Abstract
This study integrates the Technological Pedagogical Content Knowledge (TPACK) framework into a Preschool Language Education course to examine its effects on pre-service preschool teachers' instructional design competence (IDC). Using a Research and Development (R&D) methodology, the study employed an experimental design with 41 pre-service teachers at Putian University, China. The experimental group (n=21) participated in a 13-week TPACK-based course involving iterative design cycles, while the control group (n=20) received traditional instruction. Key findings indicate that the TPACK-based course significantly enhances IDC compared to traditional methods. Furthermore, the study identifies that at the early stage of professional development, IDC growth exhibits characteristics of simplification, linearity, and dogmatism.
Introduction
In the contemporary educational landscape, particularly within the Chinese context, the role of preschool teachers is undergoing a significant shift from "caregivers" to professional educators. Central to this professionalization is Instructional Design Competence (IDC). However, many pre-service teachers lack systematic design thinking and struggle to integrate modern educational technology into their lessons effectively.
The TPACK framework—which emphasizes the synergy between Content, Pedagogy, and Technology—offers a robust theoretical basis for bridging this gap.
While TPACK is well-established in primary and secondary education research, there is a notable lack of literature applying it specifically to early childhood education (ECE). This paper seeks to fill that gap by developing and testing a TPACK-based course for preschool language education.
Methods
The researchers employed an R&D methodology using a quasi-experimental design. The participants were 41 pre-service preschool teachers from the 2022 cohort at Putian University.
The Intervention
The experimental group participated in a 13-week course structured around three iterative cycles of lesson planning: Conversation, Narrative, and Literary activities. Each cycle followed a rigorous "Design -> Feedback -> Revision -> Micro-teaching -> Reflection" loop to foster deep learning and practical application.
Measurement and Validation
The course's validity was confirmed using the Item Objective Congruence (IOC) method with five experts, achieving a high score of 0.9. Data collection utilized a 36-item IDC Scale (self-reported) and a 100-point Lesson Plan Scoring Rubric (expert-evaluated). Inter-rater reliability for the rubric was high (Spearman’s rho = 0.964).
Results and Discussion
The study yielded several significant findings regarding the development of instructional competence:
Quantitative Improvement
The experimental group’s post-test IDC scores (Mean = 4.295) were significantly higher than the control group’s (Mean = 3.935), with a p-value of 0.018. Furthermore, the quality of lesson plans improved dramatically; average scores rose from a "poor" 58.2 in the first round to a "good" 79.4 in the final round.
Growth Characteristics of Novice Teachers
A qualitative analysis of the growth trajectory revealed three distinct characteristics of early-stage IDC development:
- Simplification: Novice teachers tend to focus on format and "completeness" (e.g., including the age group) over pedagogical substance.
- Linearity: Design thinking is often rigid, following steps without considering the dynamic interactions between content and technology.
- Dogmatism: There is a heavy reliance on templates and strict adherence to theoretical models before students can handle complex pedagogical nuances.
The Power of Iteration
The most significant jumps in quality occurred between the "original" and "revised" versions of lesson plans within a single cycle. This suggests that iterative feedback loops are more critical for IDC development than initial theoretical instruction alone.
Conclusion
Integrating the TPACK framework into preschool teacher training significantly improves instructional design competence. While the 13-week course provided a strong foundation, the lack of "excellent" scores (>90) highlights that true instructional expertise is a long-term professional journey. Future research should explore the longitudinal effects of this training as teachers enter the workforce and its applicability across other ECE subjects like STEM and the Arts.
Summary updated