Determining impact parameters of heavy-ion collisions at low-intermediate incident energies using deep learning with convolutional neural network

X. Zhang, Yongzhen Huang, Wei-Yang Lin, Xinyang Liu, Hao Zheng, R. Wada, A. Bonasera, Z. Chen, Le Chen, Jifeng Han, Renmin Han, Meiyu Huang, Qi Hu, Qingming Leng, Cornelissen Frans W., Guofeng Qu, Pengju Ren, Gang Tian, Zhihua Xu, Zaitian Yang, Le ZhangarXiv 2021 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

A deep learning method using a Convolutional Neural Network (CNN) is developed to determine impact parameters in heavy-ion collisions at low-to-intermediate energies (50–100 MeV/nucleon). By treating fragment momentum distributions as images, the CNN overcomes the limitations of traditional scalar proxies. Improvements in input selection and training, including the consideration of experimental filter effects, allow the CNN to significantly outperform conventional methods, particularly in identifying central collision events and accurately deducing nuclear stopping power.

Introduction

In heavy-ion physics, the impact parameter ($b$)—the perpendicular distance between the centers of two colliding nuclei—is a fundamental variable that governs reaction dynamics, nuclear matter density, and particle production. However, $b$ cannot be measured directly. Experimenters must rely on observable proxies like the number of charged particles ($N_{ch}$) or the charge of the largest fragment ($Z_{max}$). At low-to-intermediate energies (50–100 MeV/nucleon), these traditional proxies often become "blunt instruments," struggling to distinguish between central and mid-range collisions. This paper presents a CNN-based approach that treats fragment momentum distributions as high-dimensional "images" to predict $b$ with high precision.

Methodology: Momentum Distributions as Images

The researchers moved beyond scalar proxies by utilizing the entire "shape" of the collision's output. Momentum data for all fragments were converted into 2D histograms (images) plotting absolute transverse momentum ($|P_t|/A$) against longitudinal momentum ($|P_z|/A$).

2D momentum distributions ($|P_t|/A$ vs $|P_z|/A$) for different impact parameters and fragment charges.

As shown in Figure 1, these distributions act as fingerprints. Separate channels for light fragments ($Z \le 2$) and heavy fragments ($Z > 2$) capture nuanced physics that single-number observables miss. The CNN acts as a pattern recognition tool, identifying subtle correlations in how particles are sprayed into the detector.

CNN Architecture and Training

The model was trained on 400,000 simulated $^{124}\text{Sn} + ^{124}\text{Sn}$ collision events generated via the Constrained Molecular Dynamics (CoMD) model.

Schematic of the CNN architecture designed for impact parameter prediction.

The CNN architecture (Figure 2) features two convolutional layers with 32 kernels each, max-pooling for dimensionality reduction, and dropout layers to prevent overfitting. Crucially, the training process incorporated an "experimental filter" based on the INDRA detector array. This accounts for detector blind spots and energy thresholds, ensuring the model remains accurate when applied to real-world experimental data.

Key Results

  • Superior Accuracy: The CNN achieved a mean absolute error ($\Delta b$) of 0.38 to 0.44 fm, significantly outperforming traditional methods which often exhibit errors twice as large in the central collision region.
  • Central Collision Recognition: The CNN's ability to identify central events ($b/b_{max} < 0.2$) reached approximately 66% at 100 MeV/nucleon, a major improvement over conventional proxies that typically saturate at low $b$.
  • Impact on Stopping Power: When used to select events for calculating nuclear stopping power ($R_E^p$), the CNN-derived values were much closer to theoretical "true" values than those from traditional selection methods.

Conclusion

The application of deep learning to impact parameter determination represents a significant advancement in experimental nuclear physics. By leveraging the full information content of momentum distributions, the CNN method provides higher resolution for central collisions and more reliable deductions of nuclear observables like stopping power. Future work will focus on cross-training with different transport models to ensure the network's predictions are robust and model-independent.

Summary updated

Abstract

A deep learning based method with the convolutional neural network (CNN) algorithm for determining the impact parameters is developed using the constrained molecular dynamics model simulations, focusing on the heavy-ion collisions at the low-intermediate incident energies from several ten to one hundred MeV/nucleon in which the emissions of heavy fragments with the charge numbers larger than 3 become crucial. To make the CNN applicable in the task of the impact parameter determination at the present energy range, specific improvements are made in the input selection, the CNN construction and the CNN training. It is demonstrated from the comparisons of the deep CNN method and the conventional methods with the impact parameter-sensitive observables, that the deep CNN method shows better performance for determining the impact parameters, especially leading to the capability of providing better recognition of the central collision events. With a proper consideration of the experimental filter effect in both training and testing processes to keep consistency with the actual experiments, the good performance of the deep CNN method holds, and shows significantly better in terms of predicting the impact parameters and recognizing the central collision events, compared to that of the conventional methods, demonstrating the superiority of the present deep CNN method. The deep CNN method with the consideration of the filter effect is applied in the deduction of nuclear stopping power. Higher accuracy for the stopping power deduction is achieved benefitting from the better impact parameter determination using the deep CNN method, compared to using the the conventional methods. This result reveals the importance to select a reliable impact parameter determination method in the experimental deduction of the nuclear stopping power as well as other observables.
BibTeX
@misc{zhang2021determining,
  author = {X. Zhang and Yongzhen Huang and Wei-Yang Lin and Xinyang Liu and Hao Zheng and R. Wada and A. Bonasera and Z. Chen and Le Chen and Jifeng Han and Renmin Han and Meiyu Huang and Qi Hu and Qingming Leng and CORNELISSEN Frans W. and Guofeng Qu and Pengju Ren and Gang Tian and Zhihua Xu and Zaitian Yang and Le Zhang},
  title = {{Determining impact parameters of heavy-ion collisions at low-intermediate incident energies using deep learning with convolutional neural network}},
  year = {2021},
  eprint = {2111.06597},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2111.06597},
}
Figure