Deterministic Lateral Displacement-Based Separation of Magnetic Beads and Its Applications of Antibody Recognition

Haichao Zhang, Junyi Zeng, Dandan Han, Jinan Deng, Ning Hu, Xiaolin Zheng, Jun YangSensors 2020 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel magnetic-driven deterministic lateral displacement (m-DLD) microfluidic device that uses a permanent magnet to separate magnetic beads of different sizes. This device achieves high separation efficiencies and is further demonstrated for recognizing and separating antibodies, offering a simple and low-cost diagnostic tool.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Separating particles of different sizes is crucial in many biological and chemical applications, from cell sorting to diagnostics. Traditional microfluidic separation methods often rely on external pumps or complex channel designs. While deterministic lateral displacement (DLD) offers a passive approach, integrating an external driving force to enhance its capabilities, particularly for magnetic particles, has been an area of exploration. This paper addresses the challenge of efficiently separating magnetic beads of varying sizes and subsequently using this separation capability for a more complex task: recognizing and distinguishing different antibodies. The goal is to develop a simpler, more cost-effective microfluidic system for these applications.

Methods

The core innovation is a magnetic-driven deterministic lateral displacement (m-DLD) microfluidic device. Unlike traditional DLD, which relies solely on fluid flow, this system utilizes a permanent magnet positioned near the microchannel outlet to generate a magnetic force. This force acts as the primary driver for the magnetic beads.

The microfluidic chip itself features a two-stage design with mirrored arrays of cylindrical micropillars. The key parameters investigated and optimized for separation efficiency were:

  • Forcing Angle ($\alpha$): The angle between the magnetic force vector and the micropillar array. This angle dictates how particles interact with the obstacles, leading to either a "displacement mode" (following the obstacle's contour) or a "zigzag mode" (bouncing off obstacles).
  • Inlet Width ($W_{in}$): The width of the entry point into the micropillar array, controlled by a triangular structure. This parameter influences how beads enter the array and their initial trajectory.

The separation mechanism relies on the fact that particles of different sizes have different critical angles at which their movement mode transitions. By tuning the forcing angle and inlet width, the researchers could direct particles of specific sizes to different outlets.

For antibody recognition, magnetic beads were functionalized with different antigens (AFP, PSA, HBsAg) and then incubated with their corresponding antibodies. These antibody-conjugated beads were then subjected to the m-DLD device. The separation trajectories of these beads in the m-DLD system were used to identify and distinguish the different antibody types, leveraging the fact that different antibody-antigen couplings might subtly alter bead behavior or that the beads themselves were of different sizes.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The experiments utilized commercially available magnetic beads of specific sizes (10 µm, 20 µm, 40 µm) and various biological reagents (proteins, antibodies) for functionalization and testing.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Magnetic Force as a Primary Driver: Demonstrating that a simple permanent magnet can effectively drive magnetic beads through a DLD system, eliminating the need for external pumps and simplifying the setup.
  • Size-Dependent Trajectory Control: The critical insight is that by carefully controlling the forcing angle relative to the micropillar array, particles of different sizes can be reliably directed into distinct movement modes (displacement vs. zigzag), leading to size-based separation.
  • Two-Stage Separation for Enhanced Purity: Employing two sequential stages of micropillar arrays allows for more refined separation, collecting specific bead sizes at designated outlets.
  • Antibody Recognition via Trajectory: A significant finding is the potential to use the m-DLD device not just for physical separation but also for molecular recognition. The distinct trajectories of antibody-conjugated beads (even if of the same size, though the paper uses different sizes for different antibodies) can serve as a unique identifier, enabling multiplexed detection without multiple fluorescent labels.
  • Optimization is Key: The study highlights the critical interplay between forcing angle and inlet width, demonstrating that precise tuning is necessary to achieve optimal separation efficiencies.

Key Results

  • High Separation Efficiencies: The optimized m-DLD device achieved separation efficiencies of 87% for 10 µm, 89% for 20 µm, and 94% for 40 µm magnetic beads.
  • Optimal Parameters: The optimal parameters identified were a forcing angle of $\alpha_1 = 15^\circ$ and an inlet width of $W_{in1} = 2 Dy_1$ for the first stage, and $\alpha_2 = 13^\circ$ and $W_{in2} = 2 Dy_2$ for the second stage.
  • Antibody Recognition: The device successfully differentiated between three types of antibodies (anti-human AFP, anti-human PSA, and anti-human HBsAg) based on the trajectories of the magnetic beads they were attached to. The typical percentages for these separations were 87%, 89%, and 94%, respectively.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Number of Antibodies: The current study demonstrated recognition of three types of antibodies. The authors suggest that increasing the number of stages in the micropillar array could allow for the recognition and separation of more than three antibodies.
  • Size-Based vs. Trajectory-Based Differentiation: While the paper uses different-sized beads for different antibodies in the recognition part, the core mechanism for antibody recognition relies on the trajectories. It's implied that even beads of the same size could potentially be differentiated if their antibody conjugation leads to distinct interactions with the micropillars. However, the current demonstration primarily leverages size differences.
  • Separating Cells of Same Size: The authors propose that by coupling magnetic beads to cells of the same size, the m-DLD system could be extended for cell separation.
  • Bacterial Classification: Coupling magnetic beads to bacteria is suggested as a future direction for bacterial classification.
  • Low-Cost Diagnostic Potential: The paper emphasizes the simplicity and low cost of the m-DLD device, suggesting its potential as a portable biosensing platform.

Summary updated

Abstract

This work presents a magnetic-driven deterministic lateral displacement (m-DLD) microfluidic device. A permanent magnet located at the outlet of the microchannel was used to generate the driving force. Two stages of mirrored round micropillar array were designed for the separation of magnetic beads with three different sizes in turn. The effects of the forcing angle and the inlet width of the micropillar array on the separating efficiency were studied. The m-DLD device with optimal structure parameters shows that the separating efficiencies for the 10 μm, 20 μm and 40 μm magnetic beads are 87%, 89% and 94%, respectively. Furthermore, this m-DLD device was used for antibody recognition and separation among a mixture solution of antibodies. The trajectories of different kinds of magnetic beads coupled with different antigens showed that the m-DLD device could realize a simple and low-cost diagnostic test.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2020deterministic,
  author = {Haichao Zhang and Junyi Zeng and Dandan Han and Jinan Deng and Ning Hu and Xiaolin Zheng and Jun Yang},
  title = {{Deterministic Lateral Displacement-Based Separation of Magnetic Beads and Its Applications of Antibody Recognition}},
  booktitle = {Sensors},
  year = {2020},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=wMPJqZr7FK},
}
Figure