Developing AMS measurement of 59 Ni at CIAE

Ming He, Wei Wang, Xiangdong Ruan, Chaoli Li, Kejun Dong, Liang Dou, Linbo Xie, Zhenyu Li, Guo-Wen Zhen, Hao Hu, Jiancheng Liu, Shan JiangChinese 2013 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers at CIAE have successfully developed a highly sensitive method for measuring the long-lived radioisotope ⁵⁹Ni using Accelerator Mass Spectrometry (AMS). This new technique, employing a ΔE-Q3D detection system, significantly improves the ability to distinguish ⁵⁹Ni from its interfering isobar ⁵⁹Co, achieving a suppression factor of 10⁷ and a detection sensitivity as low as 3.8 × 10⁻¹³ (⁵⁹Ni/Ni). This advancement is crucial for applications in radioactive waste management, cosmic radiation studies, and astrophysics.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Measuring the radioisotope ⁵⁹Ni is challenging due to its long half-life (76,000 years) and its decay mode (pure electron capture), which makes traditional decay counting methods ineffective. Accelerator Mass Spectrometry (AMS) is the only viable technique for detecting ⁵⁹Ni at low concentrations. However, a major hurdle in AMS for ⁵⁹Ni is the presence of its stable isobar, ⁵⁹Co. Even after chemical purification, ⁵⁹Co can remain at levels that significantly interfere with ⁵⁹Ni measurements. This paper addresses the critical need for a robust AMS system capable of effectively separating ⁵⁹Ni from ⁵⁹Co to achieve high sensitivity and accurate measurements.

Methods

The core of the developed method relies on the combination of a HI-13 tandem accelerator and a newly designed ΔE-Q3D (energy loss - energy) detection system.

  • Accelerator: The HI-13 tandem accelerator is used to accelerate the ions to high energies.
  • ΔE-Q3D Detection System: This system is the key innovation. It consists of:
  • Absorber: A thin foil (Si₃N₄) is placed at the entrance of the Q3D magnetic spectrometer. Isobars passing through this foil lose different amounts of energy based on their charge state after stripping, leading to a separation based on their residual energies.
  • Q3D Magnetic Spectrometer: This device separates ions based on their magnetic rigidity (momentum-to-charge ratio). By exploiting the energy differences introduced by the absorber, the spectrometer can spatially separate ⁵⁹Ni and ⁵⁹Co at its focal plane.
  • Multi-anode Gas Ionization Chamber: Positioned at the focal plane, this detector further identifies particles by measuring their energy loss (ΔE) and total energy (E). The differences in energy loss between ⁵⁹Ni and ⁵⁹Co in the gas provide a crucial second layer of identification.
  • Simultaneous Measurement: To account for beam current fluctuations, a simultaneous measurement of a stable Ni isotope (⁵⁸Ni or ⁶⁰Ni) is employed using offset Faraday cups. This allows for real-time normalization of the ⁵⁹Ni counts.

Datasets

The study utilized:

  • Laboratory Standard Samples: Two standard samples (Ni-S-1 and Ni-S-2) with known ⁵⁹Ni/Ni atomic ratios, produced by irradiating natural Ni with thermal neutrons and subsequent chemical dilution.
  • Commercial NiO Blank Sample: Used to determine the background level of ⁵⁹Co.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Isobaric Interference is the Primary Challenge: The paper strongly emphasizes that the presence of ⁵⁹Co is the main obstacle to achieving high sensitivity in ⁵⁹Ni AMS.
  • Energy Loss as a Key Separator: The novel approach leverages the differential energy loss of ⁵⁹Ni and ⁵⁹Co after passing through a thin absorber. This energy difference, combined with magnetic separation, is crucial for their spatial separation.
  • Multi-stage Identification is Essential: Relying on a single separation method is insufficient. The combination of magnetic separation, energy loss measurement (ΔE), and total energy measurement (E) in the ΔE-Q3D system provides a powerful tool for particle identification and background suppression.
  • Simultaneous Measurement for Accuracy: The development of a simultaneous measurement technique for stable Ni isotopes addresses the issue of beam current instability, leading to more reliable atomic ratio determinations.

Key Results

  • ⁵⁹Co Suppression: The ΔE-Q3D detection system achieved a suppression factor of over 500 for ⁵⁹Co ions within the detector itself.
  • Overall Suppression: When combined with the upstream separation and identification stages, an overall suppression factor of approximately 10⁷ for ⁵⁹Co was achieved.
  • Detection Sensitivity: This high suppression enabled a detection sensitivity as low as 3.8 × 10⁻¹³ atomic ratio (⁵⁹Ni/Ni).
  • Standard Sample Measurements: The normalized atomic ratios for the laboratory standards were measured with good precision, with Ni-S-1 yielding (2.02±0.12)×10⁻⁹ and Ni-S-2 yielding (2.74±0.21)×10⁻¹¹.
  • Blank Sample Background: The background level from the blank sample was determined to be 3.8×10⁻¹³ atomic ratio (⁵⁹Ni/Ni).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations: While significant progress has been made, the paper acknowledges that further reduction of ⁵⁹Co interference is key to improving sensitivity. The current detection sensitivity is 3.8 × 10⁻¹³, and the goal is to reach 10⁻¹⁴.
  • Future Work: The authors plan to:
  • Investigate more comprehensive chemical procedures for removing ⁵⁹Co from sample materials.
  • Reduce the entrance window size of the gas ionization chamber to 75×40 mm² to further suppress ⁵⁹Co background while retaining approximately 80% of ⁵⁹Ni events.
  • Based on these improvements, they expect to achieve a detection sensitivity of 10⁻¹⁴ for the ⁵⁹Ni/Ni atomic ratio.
  • Apply the developed AMS measurement method to various research applications.

Summary updated

Abstract

Accelerator mass spectrometry (AMS) measurement of 59Ni has been established at CIAE with the HI-13 tandem accelerator and the recently developed ΔE-Q3D detection system. 59Ni standard and commercial NiO samples were measured to check the performance of the ΔE-Q3D detection system on 59Ni isobar separation and suppression. An overall suppression factor of about 107 for the interfering isobar 59Co resulting in detection sensitivity as low as 3.8 × 10 -13 atomic ratio (59Ni/Ni) has been obtained. Based on these techniques, the AMS measurement method of 59Ni with high sensitivity is developed. © 2013 Chinese Physical Society and the Institute of High Energy Physics of the Chinese Academy of Sciences and the Institute of Modern Physics of the Chinese Academy of Sciences and IOP Publishing Ltd. © 2013 Chinese Physical Society.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{he2013developing,
  author = {Ming He and Wei Wang and Xiangdong Ruan and Chaoli Li and Kejun Dong and Liang Dou and Linbo Xie and Zhenyu Li and Guo-Wen ZHEN and Hao Hu and Jiancheng Liu and Shan Jiang},
  title = {{Developing AMS measurement of <sup>59</sup> Ni at CIAE}},
  booktitle = {Chinese},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.1088/1674-1137/37/5/058201},
}
Figure