Determination of an Unknown Source in the Heat Equation by the Method of Tikhonov Regularization in Hilbert Scales

Zhenyu Zhao, Ou Xie, Zehong Meng, Lei YouJournal of Applied Mathematics and Physics 2014 · DOI

Abstract

In this paper, we consider the problem for determining an unknown source in the heat equation. The Tikhonov regularization method in Hilbert scales is presented to deal with ill-posedness of the problem and error estimates are obtained with a posteriori choice rule to find the regularization parameter. The smoothness parameter and the a priori bound of exact solution are not needed for the choice rule. Numerical tests show that the proposed method is effective and stable.

Introduction

In thermodynamics, identifying the source of a specific temperature distribution is a critical inverse problem. While predicting temperature from a known source (the forward problem) is straightforward, determining the source from observed temperature data is notoriously difficult. These inverse source problems are inherently ill-posed: the heat equation's natural tendency to "smooth out" information over time means that minor measurement errors or noise can lead to massive, physically unrealistic fluctuations in the reconstructed source term.

To address this, regularization techniques are employed to balance data fidelity with physical plausibility. However, standard methods often require a priori knowledge of the solution's smoothness or its maximum bounds—information rarely available in practical engineering scenarios. This paper introduces a robust numerical method using Tikhonov regularization in Hilbert scales, featuring an a posteriori parameter choice rule that operates without these restrictive requirements.

Methodology

The proposed approach utilizes Tikhonov regularization within Hilbert scales to stabilize the inverse problem. The methodology follows several key steps:

  1. Frequency Domain Transformation: The spatial heat equation is transformed via Fourier Transform, simplifying the relationship between the source and the data into an algebraic mapping.
  2. Hilbert Scale Regularization: Instead of standard $L^2$ norms, the authors employ Sobolev norms ($H^q$). This allows the regularization process to penalize high-frequency noise more effectively by accounting for the function's derivatives.
  3. A Posteriori Discrepancy Principle: A specific rule (based on Neubauer's work) is used to determine the regularization parameter $\alpha$. The algorithm iteratively adjusts $\alpha$ until the residual—the difference between predicted and measured data—aligns with the known noise level $\delta$.
  4. Independence from Priors: Crucially, this rule does not require the "smoothness parameter" or the "a priori bound" of the exact solution, making it significantly more practical for real-world applications.

Experimental Evaluation

The method was evaluated using synthetic numerical simulations of a 1D heat equation with a source function $f(x)$ containing exponential and cubic terms. Random Gaussian noise was injected into the "measured" data at four levels: $\delta = 10^{-1}, 10^{-2}, 10^{-3},$ and $10^{-4}$. The proposed method (M1) was benchmarked against a previously established "Modified Tikhonov" method (M2).

Key Results and Discussion

Numerical tests demonstrated that M1 consistently outperformed M2 across all noise levels and scaling parameters ($q$). The method proved to be "order optimal," meaning the reconstruction error decreases at the best possible theoretical rate as data noise is reduced.

Comparison of relative errors between the proposed method (M1) and the benchmark (M2) across various noise levels and scaling parameters.

As shown in the results, at a high noise level ($\delta = 0.1$), M1 achieved a relative error of approximately 17.3%, compared to 23.3% for M2. At the lowest noise level tested ($\delta = 0.0001$), M1's error dropped to 0.78% (for $q=0$) and reached as low as 0.02% (for $q=8$), significantly outperforming the benchmark in every scenario. The stability of the method across different scaling parameters $q$ indicates that the choice of Hilbert scale is flexible and robust.

Conclusion

By removing the need for a priori smoothness parameters and solution bounds, this research provides a practical tool for engineers who may only know their sensor's error margin. While currently demonstrated in a 1D spatial domain, the method's stability and accuracy suggest it is a promising candidate for more complex 2D or 3D applications, such as pollutant detection or structural health monitoring. Future work will focus on handling discontinuous source functions and scenarios where the noise level itself is unknown.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this paper, we consider the problem for determining an unknown source in the heat equation. The Tikhonov regularization method in Hilbert scales is presented to deal with ill-posedness of the problem and error estimates are obtained with a posteriori choice rule to find the regularization parameter. The smoothness parameter and the a priori bound of exact solution are not needed for the choice rule. Numerical tests show that the proposed method is effective and stable.
BibTeX
@article{zhao2014determination,
  author = {Zhenyu Zhao and Ou Xie and Zehong Meng and Lei You},
  title = {{Determination of an Unknown Source in the Heat Equation by the Method of Tikhonov Regularization in Hilbert Scales}},
  journal = {Journal of Applied Mathematics and Physics},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.4236/jamp.2014.22002},
}
Figure