Determining the three-dimensional atomic structure of a metallic glass

Yao Yang, Jihan Zhou, Fan Zhu, Yakun Yuan, Dillan J. Chang, Dennis Kim, Minh Phạm, Arjun Rana, Xuezeng Tian, Yonggang Yao, Stanley Osher, Andreas K. Schmid, Liangbing Hu, Peter Ercius, Jianwei MiaoResearch 2020 · DOI

Introduction

For over a century, crystallography has allowed scientists to map the precise 3D structures of crystals because their atoms are arranged in neat, repeating patterns. Amorphous solids—such as window glass or high-performance metallic glasses—present a much greater challenge. Lacking long-range order, their atomic structure is a chaotic "jumble" that has long defied direct experimental determination.

Until now, our understanding of glass structure relied on statistical averages or computer models fitted to indirect data. This research marks a significant breakthrough by directly mapping the 3D positions of over 18,000 individual atoms in a multi-component metallic glass for the first time, revealing the hidden "order within disorder."

Methodology: Atomic Electron Tomography

The researchers utilized Atomic Electron Tomography (AET), a technique involving the acquisition of multiple 2D images of a sample from different angles to reconstruct a 3D volume. To handle the non-periodic nature of glass, the team developed the REal Space Iterative REconstruction (RESIRE) algorithm. Unlike standard methods that fluctuate between real and reciprocal space, RESIRE operates primarily in real space, making it far more effective at resolving disordered structures.

Experimental determination of the 3D atomic structure of a metallic glass nanoparticle via AET.

The study achieved a 3D coordinate precision of 21 picometers, which is significantly smaller than the radius of the atoms themselves. This precision allowed for the classification of atoms into three types based on their atomic number ($Z$-contrast) and the measurement of subtle bond variations within the amorphous matrix.

Key Insights: The Hidden Networks of Glass

The most striking finding is that metallic glass is not a random pile of atoms. While the local packing, or Short-Range Order (SRO), is geometrically disordered, these clusters connect to form Medium-Range Order (MRO) in the form of crystal-like networks.

The researchers identified four distinct types of MRO networks coexisting within the same sample:

  • Face-centered cubic (fcc)
  • Hexagonal close-packed (hcp)
  • Body-centered cubic (bcc)
  • Simple cubic (sc)

These networks show translational order (the centers of clusters follow a pattern) but lack orientational order, as the networks are distorted and rotated relative to one another. These observations provide the first direct experimental support for the "efficient cluster packing model," a leading theory on how atoms pack in metallic glasses to minimize empty space.

Significance and Future Outlook

By successfully mapping 18,356 atoms in a single nanoparticle, this study demonstrates that the 3D atomic coordinates of various amorphous solids can finally be determined. This capability is expected to have an impact on non-crystalline solids comparable to the first 3D crystal structure solved by X-ray crystallography over a century ago.

Looking forward, AET could be used to study shear transformation zones—the microscopic regions where glass begins to fail under stress. Understanding these structures in 3D could lead to the design of tougher, more ductile metallic glasses for use in aerospace, electronics, and beyond. While current limitations exist in distinguishing elements with very similar atomic numbers (e.g., Cobalt vs. Nickel), the ability to see the atomic skeleton of glass opens a new era in materials science.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Amorphous solids such as glass are ubiquitous in our daily life and have found broad applications ranging from window glass and solar cells to telecommunications and transformer cores 1,2 . However, due to the lack of long-range order, the three-dimensional (3D) atomic structure of amorphous solids have thus far defied any direct experimental determination without model fitting 3-13 . Here, using a multi-component metallic glass as a proof-of-principle, we advance atomic electron tomography to determine the 3D atomic positions in an amorphous solid for the first time. We quantitatively characterize the short-range order (SRO) and medium-range order (MRO) of the 3D atomic arrangement. We find that although the 3D atomic packing of the SRO is geometrically disordered, some SRO connect with each other to form crystal-like networks and give rise to MRO. We identify four crystal-like MRO networks - face-centred cubic, hexagonal close-packed, body-centered cubic and simple cubic - coexisting in the sample, which show translational but no orientational order. These observations confirm that the 3D atomic structure in some parts of the sample is consistent with the efficient cluster packing mode l8,10-12,20 . Looking forward, we anticipate this experiment will open the door to determining the 3D atomic coordinates of various amorphous solids, whose impact on non-crystalline solids may be comparable to the first 3D crystal structure solved by x-ray crystallography over a century ago 14 .
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yang2020determining,
  author = {Yao Yang and Jihan Zhou and Fan Zhu and Yakun Yuan and Dillan J. Chang and Dennis Kim and Minh Phạm and Arjun Rana and Xuezeng Tian and Yonggang Yao and Stanley Osher and Andreas K. Schmid and Liangbing Hu and Peter Ercius and Jianwei Miao},
  title = {{Determining the three-dimensional atomic structure of a metallic glass}},
  booktitle = {Research},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-88474/v1},
}

Loading related content...

Figure