Developing NMR methods for macromolecular machines: Measurement of residual dipolar couplings to probe dynamic regions of the ribosome

Xiaolin Wang, John Kirkpatrick, Hélène Launay, Alfonso De Simone, Daniel Häußinger, Christopher M. Dobson, Michele Vendruscolo, Lisa D. Cabrita, Christopher A. Waudby, John ChristodouloubioRxiv 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a novel NMR approach using residual dipolar couplings (RDCs) to map the dynamic structural regions of the large, complex bacterial ribosome. By aligning intact ribosomes and measuring RDCs on the bL12 protein, the researchers refined its structure and gained insights into the flexibility of its linker region, paving the way for studying even more complex molecular machines.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The ribosome, the cell's protein synthesis machinery, is a massive and intricate macromolecular complex. While techniques like X-ray crystallography and cryo-electron microscopy (cryo-EM) have provided high-resolution static snapshots of ribosomes, they often struggle to capture the dynamic and flexible regions crucial for their function. Specifically, the GTPase-associated region (GAR) of the ribosome, which plays a key role in translation factor recruitment and GTPase activity, contains flexible elements like the bL12 protein's C-terminal domain (CTD) connected by a disordered linker. This flexibility has made it difficult to fully characterize its structure and dynamics using traditional methods. Solution-state NMR spectroscopy offers a powerful alternative for studying such dynamic regions, but applying it to large complexes like intact ribosomes presents significant challenges. This paper aims to overcome these challenges by developing and applying an NMR method to probe the dynamic structural properties of the ribosome, focusing on the bL12 protein.

Methods

The core of this study lies in the application and development of Residual Dipolar Couplings (RDCs) for structural and motional analysis of the intact 70S ribosome.

  • Alignment of Intact Ribosomes: To measure RDCs, the ribosomes need to be weakly aligned in solution. The researchers successfully achieved this using Pf1 filamentous bacteriophage as an alignment medium. They explored other media but found them unsuitable due to precipitation or interference with ribosome structure.
  • RDC Measurement: RDCs were measured for the bL12 protein, both when bound to the ribosome (bL12ribo) and in isolation (bL12free). This involved acquiring ¹H,¹⁵N HSQC and TROSY spectra under both isotropic and aligned conditions. The difference in spectral splittings between these conditions yields the RDC values. The authors note that this approach provided high precision for amide RDCs.
  • Structure Refinement: The measured RDCs were used to refine the existing 3D structure of the bL12 CTD. This was done using Xplor-NIH with a simulating-annealing molecular-dynamics simulation, incorporating an additional term in the force field that accounts for the difference between experimental and back-calculated RDCs. This refinement focused on optimizing the orientation of secondary structure elements.
  • Paramagnetic Alignment: To further investigate the flexibility of the linker region connecting the N-terminal domain (NTD) and CTD of bL12, a lanthanide-binding tag (LBT) was introduced via a surface mutation (S89C) in the CTD. This allowed for paramagnetic alignment, where the lanthanide ion's magnetic susceptibility induces alignment. By using mixed ¹⁵N/LBT labeling, the researchers could distinguish between direct and indirectly propagated alignment through the linker, providing insights into its flexibility.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study utilizes existing structural data (PDB code: 1rqu) for the bL12 protein as a template for refinement.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • RDCs are feasible for large, dynamic complexes: The study demonstrates that RDCs can be successfully measured even for a massive complex like the 2.4 MDa 70S ribosome, opening doors for studying other challenging macromolecular machines.
  • Ribosome constrains bL12 orientation: The RDC data revealed a subtle but significant difference in the preferred orientation of the bL12 CTD when bound to the ribosome compared to when it's free. This suggests that the ribosome core particle exerts a constraining effect on the bL12 linker region, implying it's not entirely freely flexible.
  • Linker flexibility is quantifiable: The paramagnetic alignment experiments provided a quantitative measure (order parameter S² = 0.14±0.05) of the coupling and flexibility through the bL12 linker. This experimentally determined value aligns well with predictions from an optimized ensemble model, suggesting a specific type of motion (anti-correlated extension and retraction of CTDs) that could be functionally important for factor recruitment.
  • Validation of structural ensembles: The RDC data provided experimental validation for a structural ensemble of bL12 previously derived from SAXS and NMR relaxation measurements, reinforcing the utility of these complementary techniques.

Key Results

  • RDCs were successfully measured for the CTD of ribosome-bound bL12 (bL12ribo) with an RMS uncertainty of 1.8 Hz.
  • Structure refinement using RDCs resulted in small but significant changes, with Ca RMSDs of 0.35 Å for bL12ribo and 0.52 Å for bL12free relative to the template structure. Q factors improved to 0.24 and 0.18, respectively.
  • Paramagnetic alignment experiments indicated that alignment is propagated through the bL12 linker region, with an order parameter S² = 0.14±0.05, consistent with an optimized ensemble model.
  • A slight but significant difference in the orientation of the alignment tensor between free and ribosome-bound bL12 was observed (a 5D angle of 13.8 ± 7.6°).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited refinement due to single alignment medium: The RDC measurements were performed in only one alignment medium, which restricted structure refinement to secondary structure elements. The authors suggest that using multiple alignment media would allow for more comprehensive refinement.
  • Challenges with other domains: While RDCs were obtained for bL12, the study notes that obtaining precise results for other atoms (C' and Ca) was limited by sensitivity.
  • Future Directions: The paper highlights the potential of this approach for characterizing dynamical and functional regions of more challenging macromolecular machines, specifically mentioning ribosome-nascent chain complexes. This opens up avenues for studying co-translational folding and the dynamic interplay between nascent polypeptides and the ribosome. The study also lays the groundwork for detailed characterization of modified bL12 variants.

Summary updated

Abstract

ABSTRACT We describe an NMR approach based on the measurement of residual dipolar couplings (RDCs) to probe the structural and motional properties of the dynamic regions of the ribosome. Alignment of intact 70S ribosomes in filamentous bacteriophage enabled measurement of RDCs in the stalk protein bL12, and this information was used to refine a 3D structure of its C-terminal domain (CTD). Orientational constraints on the CTD alignment arising from the semiflexible linker sequence were further probed by a paramagnetic alignment strategy, and provided direct experimental validation of a structural ensemble previously derived from SAXS and NMR relaxation measurements. Our results demonstrate the prospect of better characterising dynamical and functional regions of more challenging macromolecular machines and systems, for example ribosome–nascent chain complexes.
BibTeX
@misc{wang2018developing,
  author = {Xiaolin Wang and John Kirkpatrick and Hélène Launay and Alfonso De Simone and Daniel Häußinger and Christopher M. Dobson and Michele Vendruscolo and Lisa D. Cabrita and Christopher A. Waudby and John Christodoulou},
  title = {{Developing NMR methods for macromolecular machines: Measurement of residual dipolar couplings to probe dynamic regions of the ribosome}},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1101/319251},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure