TL;DR
Researchers at CIAE have successfully developed a highly sensitive method for measuring the long-lived radioisotope ⁵⁹Ni using Accelerator Mass Spectrometry (AMS). This new technique, employing a ΔE-Q3D detection system, significantly improves the ability to distinguish ⁵⁹Ni from its interfering isobar ⁵⁹Co, achieving a suppression factor of 10⁷ and a detection sensitivity as low as 3.8 × 10⁻¹³ (⁵⁹Ni/Ni). This advancement is crucial for applications in radioactive waste management, cosmic radiation studies, and astrophysics.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Measuring the radioisotope ⁵⁹Ni is challenging due to its long half-life (76,000 years) and its decay mode (pure electron capture), which makes traditional decay counting methods ineffective. Accelerator Mass Spectrometry (AMS) is the only viable technique for detecting ⁵⁹Ni at low concentrations. However, a major hurdle in AMS for ⁵⁹Ni is the presence of its stable isobar, ⁵⁹Co. Even after chemical purification, ⁵⁹Co can remain at levels that significantly interfere with ⁵⁹Ni measurements. This paper addresses the critical need for a robust AMS system capable of effectively separating ⁵⁹Ni from ⁵⁹Co to achieve high sensitivity and accurate measurements.
Methods
The core of the developed method relies on the combination of a HI-13 tandem accelerator and a newly designed ΔE-Q3D (energy loss - energy) detection system.
- Accelerator: The HI-13 tandem accelerator is used to accelerate the ions to high energies.
- ΔE-Q3D Detection System: This system is the key innovation. It consists of:
- Absorber: A thin foil (Si₃N₄) is placed at the entrance of the Q3D magnetic spectrometer. Isobars passing through this foil lose different amounts of energy based on their charge state after stripping, leading to a separation based on their residual energies.
- Q3D Magnetic Spectrometer: This device separates ions based on their magnetic rigidity (momentum-to-charge ratio). By exploiting the energy differences introduced by the absorber, the spectrometer can spatially separate ⁵⁹Ni and ⁵⁹Co at its focal plane.
- Multi-anode Gas Ionization Chamber: Positioned at the focal plane, this detector further identifies particles by measuring their energy loss (ΔE) and total energy (E). The differences in energy loss between ⁵⁹Ni and ⁵⁹Co in the gas provide a crucial second layer of identification.
- Simultaneous Measurement: To account for beam current fluctuations, a simultaneous measurement of a stable Ni isotope (⁵⁸Ni or ⁶⁰Ni) is employed using offset Faraday cups. This allows for real-time normalization of the ⁵⁹Ni counts.
Datasets
The study utilized:
- Laboratory Standard Samples: Two standard samples (Ni-S-1 and Ni-S-2) with known ⁵⁹Ni/Ni atomic ratios, produced by irradiating natural Ni with thermal neutrons and subsequent chemical dilution.
- Commercial NiO Blank Sample: Used to determine the background level of ⁵⁹Co.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Isobaric Interference is the Primary Challenge: The paper strongly emphasizes that the presence of ⁵⁹Co is the main obstacle to achieving high sensitivity in ⁵⁹Ni AMS.
- Energy Loss as a Key Separator: The novel approach leverages the differential energy loss of ⁵⁹Ni and ⁵⁹Co after passing through a thin absorber. This energy difference, combined with magnetic separation, is crucial for their spatial separation.
- Multi-stage Identification is Essential: Relying on a single separation method is insufficient. The combination of magnetic separation, energy loss measurement (ΔE), and total energy measurement (E) in the ΔE-Q3D system provides a powerful tool for particle identification and background suppression.
- Simultaneous Measurement for Accuracy: The development of a simultaneous measurement technique for stable Ni isotopes addresses the issue of beam current instability, leading to more reliable atomic ratio determinations.
Key Results
- ⁵⁹Co Suppression: The ΔE-Q3D detection system achieved a suppression factor of over 500 for ⁵⁹Co ions within the detector itself.
- Overall Suppression: When combined with the upstream separation and identification stages, an overall suppression factor of approximately 10⁷ for ⁵⁹Co was achieved.
- Detection Sensitivity: This high suppression enabled a detection sensitivity as low as 3.8 × 10⁻¹³ atomic ratio (⁵⁹Ni/Ni).
- Standard Sample Measurements: The normalized atomic ratios for the laboratory standards were measured with good precision, with Ni-S-1 yielding (2.02±0.12)×10⁻⁹ and Ni-S-2 yielding (2.74±0.21)×10⁻¹¹.
- Blank Sample Background: The background level from the blank sample was determined to be 3.8×10⁻¹³ atomic ratio (⁵⁹Ni/Ni).
Limitations and Future Work
- Limitations: While significant progress has been made, the paper acknowledges that further reduction of ⁵⁹Co interference is key to improving sensitivity. The current detection sensitivity is 3.8 × 10⁻¹³, and the goal is to reach 10⁻¹⁴.
- Future Work: The authors plan to:
- Investigate more comprehensive chemical procedures for removing ⁵⁹Co from sample materials.
- Reduce the entrance window size of the gas ionization chamber to 75×40 mm² to further suppress ⁵⁹Co background while retaining approximately 80% of ⁵⁹Ni events.
- Based on these improvements, they expect to achieve a detection sensitivity of 10⁻¹⁴ for the ⁵⁹Ni/Ni atomic ratio.
- Apply the developed AMS measurement method to various research applications.
Summary updated