Determining the stability of minimally displaced lateral humeral condyle fractures in children: ultrasound is better than arthrography

Desheng Wu, Xiongtao Li, Shaowei Yang, Si Wang, Jingdong Xia, Xiaoliang Chen, Xiantao ShenResearch 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This study demonstrates that ultrasound is a highly reliable, non-invasive, and radiation-free alternative to arthrography for assessing the stability of elbow fractures in children. By accurately identifying whether the cartilage hinge is intact, ultrasound can guide surgical decisions for minimally displaced fractures without the need for invasive dye injections or sedation.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Lateral humeral condyle fractures (LHCFs) are the second most common elbow fractures in children. The critical factor in deciding how to treat these fractures—whether through simple pinning or more invasive open surgery—is the "stability" of the fracture. Stability is determined by the integrity of the cartilage hinge at the joint; if the cartilage is intact, the fracture is incomplete and stable.

The challenge is that this cartilage is "invisible" on standard X-rays because it hasn't yet ossified in young children. The current "gold standard" for checking this hinge is arthrography, which involves injecting a contrast dye into the joint under fluoroscopy (X-ray). However, arthrography is invasive, carries a risk of infection, exposes the child to ionizing radiation, and often requires sedation. This paper investigates whether ultrasound can provide the same diagnostic clarity more safely and efficiently.

Methods

The researchers conducted a prospective study of 39 pediatric patients (average age ~4.5 years) with minimally displaced LHCFs (displaced by 2–5 mm).

  • Ultrasound Protocol: Each patient first underwent a specialized ultrasound exam using a high-frequency linear array transducer. A pediatric orthopedic surgeon examined the elbow in five standardized planes, specifically looking for a "hypoechoic" (dark) continuous line representing the cartilage hinge.
  • Arthrography Protocol: Following the ultrasound, arthrography was performed by injecting iohexol contrast into the joint.
  • Blinding: To ensure objective results, the experts analyzing the ultrasound images were blinded to the arthrography results, and vice versa.
  • Comparison: The researchers compared the two methods' ability to classify fractures as "incomplete" (stable hinge) or "complete" (disrupted hinge).

Datasets

The study utilized a primary clinical dataset of 39 pediatric patients treated at the Wuhan Women and Children Medical Care Center between May 2018 and December 2019.

  • Demographics: 27 boys and 12 girls.
  • Fracture Profile: All fractures were minimally displaced, with a mean displacement of 3.1 mm.
  • Reference: No external benchmarks were used; the study compared two diagnostic modalities within the same patient cohort.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Invisible" Hinge: The study reinforces that bone displacement seen on an X-ray is a poor predictor of actual stability. Even fractures displaced by more than 2mm often had intact cartilage hinges (64.1% of cases), making them candidates for less invasive treatment.
  • High Diagnostic Concordance: Ultrasound and arthrography agreed on the status of the articular surface in 92.3% of cases.
  • Efficiency and Safety: The ultrasound exam took an average of only 3 minutes and provided a direct view of the cartilage, whereas arthrography provides an indirect view by tracking where the dye flows.
  • Superiority of Non-Invasive Imaging: The authors argue that because ultrasound is non-ionizing and doesn't require sedation or joint penetration, it should be considered a primary complementary tool rather than just a backup.

Key Results

  • Agreement: The Pearson correlation coefficient between ultrasound and arthrography was 0.837, indicating a very strong correlation.
  • Fracture Classification:
    • Arthrography identified 24 incomplete and 15 complete fractures.
  • Ultrasound identified 25 incomplete and 14 complete fractures.
  • Clinical Outcomes: All patients were successfully treated with Closed Reduction and Percutaneous Pinning (CRPP). Post-operative scans confirmed that the cartilage remained continuous, and all patients achieved fracture union without complications like non-union.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Sample Size: While the authors claim this is the largest study on this specific topic to date, 39 patients is still a relatively small cohort.
  • Operator Expertise: Ultrasound is highly operator-dependent. The results were achieved by a pediatric orthopedic surgeon experienced in "osteosonographic" diagnostics; results might vary in centers without specialized training.
  • Future Directions: The authors have begun incorporating preoperative MRI into their workflow to further validate ultrasound findings against a 3D imaging standard. They suggest that larger, multi-center trials could help establish ultrasound as the new standard of care for pediatric elbow assessments.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Background: Evaluating of the articular cartilage status of the distal humeral epiphysis is difficult. Ultrasound imaging of the elbow is increasingly being used to confirm the integrity of the articular cartilage of minimally displaced lateral humeral condyle fractures in children with minimally displaced fractures. The aims of this study were to assess the correlations between ultrasound and arthrography findings for predicting the integrity of the cartilage hinge and to describe the utility of ultrasound in determining the need for pre-treatment. Methods: Thirty-nine patients with minimally displaced lateral humeral condyle fractures who underwent ultrasound and arthrography examinations before surgery from May 2018 to December 2019 were included in this study. Ultrasound and arthrography predictors of the cartilage hinge status were independently measured. The ultrasound and arthrography results were compared. Results: The mean displacement of the fractures was 3.1 mm (range, 2.0~5.0 mm). Arthrography showed incomplete fractures in 24 patients (61.5%) and complete fractures in 15 patients (38.5%). Ultrasound showed incomplete fractures in 25 patients (64.1%) and complete fractures in 14 patients (35.9%). The ultrasound and arthrography results of the integrity of the articular surface were consistent in 92.3% of the cases, including 23 that were predicted to have an intact articular surface and 13 that were predicted to have an incongruity articular surface. There was no correlation between the displacement and the fracture appearing complete on the ultrasound scan. The Pearson coefficient between ultrasound and arthrography for assessing the integrity of the articular surface was 0.837. Conclusions: Ultrasound and arthrography assessments of the integrity of the cartilage hinge status appear to be highly consistent. Ultrasound can be used as a complementary tool with arthrography to predict the integrity of the cartilage hinge status in children with minimally displaced lateral humeral condyle fractures. Level of evidence: Prospective study; level Ⅱ.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wu2020determining,
  author = {Desheng Wu and Xiongtao Li and Shaowei Yang and Si Wang and Jingdong Xia and Xiaoliang Chen and Xiantao Shen},
  title = {{Determining the stability of minimally displaced lateral humeral condyle fractures in children: ultrasound is better than arthrography}},
  booktitle = {Research},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-61559/v2},
}
Figure