Deterministic form-position deflectometric measurement of monolithic multi-freeform optical structures via bayesian multisensor fusion

Wei Lang, Xiangchao Zhang, Yunuo Chen, Ting Chen, Peide Yang, Min Xu, Xiangqian JiangLight 2025 · DOI

Abstract

Monolithic multi-freeform optical structures are revolutionizing high-end optical systems by integrating multiple complex surfaces into single components. However, their manufacturing and measurement are challenging, requiring simultaneous verification of surface form and relative positioning. This paper proposes a deterministic form-position deflectometric measurement method based on Bayesian multisensor fusion. By integrating calibration priors and a fully probabilistic framework, the method overcomes the inherent absolute positioning limitations of deflectometry. Experimental results demonstrate measurement accuracies of approximately 100 nm for surface forms and a few microns for surface positions.

Introduction

Modern optical systems are increasingly moving toward "monolithic multi-freeform" structures—single pieces of material featuring multiple complex, non-spherical surfaces. These designs are compact and high-performing, making them ideal for advanced aerospace and astronomical instruments. However, measuring these components is notoriously difficult because it requires high-precision data for both the shape (form) of each surface and its absolute position relative to others on the same part.

Examples of monolithic multi-freeform optical structures and their designs.

The Challenge: Slope-Height Ambiguity

A primary tool for measuring such surfaces is Phase Measuring Deflectometry (PMD), valued for its high resolution and low cost. However, PMD suffers from "slope-height ambiguity," where it cannot easily distinguish between a change in surface height and a change in tilt. While excellent for measuring surface form, PMD struggles to determine the absolute position of surfaces relative to a global datum.

Methodology: Bayesian Multisensor Fusion

To address this, researchers developed a multisensor fusion system that integrates three key components:

  1. Phase Measuring Deflectometry (PMD): To capture high-resolution surface gradients.
  2. Chromatic Confocal Sensor (CCS): A distance sensor that provides a "rigid constraint" for absolute distance.
  3. Precision Rotary Table: To facilitate measuring different surfaces from multiple angles.

The core of this approach is a Bayesian multisensor fusion framework. Unlike traditional sequential optimization, which can be prone to numerical bias or local optima, this framework treats calibration and measurement as a state estimation problem. By modeling physical uncertainties and marginalizing calibration priors into the measurement model, the system accounts for its own inherent uncertainties, leading to higher fidelity and preventing overfitting to measurement noise.

Schematic of the multi-sensor measurement system and its positioning logic.

Key Results and Insights

The study evaluated the system using a custom-machined monolithic structure with four functional surfaces.

  • Surface Form Accuracy: Achieved approximately 100 nm RMS.
  • Surface Position Precision: Achieved 3.9 to 9.3 μm Peak-to-Valley.

The success of this method lies in sensor complementarity: PMD is highly sensitive to angles but weak on distance, while the CCS is the exact opposite. Fusing them creates a system with "absolute" vision. Furthermore, using the nominal design as a geometric constraint helps shorten the error propagation chain, ensuring multiple surfaces are positioned correctly relative to a consistent datum.

Conclusion and Future Directions

This Bayesian fusion method provides a robust solution for the deterministic measurement of complex monolithic optics. The most promising direction for future work is in-situ measurement. Integrating this system directly onto single-point diamond-turning machines would allow for real-time measurement and corrective machining without removing the part, significantly increasing manufacturing efficiency for high-precision optics.

Summary updated

Abstract

Monolithic multi-freeform optical structures play significant roles in advanced optical systems by simplifying system structures and enhancing optoelectronic performance. However, manufacturing and measurement present significant challenges, which require the simultaneous assurance of form quality and relative positioning of multiple functional surfaces. Consequently, a deterministic form-position deflectometric measuring method is proposed based on Bayesian multisensor fusion, which effectively overcomes the inherent limitation of deflectometry in absolute positioning. Calibration priors were marginalised in the measurement model to improve fidelity, and a fully probabilistic measurement framework was proposed to eliminate numerical bias in conventional sequential optimisation approaches. Finally, a geometric-constraint-based registration method was developed to evaluate the form-position quality of freeform surfaces. The experimental results demonstrated the measurement accuracy could achieve a level of one hundred nanometres for surface forms and a few microns for surface positions.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{lang2025deterministic,
  author = {Wei Lang and Xiangchao Zhang and Yunuo Chen and Ting Chen and Peide Yang and Min Xu and Xiangqian Jiang},
  title = {{Deterministic form-position deflectometric measurement of monolithic multi-freeform optical structures via bayesian multisensor fusion}},
  booktitle = {Light},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.37188/lam.2025.029},
}
Figure