Developing new analysis tools for near surface radio-based neutrino detectors

A. Anker, Pierre Baldi, S. W. Barwick, Jakob Beise, D. Z. Besson, Pisin Chen, Geoffrey Gaswint, Christian Gläser, A. Hallgren, J. Hanson, S. R. Klein, S. Kleinfelder, R. Lahmann, J. Liu, J. W. Nam, A. Nelles, Manuel P. Paul, Christopher Persichilli, Ilse Plaisier, Ryan Rice-Smith, J. Tatar, K. Terveer, Shih‐Hao Wang, L.r. ZhaoJournal of Cosmology and Astroparticle Physics 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces novel analysis techniques, including physics-based "cuts" and a deep learning approach, to significantly improve the detection efficiency and background rejection for ultra-high-energy neutrinos using radio antennas in Antarctic ice. These advancements are crucial for future large-scale neutrino observatories like IceCube-Gen2, demonstrating that near-surface antennas can meet stringent performance requirements.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Detecting ultra-high-energy (UHE) neutrinos (above 10¹⁶ eV) is incredibly challenging due to their extremely low flux. These neutrinos interact with matter (like Antarctic ice) to produce cascades of particles, which in turn emit radio Cherenkov radiation. The ARIANNA experiment aims to detect this faint radio signal. However, the raw data captured by the detector is heavily contaminated with background noise. The challenge is to develop sophisticated analysis tools that can reliably distinguish the rare neutrino signals from this overwhelming background, especially as future detectors aim for much larger target volumes and thus require even greater background rejection capabilities.

Methods

The paper presents three main analysis "cuts" (selection criteria) to identify neutrino events:

  • Updown Cut: This physics-based cut leverages the directional sensitivity of the antennas. Neutrino signals originating from below the ice surface (expected for neutrino interactions) tend to have a different amplitude ratio in upward-facing versus downward-facing antennas compared to background events (like wind-induced noise) that originate from above the surface.
  • Dipole Cut: This cut utilizes the unique "double pulse" signature expected from neutrino interactions. When a neutrino interacts deep within the ice, it produces a radio pulse. This pulse can reflect off the firn-air interface, creating a second, delayed pulse. This cut analyzes the timing and amplitude ratio of these two pulses using a buried dipole antenna.
  • Deep Learning Cut: A convolutional neural network (CNN) is trained to classify events. The network takes the waveform data from multiple antenna channels as input and learns to distinguish between simulated neutrino signals and experimental background noise. This approach aims to capture complex patterns that might be missed by simpler physics-based cuts.

These cuts are applied sequentially, building upon each other to progressively reduce background while retaining neutrino signal.

Datasets

The study utilizes several datasets:

  • Simulated Neutrino Data (S-NU61): Generated using NuRadioMC, simulating expected neutrino events for the ARIANNA detector.
  • Experimental Background Data (E-BG61): Real data collected by ARIANNA station 61, primarily consisting of thermal noise, wind-generated noise, and electronic noise.
  • Simulated Cosmic Ray Data (S-CR52): Generated using CoREAS, simulating cosmic ray air showers.
  • Experimental Cosmic Ray Data (E-CR52): Real data from a dedicated cosmic ray station, used for validation.
  • Experimental Background Data (E-BG52): Real data from the cosmic ray station, used as background for cosmic ray analysis.

The paper also mentions the use of a previously developed LPDA waveform template cut.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Leveraging Antenna Diversity: The ARIANNA station's expanded configuration with upward-facing antennas and dipole antennas provides crucial new information that significantly enhances background rejection beyond previous analyses.
  • Physics-Based Intuition Works: The "updown" and "dipole" cuts, rooted in the expected physical signatures of neutrino interactions and background sources, are highly effective on their own.
  • Deep Learning's Power: The deep learning approach demonstrates a remarkable ability to reject background events, significantly outperforming the combined physics-based cuts in terms of the number of events rejected for a similar signal efficiency.
  • Simulation Validity: The validation using cosmic ray data shows that the deep learning model does not rely on artificial differences between simulated and experimental data, increasing confidence in its performance for neutrino detection.
  • Future Detector Readiness: The achieved efficiencies and background rejection levels meet or exceed the requirements for the baseline design of future large-scale neutrino detectors like IceCube-Gen2.

Key Results

  • Combined Physics Cuts (Updown + Dipole + LPDA): Achieve a neutrino efficiency of >95% per station-year, reducing background events to approximately 1 per 1,000 station-years. Extrapolated to 1,000 station-years, this yields a 91% overall efficiency.
  • Deep Learning Cut: Achieves 99% signal efficiency per station-year, rejecting 99.997% of background events (leaving only 2 misclassified events). When combined with the waveform template cut, all background is removed with no significant loss in neutrino efficiency.
  • Deep Learning vs. Physics Cuts: The deep learning method rejects over 25 times more background events than the combined updown and dipole cuts for the same neutrino signal efficiency.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Cosmic Ray Identification: While the cosmic ray study validates the deep learning approach, it notes that the current model does not achieve highly efficient identification of cosmic rays themselves. Further studies and more complex models are needed for real-time cosmic ray identification.
  • Template Model Simplification: The dipole template generation relies on simplified assumptions about plane waves and a perfect snow surface mirror, which can lead to slight inaccuracies in amplitude ratio prediction.
  • Optimization of Cuts: Future work will focus on optimizing the thresholds for all cuts, including the deep learning cut, and exploring the statistical independence of different cut combinations.
  • Broader Astrophysical Spectra: The analysis is based on a specific model of the cosmogenic diffuse neutrino flux. Future work will involve broadening the analysis to include other astrophysical spectra and transient point source searches.
  • Lower SNR Events: The current analysis focuses on events with a signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) of 4.4. Future work aims to extend the analysis to events with lower SNR, potentially increasing efficiency.
  • Real-time Triggering: The paper suggests that incorporating deep learning methods directly into real-time triggers could significantly reduce trigger thresholds and increase sensitivity, a promising avenue for future detector designs.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract The ARIANNA experiment is an Askaryan radio detector designed to measure high-energy neutrino induced cascades within the Antarctic ice. Ultra-high-energy neutrinos above 10 16 eV have an extremely low flux, so experimental data captured at trigger level need to be classified correctly to retain as much neutrino signal as possible. We first describe two new physics-based neutrino selection methods, or “cuts”, (the updown and dipole cut) that extend the previously published analysis to a specialized ARIANNA station with 8 antenna channels, which is double the number used in the prior analysis. For a standard trigger with a threshold signal to noise ratio at 4.4, the new cuts produce a neutrino efficiency of > 95% per station-year of operation, while rejecting 99.93% of the background (corresponding to 53 remaining experimental background events). When the new cuts are combined with a previously developed cut using neutrino waveform templates, all background is removed at no change of efficiency. In addition, the neutrino efficiency is extrapolated to 1,000 station-years of operation, obtaining 91%. This work then introduces a new selection method (the deep learning cut) to augment the identification of neutrino events by using deep learning methods and compares the efficiency to the physics-based analysis. The deep learning cut gives 99% signal efficiency per station-year of operation while rejecting 99.997% of the background (corresponding to 2 remaining experimental background events), which are subsequently removed by the waveform template cut at no significant change in efficiency. The results of the deep learning cut were verified using measured cosmic rays which shows that the simulations do not introduce artifacts with respect to experimental data. The paper demonstrates that the background rejection and signal efficiency of near surface antennas meets the requirements of a large scale future array, as considered in baseline design of the radio component of IceCube-Gen2.
BibTeX
@article{anker2023developing,
  author = {A. Anker and Pierre Baldi and S. W. Barwick and Jakob Beise and D. Z. Besson and Pisin Chen and Geoffrey Gaswint and Christian Gläser and A. Hallgren and J. Hanson and S. R. Klein and S. Kleinfelder and R. Lahmann and J. Liu and J. W. Nam and A. Nelles and Manuel P. Paul and Christopher Persichilli and Ilse Plaisier and Ryan Rice-Smith and J. Tatar and K. Terveer and Shih‐Hao Wang and L.R. Zhao},
  title = {{Developing new analysis tools for near surface radio-based neutrino detectors}},
  journal = {Journal of Cosmology and Astroparticle Physics},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1088/1475-7516/2023/10/060},
}
Figure