Determination of onset temperature from the entropy for fragile to strong liquids

Atreyee Banerjee, Manoj Kumar Nandi, Srikanth Sastry, Sarika Maitra BhattacharyyaThe Journal of Chemical Physics 2017 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

In this paper, we establish a connection between the onset temperature of glassy dynamics with the change in the entropy for a wide range of model systems. We identify the crossing temperature of pair and excess entropies as the onset temperature. Below the onset temperature, the residual multiparticle entropy, the difference between excess and pair entropies, becomes positive. The positive entropy can be viewed as equivalent to the larger phase space exploration of the system. The new method of onset temperature prediction from entropy is less ambiguous, as it does not depend on any fitting parameter like the existing methods.

Introduction

As a liquid is cooled rapidly to avoid crystallization, it enters a supercooled state. A critical milestone in this cooling process is the onset temperature ($T_{onset}$), which marks the transition from normal liquid flow to a regime characterized by sluggish dynamics, spatial heterogeneity, and landscape-influenced motion. Identifying $T_{onset}$ is crucial for understanding the glass transition, yet traditional methods—such as observing the emergence of a plateau in time-correlation functions or fitting potential energy data to linear regimes—are often subjective. These methods rely on researcher-defined fitting parameters, leading to inconsistent reported values. This study proposes a universal, parameter-free thermodynamic signature for $T_{onset}$ based on entropy.

Methodology

The researchers utilized Molecular Dynamics (MD) simulations to analyze four distinct model liquids: the fragile Kob-Andersen Lennard-Jones (KALJ) and its repulsive counterpart (KAWCA), the Wahnström (WAHN) binary mixture, and a network-forming (NTW) model mimicking silica. The core of the analysis involves comparing two thermodynamic quantities:

  1. Excess Entropy ($S_{ex}$): The entropy difference between the system and an ideal gas at identical conditions.
  2. Pair Entropy ($S_2$): The entropy contribution derived from pair correlations.
  3. Residual Multiparticle Entropy (RMPE or $\Delta S$): Defined as the difference between the two ($\Delta S = S_{ex} - S_2$).

The Entropy Crossing Method

The primary finding is that $T_{onset}$ corresponds to the "crossing temperature" ($T_{crossing}$) where $S_2$ and $S_{ex}$ are equal, making $\Delta S = 0$.

Figure 4: Temperature dependence of pair entropy ($S_2$) and excess entropy ($S_{ex}$) for various models and densities. The vertical dotted lines indicate the crossing points where $S_2 = S_{ex}$.

As shown in Figure 4, below $T_{crossing}$, the RMPE ($\Delta S$) becomes positive. The authors suggest that this positive entropy acts like "activation," helping the system explore more of its phase space to overcome the energy barriers that start appearing as the liquid gets "stuck" in deep energy minima.

Validation and Universality

To confirm the validity of this thermodynamic marker, the researchers compared $T_{crossing}$ with traditional kinetic markers across different densities and models.

Figure 5: Comparison of characteristic temperatures, including the plateau emergence temperature ($T_{Plateau-arises}$), the energy drop temperature ($T_{e_{IS}-drop}$), and the proposed entropy crossing temperature ($T_{crossing}$).

The data in Figure 5 demonstrates remarkable consistency. For the standard KALJ model at $\rho = 1.2$, $T_{crossing}$ is found to be 0.77, aligning closely with literature values (0.78–0.80) obtained through more ambiguous fitting methods. This relationship holds across both "fragile" liquids (KALJ, WCA) and "strong" network-formers (NTW), suggesting a universal thermodynamic origin for the onset of glassy dynamics. Furthermore, at high densities, the crossing temperatures of different models converge, indicating that packing physics dominates over specific attractive forces in this regime.

Conclusion

By identifying $T_{onset}$ through the crossing of pair and excess entropies, this work provides a robust, parameter-free method to pinpoint the start of the glass transition. This thermodynamic "anchor" not only resolves existing ambiguities in kinetic measurements but also offers a new perspective on how entropy-driven activation facilitates phase space exploration in supercooled liquids.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this paper, we establish a connection between the onset temperature of glassy dynamics with the change in the entropy for a wide range of model systems. We identify the crossing temperature of pair and excess entropies as the onset temperature. Below the onset temperature, the residual multiparticle entropy, the difference between excess and pair entropies, becomes positive. The positive entropy can be viewed as equivalent to the larger phase space exploration of the system. The new method of onset temperature prediction from entropy is less ambiguous, as it does not depend on any fitting parameter like the existing methods.
BibTeX
@article{banerjee2017determination,
  author = {Atreyee Banerjee and Manoj Kumar Nandi and Srikanth Sastry and Sarika Maitra Bhattacharyya},
  title = {{Determination of onset temperature from the entropy for fragile to strong liquids}},
  journal = {The Journal of Chemical Physics},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1063/1.4991848},
}
Figure