Determinants of the Mobile Health Continuance Intention of Elders with Chronic Diseases: An Integrated Framework of ECM-ISC and UTAUT

Xiu-Fu Tian, Runze WuInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates why elderly individuals with chronic diseases continue to use mobile health (mHealth) services in China. By integrating two established models (ECM-ISC and UTAUT), the research identifies key factors like performance expectancy, satisfaction, social influence, and facilitating conditions that drive continued mHealth adoption, offering practical insights for improving these services.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper addresses a critical gap in understanding the long-term adoption of mobile health (mHealth) services, specifically among the elderly population in China who are disproportionately affected by chronic diseases. While mHealth holds immense potential for managing these conditions and alleviating healthcare burdens, its value is only realized through sustained use. Existing research has largely focused on initial adoption rather than the factors influencing continued engagement. This is particularly problematic for older adults, who may face unique challenges with technology adoption and have specific health needs. The study aims to fill this void by empirically examining the determinants of mHealth continuance intention in this demographic.

Methods

The researchers employed a quantitative approach using Structural Equation Modeling (SEM) to analyze data collected through questionnaires. They integrated two theoretical frameworks:

  • ECM-ISC (Expectation-Confirmation Model of Information System Continuance): This model focuses on how users' initial expectations are confirmed by their experience, leading to satisfaction and subsequent continuance intention.
  • UTAUT (Unified Theory of Acceptance and Usage of Technology): This model examines factors like performance expectancy, effort expectancy, social influence, and facilitating conditions that influence technology adoption and usage.

By combining these models, the researchers aimed to create a more comprehensive framework to explain mHealth continuance intention, overcoming the limitations of each individual model. The SEM analysis allowed them to test multiple hypotheses simultaneously and assess the causal relationships between the identified factors and continuance intention.

Datasets

The study utilized data collected from a questionnaire administered to elders with chronic diseases in China. A total of 1453 valid questionnaires were collected, with 926 obtained online and 527 offline. The data was analyzed using IBM SPSS v23.0 and IBM AMOS v23.0. No new benchmark datasets were introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Performance is King (for continued use): The most significant driver for elderly individuals with chronic diseases to continue using mHealth is the perceived performance of the service – how well it actually helps them manage their health. This suggests that functionality and tangible benefits are paramount.
  • Confirmation Sets the Stage: Initial positive experiences (confirmation of expectations) are crucial. When mHealth meets or exceeds users' initial hopes, it positively impacts their satisfaction, perceived usefulness, and ease of use, laying the groundwork for continued engagement.
  • Satisfaction is a Bridge: While direct influences exist, satisfaction acts as a key intermediary. When users are satisfied with mHealth, they are more likely to continue using it. This satisfaction is, in turn, influenced by how well the service performs and how easy it is to use.
  • Social Echoes Matter: The opinions and behaviors of people around the elderly users (social influence) play a significant role in their decision to continue using mHealth. Positive encouragement from family, friends, or healthcare providers can boost adoption.
  • Enabling Environments are Essential: The availability of necessary technology and support (facilitating conditions) is also a direct predictor of continued mHealth use. This includes having the right devices and access to helpful resources.

Key Results

The integrated ECM-ISC and UTAUT model explained a substantial 61.7% of the variance in mHealth continuance intention.

  • Direct Influences on Continuance Intention:
    • Performance Expectancy: Had the strongest direct positive influence (β = 0.383).
  • Effort Expectancy: Also had a significant positive influence (β = 0.319).
  • Social Influence: Showed a positive influence (β = 0.273).
  • Facilitating Conditions: Had a positive influence (β = 0.214).
  • Satisfaction: Directly influenced continuance intention (β = 0.171).
  • Influences on Satisfaction:
    • Performance Expectancy: Was the most significant predictor of satisfaction (β = 0.360).
  • Effort Expectancy: Also positively influenced satisfaction (β = 0.319).
  • Confirmation: Directly influenced satisfaction (β = 0.304).
  • Confirmation's Impact: Confirmation significantly influenced performance expectancy (β = 0.457) and effort expectancy (β = 0.478), highlighting its foundational role.

All ten hypotheses tested in the study were supported.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Limited Scope of Factors: While the integrated model is robust, future research could incorporate additional factors like perceived value, trust, and privacy to further enhance the model's scientificity and feasibility.
  • Geographic Specificity: The study was conducted solely in China. The findings might not be universally applicable to other countries, and further verification in different cultural contexts is recommended.
  • Focus on Chronic Diseases: The study exclusively focused on elders with chronic diseases. Future research could explore differences in continuance intention between patients with acute versus chronic conditions.

The authors suggest that future research should continue to explore mHealth user adoption using these theoretical frameworks and consider integrating them with other relevant theories. They also propose that mHealth operators should focus on improving service functionality, user experience, and providing clear support to enhance continuance intention among the elderly.

Summary updated

Abstract

With the deepening of population aging in China, chronic diseases are a major public health concern that threatens the life and health of nationals. Mobile health or mHealth can effectively monitor chronic diseases, which holds vital significance to the alleviation of social pressure caused by aging. To patients with chronic diseases, mHealth cannot give full play to its value, only when it is used in the long term. However, there is not yet research exploring mHealth continuance intention from the perspective of elders with chronic diseases. So, this research represents the first attempt to empirically analyze mHealth continuance intention from the perspective of elders with chronic diseases. The purpose of this research is to make up the research gap of the mHealth field and to put forward theoretical and practical implications based on research results. To obtain research data, a questionnaire was conducted. A total of 926 copies were collected online and 527 copies were collected offline. The structural equation model (SEM) was used for data analysis. Research results suggest that confirmation can significantly influence satisfaction, performance expectancy and effort expectancy. Meanwhile, confirmation and performance expectancy can significantly influence satisfaction. Additionally, effort expectancy, performance expectancy, social influence and facilitating conditions can directly and significantly influence continuance intention. Among them, performance expectancy can directly influence continuance intention in the most significant way. This research provides solid evidence for the validity of the integrated model of ECM-ISC and UTAUT in the mHealth field, which can be a theoretical basis for mHealth operators' product R&D.
BibTeX
@article{tian2022determinants,
  author = {Xiu-Fu Tian and Runze Wu},
  title = {{Determinants of the Mobile Health Continuance Intention of Elders with Chronic Diseases: An Integrated Framework of ECM-ISC and UTAUT}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph19169980},
}
Figure