {{Development analysis of American directed energy maneuver short-range air defense program}},
  journal = {Journal of Applied Optics},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.5768/jao202445.0310001},
}
Figure