Developing a Health-Spatial Indicator System for a Healthy City in Small and Midsized Cities

Jiemei Luo, Edwin H.w. Chan, Jinfeng Du, Linxia Feng, Peng Jiang, Ying XuInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper addresses the critical gap in "Healthy City" research, which has largely overlooked small and midsized cities (SMCs). The authors developed and validated a comprehensive health-spatial indicator system specifically for SMCs, integrating urban design and governance factors. This system highlights the paramount importance of urban form, transportation, environmental quality, and governance for promoting health in these often-underserved urban areas.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The "Healthy City" concept, aiming to improve public health through urban planning, has gained global traction. However, existing research and initiatives predominantly focus on large metropolitan areas, leaving smaller and midsized cities (SMCs) with a significant knowledge gap. This oversight contributes to health inequities, as SMCs often face unique challenges related to resource distribution, infrastructure, and governance that differ from their larger counterparts. The paper aims to bridge this gap by creating a tailored indicator system that can guide SMCs in developing healthier urban environments, considering their specific contexts and needs.

Methods

The study employed a multi-stage methodology to develop and validate its health-spatial indicator system.

  1. Systematic Literature Review: An initial review identified key factors related to urban design and Healthy Cities.
  2. Expert Consultation: A panel of 13 experts refined these factors, leading to an initial framework of 5 aspects and 39 variables, which was further adjusted to 40 variables after a pilot interview.
  3. Questionnaire Survey: A survey was administered to 281 professionals with expertise in urban design, planning, and health services.
  4. Exploratory Factor Analysis (EFA): EFA was used to identify principal components and reduce the number of variables, resulting in six key factors and 37 variables. The reliability of the survey data was confirmed with a Cronbach's alpha of 0.967 and a KMO test of 0.952.
  5. Fuzzy Synthetic Evaluation (FSE): FSE was then applied to assess the relative importance and ranking of these factors. This technique is well-suited for handling subjective expert opinions and multi-level evaluations, making it ideal for creating a composite indicator system. The FSE process involved normalization of data, calculation of membership functions, and determination of factor indices.

Datasets

The study did not utilize pre-existing datasets for training or evaluation. Instead, it generated its own data through:

  • Expert Opinions: Collected via questionnaires and interviews from 281 professionals.
  • Literature Review: A systematic review of academic articles published between 2010 and 2020 from the Web of Science database.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • SMCs Have Unique Needs: The research strongly emphasizes that a one-size-fits-all approach to Healthy Cities doesn't work. SMCs require a tailored framework that acknowledges their distinct challenges and opportunities.
  • Urban Form and Transportation are Paramount: The study's most striking finding is the critical importance of "Urban Form and Transportation" (UFT) for SMCs. This suggests that how cities are physically structured and how people move within them are foundational to health.
  • Environmental Quality and Governance are Intertwined: The close ranking of "Environmental Quality and Governance" (EQG) highlights that a healthy city requires both clean surroundings and effective leadership and citizen engagement.
  • Health-Friendly Services are Crucial, but Context-Dependent: While "Health-Friendly Service" (HFS) is vital, its importance in SMCs might stem from a need to address basic accessibility and equity issues, rather than advanced specialized care often found in larger cities.
  • Green Spaces and Biodiversity are "Neutral" but Not Unimportant: While GOS and ECB were ranked as "neutral" in importance, this doesn't mean they are unimportant. It suggests that in SMCs, these aspects might be less of a pressing concern compared to fundamental infrastructure and services, possibly due to their closer proximity to nature.

Key Results

The study identified six key factors influencing Healthy City development in SMCs, ranked by their importance index:

  1. Urban Form and Transportation (UFT): Index 5.73 (Normalized Index 0.175) - Important
  2. Environmental Quality and Governance (EQG): Index 5.69 (Normalized Index 0.174) - Important
  3. Health-Friendly Service (HFS): Index 5.69 (Normalized Index 0.174) - Important
  4. Community and Facilities (CF): Index 5.43 (Normalized Index 0.166) - Neutral
  5. Green and Open Space (GOS): Index 5.40 (Normalized Index 0.165) - Neutral
  6. Ecological Construction and Biodiversity (ECB): Index 4.85 (Normalized Index 0.148) - Neutral

The top three factors (UFT, EQG, HFS) collectively accounted for a significant portion of the variance and were deemed "important," while the remaining three were ranked as "neutral." Within UFT, transportation infrastructure, urban structure, and public transport accessibility were key variables. For EQG, safety, noise, and sanitation facilities were most prominent. Health service equity, community-level service, and public health service accessibility were key for HFS.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Flexibility of the Framework: The proposed indicator system is presented as a flexible option that can be adjusted based on local contexts and future longitudinal, empirical, and in-depth studies.
  • Interrelationships: While the study identified factor importance, it suggests that future research could explore the interrelationships among factors and variables using techniques like Bayesian network analysis or structural equation modeling.
  • Geographic Bias: Expert surveys may have a geographic bias, potentially concentrating in Asia. Future studies should aim for broader global representation and incorporate grassroots community perceptions.
  • Heterogeneity of SMCs: SMCs are diverse, and future research should consider their inner heterogeneity, different development periods, and varied challenges to provide more nuanced insights.

The paper suggests that its methodology can be applied to validate the framework in varied localized contexts with featured variables and hierarchies. Future work should also focus on understanding the real usage of spaces and the impact of dynamic urban changes on SMCs.

Summary updated

Abstract

A recent examination of the significant role of public health has prompted calls to re-investigate how the urban environment affects public health. A vital part of the solution includes Healthy City initiatives that have been the subject of extensive policies, implications, and practices globally. However, the existing literature mainly focuses on big cities and metropolitan areas, while investigations into small and midsized cities (SMCs) are lacking, and thus reflect the underlying issues of health inequity. This study develops an indicator system for evaluating Healthy City initiatives in SMCs, linking urban design and public health, supported by the analyzed opinions from experts collected using both questionnaires and interviews. The indicator system includes six primary dimensions and 37 variables: urban form and transportation (UFT); health-friendly service (HFS); environmental quality and governance (EQG); community and facility (CF); green and open space (GOS); and ecological construction and biodiversity (ECB). A fuzzy synthetic evaluation technique was used to assess the relative importance of factors, emphasizing the importance of UFT, HFS, and EQG, with importance indexes of 0.175, 0.174, and 0.174, respectively. This indicator system is helpful for SMCs seeking to construct a Healthy City in the future, and is based on urban design and governance inputs and for enhancing the Healthy City knowledge base of cities of varied scales.
BibTeX
@article{luo2022developing,
  author = {Jiemei Luo and Edwin H.W. Chan and Jinfeng Du and Linxia Feng and Peng Jiang and Ying Xu},
  title = {{Developing a Health-Spatial Indicator System for a Healthy City in Small and Midsized Cities}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph19063294},
}
Figure