Determination of Winding Losses of Low-Profile Planar-Type Transformer

C.f. Foo, Xun GongJournal de Physique IV (Proceedings) 1997 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates how winding arrangement impacts AC losses in high-frequency planar transformers, crucial for efficient power supplies. By simulating current distribution, they demonstrate that interleaving windings significantly reduces losses caused by skin and proximity effects, leading to better transformer efficiency.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

As power electronics push towards higher frequencies and smaller form factors, transformers are becoming a bottleneck for efficiency and power density. At high frequencies, traditional winding losses, primarily from DC resistance, are overshadowed by AC losses due to skin and proximity effects. These effects cause current to flow unevenly within conductors, effectively increasing their resistance and generating heat. This paper specifically addresses how to mitigate these AC losses in low-profile planar transformers, which are attractive for their compact size and suitability for high-frequency applications like soft-switching power supplies. The challenge lies in optimizing the winding configuration to minimize these frequency-dependent loss mechanisms.

Methods

The authors employ a combination of 2D and 3D Finite Element Method (FEM) simulations using the Maxwell CAD program. This allows them to visualize and quantify the magnetic flux distribution within the transformer's window and, critically, the current density distribution within the winding conductors. They compare two primary winding arrangements: non-interleaving and interleaving. The simulations are run at a high frequency (500 kHz) and with a specific input current (1A) to accurately model the AC loss phenomena.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Interleaving is Key: The most significant finding is that interleaving the primary and secondary windings dramatically reduces AC losses compared to a non-interleaved configuration.
  • Current Density Uniformity: Interleaving improves the uniformity of current distribution within the winding conductors. This directly combats the non-uniformity caused by skin and proximity effects, effectively lowering the AC resistance.
  • Reduced Leakage Inductance: Beyond loss reduction, interleaving also leads to a smaller leakage inductance and better flux coupling, which are desirable for transformer performance.
  • Planar Advantage: Planar winding configurations inherently help reduce skin and proximity effects compared to traditional wound transformers, making them a good choice for high-frequency applications.

Key Results

The study quantifies the reduction in winding losses achieved through interleaving. At 500 kHz, the winding losses (Pa) were reduced from 43.52 mW in the non-interleaving configuration to 23.32 mW in the interleaved configuration. This represents a significant reduction of approximately 46.6%. Furthermore, Table 1 shows that the interleaved structure (No3) has a leakage inductance (Lk) of 102.67 nH, which is smaller than the non-interleaved structure (No2) at 146.94 nH, while maintaining a comparable magnetizing inductance (Lm). The ratio Lk/Lm, indicating coupling efficiency, is also improved in the interleaved case (0.35 vs. 0.52).

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that their study focuses on specific winding arrangements and a particular transformer geometry. While they demonstrate the benefits of interleaving, further research could explore the optimal degree of interleaving, the impact of different conductor shapes and materials, and the trade-offs between interleaving and other design parameters for various applications. The paper suggests that interleaving is a crucial technique for reducing losses and improving flux coupling in low-profile planar transformers, making them well-suited for soft-switching converters.

Summary updated

Abstract

At high frequency, the winding losses of power transformer due to skin and proximity effects becomes a significant component in the loss calculation of the transformer efficiency. This paper examines the winding losses associated with these effects for planar-type low-profile transformers that are suitable for high frequency high density soft switching power supply application. The transformer winding ac resistance and leakage inductance are investigated for the different winding arrangements. 2D and 3D Finite-element methods are used to study the magnetic flux distribution in the transformer window area and the current density distribution in the winding conductors.
BibTeX
@article{foo1997determination,
  author = {C.F. Foo and Xun Gong},
  title = {{Determination of Winding Losses of Low-Profile Planar-Type Transformer}},
  journal = {Journal de Physique IV (Proceedings)},
  year = {1997},
  doi = {10.1051/jp4:1997149},
}

Loading related content...

Figure