Determination of geopotential difference by hydrogen masers based on precise point positioning time-frequency transfer

Lei Wang, Wei Xu, Lihong Li, Pengfei Zhang, Ning An, Rui Xu, Peng Cheng, Ziyu Shen, Wenbin ShenarXiv 2023 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

According to the general relativity theory, the geopotential difference can be determined by gravity frequency shift between two clocks. Here we report on the experiments to determine the geopotential difference between two remote sites by hydrogen masers based on precise point positioning time-frequency transfer technique. The experiments include the remote clock comparison and the local clock comparison using two CH1-95 active hydrogen masers linked with global navigation satellite system time-frequency receivers. The frequency difference between two hydrogen masers at two sites is derived from the time difference series resolved by the above-mentioned technique. Considering the local clock comparison as calibration, the determined geopotential difference by our experiments is 12,142.3 (112.4) m²/s², quite close to the value 12,153.3 (2.3) m²/s² computed by the EIGEN-6C4 model. Results show that the proposed approach here for determining geopotential difference is feasible, operable, and promising for applications in various fields.

Introduction

In traditional geodesy, determining the geopotential difference (or "height") between two points typically relies on geometric leveling combined with local gravity measurements. While accurate over short distances, this method is labor-intensive, expensive, and prone to error accumulation over long spans. Furthermore, it is physically impossible to apply across oceans or impassable terrain.

General Relativity provides an elegant alternative: the gravity frequency shift. Einstein’s theory predicts that a clock at a higher geopotential ticks faster than an identical clock at a lower geopotential. By comparing the frequencies of two remote clocks with high precision, the geopotential difference can be calculated directly. This "relativistic geodesy" transforms height measurement from a geometric problem into a chronometric one.

Experimental Methods and Setup

The researchers conducted a practical demonstration between two stations in China: Jiugongshan (JTFS) and Luojiashan (LTFS). These sites are separated by approximately 129 km with a height difference of roughly 1,245 meters.

Schematic of the experimental setup showing the two sites (JTFS and LTFS), GNSS satellites, and the hydrogen maser links.

The experiment utilized two CH1-95 active hydrogen masers (AHMs) as high-stability frequency standards. These were linked to GNSS time-frequency receivers. To achieve the necessary precision, the team employed Precise Point Positioning Time-Frequency Transfer (PTFT) with Ambiguity Resolution (PPP-AR). Unlike standard PPP, PPP-AR recovers the integer nature of satellite signal phase ambiguities, significantly enhancing time transfer precision.

A critical component of the methodology was the AA/AB calibration strategy:

  1. AB Experiment: Clocks were placed at separate sites to measure the combined effect of geopotential difference and inherent hardware frequency offsets.
  2. AA Experiment: The remote clock was brought to the local site for a side-by-side comparison. This served as a calibration to isolate and remove the internal frequency bias of the masers themselves.

Key Results

The frequency stability of the satellite links reached the $10^{-16}$ level after one day of averaging, matching the nominal performance of the hydrogen masers.

Time difference (a,b), frequency difference (c,d), and Allan deviation (e,f) for the local (AA) and remote (AB) comparisons.

The experimental geopotential difference was calculated to be 12,142.3 (± 112.4) m²/s². This result aligns closely with the EIGEN-6C4 model value of 12,153.3 (± 2.3) m²/s². The discrepancy of approximately 11.0 m²/s² corresponds to a height error of about 1.1 meters, demonstrating the feasibility of using GNSS-based time transfer for geodetic surveys.

Conclusion and Future Outlook

This experiment proves that GNSS satellites can serve as effective "bridges" for determining geopotential differences over long distances. While hydrogen masers provide sufficient stability for meter-level accuracy, achieving the centimeter-level precision required for modern geodesy will necessitate the use of optical clocks, which offer fractional frequency accuracies in the $10^{-18}$ to $10^{-19}$ range. Future developments in portable optical clocks and improved atmospheric noise mitigation for GNSS signals will be key to establishing a global chronometric height system.

Summary updated

Abstract

According to the general relativity theory, the geopotential difference can be determined by gravity frequency shift between two clocks. Here we report on the experiments to determine the geopotential difference between two remote sites by hydrogen masers based on precise point positioning time-frequency transfer technique. The experiments include the remote clock comparison and the local clock comparison using two CH1-95 active hydrogen masers linked with global navigation satellite system time-frequency receivers. The frequency difference between two hydrogen masers at two sites is derived from the time difference series resolved by the above-mentioned technique. Considering the local clock comparison as calibration, the determined geopotential difference by our experiments is 12,142.3 (112.4) m^2/s^2, quite close to the value 12,153.3 (2.3) m^2/s^2 computed by the EIGEN-6C4 model. Results show that the proposed approach here for determining geopotential difference is feasible, operable, and promising for applications in various fields.
BibTeX
@misc{wang2023determination,
  author = {Lei Wang and Wei Xu and Lihong Li and Pengfei Zhang and Ning An and Rui Xu and Peng Cheng and Ziyu Shen and Wenbin Shen},
  title = {{Determination of geopotential difference by hydrogen masers based on precise point positioning time-frequency transfer}},
  year = {2023},
  eprint = {2306.15184},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2306.15184},
}

Loading related content...

Figure