Developing Socio-Techno-Economic-Political (STEP) Solutions for Addressing Resource Nexus Hotspots

Bassel Daher, Rabi H. Mohtar, Efstratios N. Pistikopoulos, Kent E. Portney, Ronald A. Kaiser, Walid SaadSustainability 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper argues that addressing global water, energy, and food (WEF) "hotspots" requires a holistic approach that considers not just the biophysical interdependencies but also the socio-economic and political dimensions. They propose an iterative 3-Filter framework (STEP) to vet proposed solutions, ensuring they are technically feasible, socially acceptable, and politically/financially viable.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The world faces increasing demands for water, energy, and food, exacerbated by their complex interdependencies. These interdependencies create "hotspots" – regions or sectors under significant stress due to resource allocation challenges. Traditional approaches often tackle these resources in isolation, failing to account for their interconnectedness and the diverse stakeholders involved. This leads to fragmented solutions that may not be sustainable or effective. The paper aims to bridge this gap by providing a framework for developing comprehensive, multi-dimensional solutions that consider the biophysical, socio-economic, and political aspects of resource management.

Methods

The paper introduces a conceptual framework called the "Socio-Techno-Economic-Political (STEP)" approach. This framework is operationalized through an iterative "3-Filter" process for vetting proposed resource allocation scenarios:

  • Filter I: Resources Interaction and Trade-offs: Assesses the physical resource constraints and interdependencies. It asks if proposed scenarios are within the limits of available water, land, financial, and human capital, considering their multi-dimensional nature (e.g., water quality, spatial distribution, not just volume).
  • Filter II: Stakeholder Interaction and Trade-offs: Examines the roles, goals, power dynamics, and interactions of various stakeholders (government, business, society). It evaluates the feasibility of scenarios based on stakeholder acceptance and potential conflicts.
  • Filter III: Mobilizing Nexus Interventions (Governance and Financing): Focuses on the governance structures and financing schemes required for implementation. It checks if the proposed solutions are politically coherent and financially sustainable.

The framework is iterative, allowing for feedback loops between filters to refine scenarios.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper is a conceptual commentary and framework proposal, not an empirical study with specific datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Resource systems are multidimensional: Water, energy, and food are not just interconnected but also have multiple dimensions beyond their basic units (e.g., water's spatial distribution, quality, and temporal availability; food's source, nutritional value; energy's source, spatial footprint).
  • Players are equally multidimensional: Stakeholders (government, business, society) have diverse goals, value systems, and decision-making powers that influence resource management.
  • Interactions are complex and cross-scale: Decisions made within one resource system or by one player can have ripple effects across others and at different scales (local to global).
  • Policy incoherence is a major challenge: Conflicting policies across different scales and sectors can undermine resource management efforts.
  • A holistic framework is essential: Addressing WEF hotspots requires integrating technical, economic, social, and political considerations. The STEP framework provides a structured way to do this.
  • Iterative vetting is crucial: Proposed solutions must be rigorously tested against resource constraints, stakeholder realities, and governance/financing feasibility.

Key Results

Not applicable, as this paper presents a conceptual framework rather than empirical results from a specific study. The "result" is the proposed 3-Filter STEP framework itself, designed to guide the development and vetting of WEF nexus solutions.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Tool Compatibility: The paper acknowledges that while many tools exist for analyzing aspects of the WEF nexus, their incompatibility in terms of inputs, outputs, and scales can hinder integrative assessment.
  • Quantification Challenges: Accurately quantifying interactions between players and resource systems across scales remains a challenge.
  • Context-Specific Solutions: The authors emphasize that there is "no one size tool that fits all." Solutions must be localized and contextualized, requiring tailored assessments.
  • Future Work: The paper suggests the need for further investigation and quantification of critical questions through case studies at different scales and environments. It also calls for refining approaches to address complex resource hotspots and enabling more effective achievement of Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). The framework itself is presented as a guide for collaboration among analysts, modelers, engineers, and researchers.

Summary updated

Abstract

The challenge of meeting increasing water, energy, and food needs is linked not only to growing demands globally, but also to the growing interdependency between these interconnected resource systems. Pressures on these systems will emerge to become hotspots with different characteristics, and will require a fresh look at the challenges existing both within each of the resource systems and at their respective interfaces. Proposing solutions to address different resource hotspots must be multi-faceted and need to acknowledge the multiple dimensions of the biophysical water, energy, and food systems, and the players connected with them. This commentary first explores the multiple dimensions of water, energy, and food systems as these relate to government, business, and society. It then identifies contemporary critical questions at the interface of these stressed resource systems. A 3-Filter framework is then introduced for vetting the feasibility of proposed resource allocation scenarios and to account for the bio-physical resource interactions and trade-offs, the stakeholder interactions and trade-offs, and to address governance and financing schemes for carrying forward the implementation of those scenarios.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{daher2018developing,
  author = {Bassel Daher and Rabi H. Mohtar and Efstratios N. Pistikopoulos and Kent E. Portney and Ronald A. Kaiser and Walid Saad},
  title = {{Developing Socio-Techno-Economic-Political (STEP) Solutions for Addressing Resource Nexus Hotspots}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.3390/su10020512},
}
Figure