Developing a graduate training program in Synthetic Biology: SynBioCDT

Idil Cazimoglu, Alexander P. S. Darlington, Aurelija Grigonyte, Charlotte E G Hoskin, Juntai Liu, Robert Oppenheimer, Jesús A. Siller‐Farfán, Claire Grierson, Antonis PapachristodoulouSynthetic 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper details the development and implementation of SynBioCDT, a UK-wide doctoral training program in synthetic biology. It highlights the program's interdisciplinary structure, covering taught modules, research rotations, and career development, while addressing the challenges of training students from diverse backgrounds in this rapidly evolving field.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Synthetic biology is a burgeoning field that integrates computational and experimental approaches across various scientific disciplines. However, typical undergraduate programs only cover a fraction of these necessary skills. The paper addresses the need for a comprehensive, interdisciplinary graduate training program to equip the next generation of leaders in synthetic biology with the broad knowledge and specialized skills required to drive innovation in this area. The challenge lies in creating a program that can effectively train students with vastly different academic backgrounds (e.g., biology, physics, math, engineering) and prepare them for both academic and industrial careers.

Methods

The SynBioCDT program employs a multi-faceted approach to graduate training:

  • Taught Modules: A 6-month intensive taught program consisting of 14 short modules covering essential and advanced topics. This includes introductory courses tailored to students' backgrounds (e.g., "Essential Mathematics" for biologists, "Cells and Systems" for physical scientists/engineers), followed by a common cohort for advanced topics.
  • Computational and Mathematical Training: A 2-week software carpentry course in C and Python, followed by MATLAB and mathematical modeling modules focusing on various biological systems.
  • Biological and Biophysical Training: Advanced modules on synthetic circuits, DNA/RNA nanostructures, metabolic and protein engineering, and genetic engineering tools. This also includes exposure to relevant software suites and visits to partner institutions.
  • Experimental Synthetic Biology Training: Hands-on training in constructing and characterizing genetic circuits and DNA nanostructures, covering molecular cloning, microscopy, and quantitative PCR.
  • Ethical, Legal, and Social Aspects (ELSA) Training: Lectures and discussions on ELSA and Responsible Research and Innovation (RRI), culminating in a written essay.
  • Research Training: Two 3-month exploratory research projects across different institutions to allow students to experience diverse research environments and make informed decisions about their doctoral projects.
  • Industrial Engagement: Collaboration with over 10 industrial partners, including opportunities for iCASE scholarships and dedicated modules on industrial applications.
  • Continuous and Career Development: Ongoing training in academic skills (poster presentation, publishing), scientific divulgation, and a 2-year "Impact beyond academia" module focusing on communication, public engagement, and enterprise.
  • Student-Led Events: Requirement for first-year students to organize an academic event and participation in an annual CDT Summer School.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on the program structure and training methodology rather than specific datasets used for computational modeling or experimental validation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Bridging Diverse Backgrounds is Crucial: The program's success hinges on its ability to create a common foundation for students from vastly different scientific disciplines, ensuring everyone has the necessary prerequisites for advanced synthetic biology training.
  • Interdisciplinarity Fosters Collaboration: The cohort-based learning and multi-institutional nature of the CDT actively promote collaboration and the sharing of knowledge and facilities, mirroring the interdisciplinary nature of synthetic biology itself.
  • Early Exposure to ELSA is Essential: Integrating ethical, legal, and social aspects from the outset encourages critical reflection and responsible innovation, preparing students for the broader societal implications of their work.
  • Student Feedback Drives Program Evolution: The paper emphasizes the iterative improvement of the CDT based on regular student feedback, leading to concrete changes in timetabling, module content, and support services.
  • "Confidence" and "Connections" are Key Outcomes: Student feedback consistently highlights increased confidence in tackling new skills and the development of valuable academic and industrial connections as major benefits of the program.

Key Results

The SynBioCDT has been running since 2014, successfully training 78 students. The program has established collaborations with over 10 industrial partners, with several students undertaking projects directly related to industry. Student feedback indicates significant increases in confidence and the formation of strong academic and industrial networks. The program has demonstrated adaptability, with changes made to timetabling and support structures based on student input.

Limitations and Future Work

Limitations:

  • The paper acknowledges that a 2-week programming module is insufficient for students to become experts, but it effectively increases their confidence and provides a foundation for further learning.
  • The diverse backgrounds of students in a single cohort can present challenges for lecturers in tailoring content to all levels, requiring flexibility and careful consideration of prior knowledge.
  • Formative assessment is a relatively new concept for some students, who may expect formal grading for all assignments.

Future Work:

  • The CDT aims to further reshape training to foster a deeper understanding of challenges related to start-up, scale-up, and process development.
  • Future training will support creativity and innovation in the public interest, with an enhanced responsible research innovation component.
  • The program will continue to evolve to meet the needs of the rapidly accelerating field of synthetic biology, ensuring realistic and student-oriented preparation.

Summary updated

Abstract

This article presents the experience of a team of students and academics in developing a post-graduate training program in the new field of Synthetic Biology. Our Centre for Doctoral Training in Synthetic Biology (SynBioCDT) is an initiative funded by the United Kingdom's Research Councils of Engineering and Physical Sciences (EPSRC), and Biotechnology and Biological Sciences (BBSRC). SynBioCDT is a collaboration between the Universities of Oxford, Bristol and Warwick, and has been successfully running since 2014, training 78 students in this field. In this work, we discuss the organization of the taught, research and career development training. We also address the challenges faced when offering an interdisciplinary program. The article concludes with future directions to continue the development of the SynBioCDT.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{cazimoglu2019developing,
  author = {Idil Cazimoglu and Alexander P. S. Darlington and Aurelija Grigonyte and Charlotte E G Hoskin and Juntai Liu and Robert Oppenheimer and Jesús A. Siller‐Farfán and Claire Grierson and Antonis Papachristodoulou},
  title = {{Developing a graduate training program in Synthetic Biology: SynBioCDT}},
  booktitle = {Synthetic},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1093/synbio/ysz006},
}
Figure