Determination and evaluation of the nonadditivity in wetting of molecularly heterogeneous surfaces

Zhi Luo, Anna Murello, David M. Wilkins, Filip Kovacik, Joachim Kohlbrecher, Aurel Rădulescu, Halil İ. Okur, Quy K. Ong, Sylvie Roke, Michele Ceriotti, Francesco StellacciProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper challenges the long-held assumption that surface properties like wetting are simply additive, especially for complex, "patchy" surfaces like those found on proteins. By combining experimental measurements with molecular dynamics simulations, the authors demonstrate significant non-additive effects in how water interacts with these surfaces, proposing a new model that considers local molecular arrangements.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The behavior of liquids at interfaces is crucial in many scientific and engineering fields, from biology to materials science. For simple, uniform surfaces, classical thermodynamic models like Cassie's equation (CE) predict that the overall interfacial properties (like the work of adhesion, WSL) are simply the weighted average of the properties of different components. However, real-world surfaces, particularly biological ones like proteins, are often "patchy," meaning they have distinct regions with varying chemical properties (e.g., hydrophobic and hydrophilic patches). While computational studies have suggested that these patchiness effects lead to non-additive wetting behavior, there's been a lack of conclusive experimental evidence to support this and no robust theoretical framework to explain it. This paper aims to bridge this gap by experimentally investigating and theoretically modeling the non-additive wetting of molecularly heterogeneous surfaces.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Model System Design: They synthesized gold nanoparticles coated with a binary mixture of hydrophobic (1-octanethiol, OT) and hydrophilic (3-mercaptopropionic acid, MPA) ligands. Crucially, they created two sets of nanoparticles that were identical in ligand composition but differed in the organization of these ligands – one with a "patchy" arrangement and another with a "stripelike" arrangement, achieved through controlled thermal treatment.
  • Characterization Techniques: A suite of techniques was used to confirm the nanoparticles' properties:
  • Small-Angle X-ray Scattering (SAXS): To verify the gold core size and polydispersity remained unchanged.
  • Nuclear Magnetic Resonance (NMR) and Thermogravimetric Analysis (TGA): To confirm the ligand composition and density were identical between the two nanoparticle sets.
  • Fourier-Transform Infrared Spectroscopy (FTIR): To ensure the chemical state of the ligands (e.g., protonation) was consistent.
  • Small-Angle Neutron Scattering (SANS): This was the key technique to reveal differences in the morphology of the ligand shells, showing distinct patchy vs. stripelike structures.
  • Vibrational Sum-Frequency Generation (SFG): A surface-sensitive technique used to probe the structure of interfacial water, specifically its hydrogen bonding.
  • Contact Angle Measurements and Atomic Force Microscopy (AFM): Used to measure the solid-liquid work of adhesion (WSL) on films of these nanoparticles.
  • Molecular Dynamics (MD) Simulations: Large-scale MD simulations were performed to model water interacting with surfaces mimicking the patchy and stripelike ligand arrangements. These simulations helped to understand the structure of interfacial water and the distribution of water dipoles.
  • Predictive Model Development: Based on the simulation insights, a linear regression model was developed. This model predicts excess interfacial properties (like water density and dipole orientation) based on the first-nearest neighbors of each molecule on the surface, treating long-range interactions as a mean field.

Datasets

The paper introduces a new experimental dataset generated from the characterization of the synthesized nanoparticles and their interactions with various solvents. This includes:

  • SAXS, SANS, NMR, TGA, FTIR, SFG, and contact angle/AFM measurements for the two distinct nanoparticle morphologies (patchy and stripelike).
  • WSL measurements for both nanoparticle types across a range of solvents with varying effective molecular volumes.
  • MD simulation data detailing water density and dipole orientation profiles at the interfaces.

The authors also refer to previously published data (ref. 17) on the saturation concentration of nanoparticles in various solvents, which they re-evaluate to support their findings.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Patchiness Matters: Non-Additive Wetting is Real: The most significant insight is the experimental and theoretical confirmation that the arrangement of chemical groups on a surface, not just their overall composition, profoundly affects interfacial properties like wetting. This directly challenges the additive assumption of Cassie's equation for complex surfaces.
  • Interfacial Water Structure is Sensitive to Morphology: SFG measurements revealed distinct differences in the hydrogen bonding of water molecules at the interfaces of the patchy versus stripelike nanoparticles, indicating that the water structure is not simply dictated by the average surface chemistry.
  • First-Nearest Neighbors are Key: The MD simulations and subsequent model development highlight the critical role of immediate molecular neighbors in determining interfacial behavior. This suggests that local ordering and interactions are more important than global surface properties for understanding non-additive effects.
  • Solvent Size Dictates Non-Additivity: The study found that non-additive effects in WSL are most pronounced for solvents with effective molecular diameters smaller than approximately 6 Å. This is attributed to their ability to probe and be influenced by the fine-scale heterogeneity of the surface.

Key Results

  • WSL Differences: The work of adhesion (WSL) for the stripelike nanoparticles was found to be approximately 20% different from that of the patchy nanoparticles, with the stripelike surfaces being more hydrophobic. This difference was validated by two independent techniques (contact angle and AFM).
  • Interfacial Water Differences: SFG spectra showed significant differences in the O-D stretch region, indicating distinct intermolecular H-bond environments for water at the patchy vs. stripelike interfaces.
  • MD Simulation Agreement: Molecular dynamics simulations successfully captured the observed differences in interfacial water structure and dipole orientation, correlating them with the distinct surface morphologies.
  • Predictive Model Success: The developed linear regression model, based on first-nearest neighbor interactions, accurately predicted excess interfacial properties for both patchy and stripelike surfaces, demonstrating its predictive power.
  • Solvent Dependence: Significant differences in WSL were observed for solvents with effective volumes below ~125 ų (diameter ~6 Å), while larger solvents showed minimal differences, confirming the hypothesis about solvent size.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model System vs. Biological Complexity: The authors acknowledge that their model compounds, while effective, are simplified representations. Extending these findings to the dynamic and highly complex nature of biological interfaces, such as those of proteins, will require significant further development.
  • Dynamical Nature of Peptides: The current model does not fully account for the dynamical nature of peptides and proteins, which could introduce additional complexities to interfacial interactions.
  • Predictive Power for Solvent Interactions: While the model successfully predicts the existence and magnitude of non-additive effects based on solvent size, predicting the precise variations in WSL for small solvents remains challenging, suggesting that other solvent properties (polarity, polarizability, etc.) play a role that is not yet fully captured.
  • Future Directions: The authors propose that their work provides a foundation for developing a more comprehensive understanding of complex biological interfaces and for engineering synthetic surfaces with tailored wetting properties. Future work could focus on incorporating dynamic effects and exploring a wider range of solvent properties for more precise predictions.

Summary updated

Abstract

The interface between water and folded proteins is very complex. Proteins have "patchy" solvent-accessible areas composed of domains of varying hydrophobicity. The textbook understanding is that these domains contribute additively to interfacial properties (Cassie's equation, CE). An ever-growing number of modeling papers question the validity of CE at molecular length scales, but there is no conclusive experiment to support this and no proposed new theoretical framework. Here, we study the wetting of model compounds with patchy surfaces differing solely in patchiness but not in composition. Were CE to be correct, these materials would have had the same solid-liquid work of adhesion (<i>W</i><sub><i>SL</i></sub> ) and time-averaged structure of interfacial water. We find considerable differences in <i>W</i><sub><i>SL</i></sub> , and sum-frequency generation measurements of the interfacial water structure show distinctively different spectral features. Molecular-dynamics simulations of water on patchy surfaces capture the observed behaviors and point toward significant nonadditivity in water density and average orientation. They show that a description of the molecular arrangement on the surface is needed to predict its wetting properties. We propose a predictive model that considers, for every molecule, the contributions of its first-nearest neighbors as a descriptor to determine the wetting properties of the surface. The model is validated by measurements of <i>W</i><sub><i>SL</i></sub> in multiple solvents, where large differences are observed for solvents whose effective diameter is smaller than ∼6 Å. The experiments and theoretical model proposed here provide a starting point to develop a comprehensive understanding of complex biological interfaces as well as for the engineering of synthetic ones.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{luo2019determination,
  author = {Zhi Luo and Anna Murello and David M. Wilkins and Filip Kovacik and Joachim Kohlbrecher and Aurel Rădulescu and Halil İ. Okur and Quy K. Ong and Sylvie Roke and Michele Ceriotti and Francesco Stellacci},
  title = {{Determination and evaluation of the nonadditivity in wetting of molecularly heterogeneous surfaces}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1073/pnas.1916180116},
}
Figure