Determinants of successful guideline implementation: a national cross-sectional survey

Ying-Hui Jin, Li-Ming Tan, Khalid S. Khan, Tong Deng, Chao Huang, Fei Han, Jing Zhang, Qiao Huang, Di Huang, Dan-qi Wang, Yu Wang, Xiantao Zeng, Qiang Wang, Xing-huan WangBMC Medical Informatics Decis. Mak 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigated the factors influencing the adoption and adherence to clinical practice guidelines (CPGs) among healthcare professionals in China. It found that while CPGs are generally valued, their implementation faces significant barriers, particularly a lack of education and training, and issues with guideline clarity and scope. Adherence is influenced by regional factors, hospital grade, practitioner experience, education level, and specialty.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Clinical Practice Guidelines (CPGs) are intended to improve healthcare quality by providing evidence-based recommendations. However, their successful implementation is often hindered, leading to suboptimal patient outcomes and wasted resources. Despite the increasing number of CPGs, there's a persistent gap in understanding the specific barriers and enablers to their adoption and adherence, especially in diverse healthcare systems like China's. This paper aims to fill this gap by conducting a national survey to identify the determinants of successful CPG implementation and explore factors associated with adherence among Chinese healthcare practitioners.

Methods

The study employed a cross-sectional survey design using a multi-stage stratified sampling method across China's economic regions. A bespoke questionnaire was developed, drawing on existing frameworks for guideline use, literature analysis, and behavior change theories. The questionnaire covered participants' knowledge of guideline development, barriers to acquisition and implementation, and methods for improvement. Multivariate logistic regression was used to analyze the data, identifying independent determinants of guideline adherence. The survey was piloted and tested for reliability, achieving a test-retest reliability coefficient of 0.80.

Datasets

The study utilized data collected from a national survey of 1732 healthcare practitioners across 51 hospitals in China. The data was analyzed using SPSS. No new benchmarks were introduced, and the dataset is described as available from the corresponding author upon reasonable request.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • "Knowing is not enough": Positive attitudes towards CPGs and knowledge of their development methodology do not automatically translate into guideline use or adherence. This highlights the complexity of implementation beyond mere awareness.
  • Education is Key: "Lack of education or training in guideline use" emerged as the most significant barrier to implementation. This underscores the need for targeted educational programs for healthcare professionals.
  • Clarity and Scope Matter: Overly simplistic wording or overly broad recommendations were also major barriers. This suggests that guidelines need to be practical, specific, and easily applicable to real-world clinical scenarios.
  • Context is Crucial: Adherence varies significantly by geographical region, hospital grade, and even medical specialty. This implies that implementation strategies need to be tailored to these contextual factors.
  • Experience and Education Drive Adherence: Longer years of practice and higher educational attainment (Master's and PhD) were associated with higher adherence, suggesting that experienced and well-educated practitioners are more likely to adopt guidelines.

Key Results

  • High Usage, but Room for Improvement: 77.2% of participants reported using guidelines frequently or very frequently, but the study identified significant barriers.
  • Top Barriers: The most frequently cited barriers to guideline implementation were "lack of education or training" (46.2%) and "wording of recommendations were too simple or the scope of the recommendations were too broad" (43.8%).
  • Regional Differences: Participants in the Northeast, Middle, and West regions were more likely to consider using guidelines compared to those in the East.
  • Hospital Grade Impact: Participants in secondary public hospitals showed higher self-reported guideline adherence than those in tertiary public hospitals.
  • Significant Determinants of Adherence (Multivariate Analysis):
    • Region: Northeast (OR 2.02), West (OR 1.53), Middle (OR 2.16) compared to East.
  • Hospital Grade: Secondary hospitals had higher adherence (OR 0.70, indicating lower adherence in tertiary hospitals).
  • Years of Practice: Each additional year of practice was associated with higher adherence (OR 1.03).
  • Education Background: PhD (OR 1.90) and Master's (OR 2.11) degrees were associated with higher adherence compared to Junior college.
  • EBM Skills: EBM skills acquired in the work unit were associated with higher adherence (OR 1.44).
  • Specialty: General Practice (OR 2.06) and Surgery (OR 1.49) specialties showed higher adherence.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Geographical Omission: Hong Kong, Macao, and Taiwan were not included, potentially limiting generalizability to all of China.
  • Exclusion of Primary Care: First-level hospitals and grass-roots medical and health institutions were not included, which might affect the representativeness of findings for primary care settings.
  • Cross-Sectional Design: The study design limits the ability to infer causal relationships between identified factors and guideline adherence.
  • Self-Reported Data: Reliance on self-reported data may introduce social desirability bias, potentially leading to an overestimation of guideline use and adherence.

Future work should focus on developing implementation strategies that address the identified barriers, particularly through targeted education and by improving the clarity and applicability of guidelines. The authors suggest that guideline development should be more inclusive, focusing on unambiguous presentation and providing bespoke implementation tools. They also emphasize the need for training medical staff to embrace guidelines and for implementation plans to be bespoke and tailored to specific contexts.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{jin2021determinants,
  author = {Ying-Hui Jin and Li-Ming Tan and Khalid S. Khan and Tong Deng and Chao Huang and Fei Han and Jing Zhang and Qiao Huang and Di Huang and Dan-qi Wang and Yu Wang and Xiantao Zeng and Qiang Wang and Xing-huan Wang},
  title = {{Determinants of successful guideline implementation: a national cross-sectional survey}},
  journal = {BMC Medical Informatics Decis. Mak.},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1186/s12911-020-01382-w},
}
Figure