Determinants of Bowel Preparation Quality and Its Association With Adenoma Detection

Martin C. S. Wong, Jessica Y. L. Ching, Victor Chan, Thomas Y. Lam, Arthur K.c. Luk, Raymond S. Tang, Sunny H. Wong, Siew C. Ng, Simon S.m. Ng, Justin C. Wu, Francis K.l. Chan, Joseph J.�y. SungMedicine 2016 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigated factors influencing bowel preparation quality during colonoscopies and its impact on detecting colorectal neoplasia in a large Asian cohort. They found that older age, male sex, and current smoking are significant predictors of poor bowel prep, which in turn, is associated with a substantially lower detection rate of polyps. This highlights the critical role of adequate bowel cleansing as a quality indicator for effective colonoscopy screening.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Colorectal cancer (CRC) screening is crucial for reducing mortality, and colonoscopy is a primary method for detection and removal of precancerous lesions (adenomas). However, the effectiveness of colonoscopy hinges on a clear view of the colon lining, which is achieved through proper bowel preparation. Inadequate bowel preparation can lead to missed lesions, increased procedure time, and the need for repeat examinations, all of which impact screening efficacy and healthcare costs. While the importance of bowel prep is recognized, the specific factors that predict poor preparation and its precise association with adenoma detection, especially in non-Western populations, have not been thoroughly studied. This paper aims to fill this gap by identifying determinants of poor bowel preparation and quantifying its impact on adenoma detection rates in a large, prospective screening cohort in Hong Kong.

Methods

The researchers conducted a prospective observational study involving 5470 participants aged 50-70 undergoing colonoscopy for CRC screening between 2008 and 2014.

  • Bowel Preparation Assessment: Colonoscopists, trained on standardized guidelines (ASGE/AGA), rated the quality of bowel preparation using terms like "excellent," "good," "fair," and "poor." For analysis, "poor" and "fair" were grouped as "poor/fair" preparation.
  • Determinant Analysis: Binary logistic regression was used to identify factors associated with poor/fair bowel preparation.
  • Adenoma Detection Association: Separate binary logistic regression models were employed to assess the relationship between bowel preparation quality and the detection of colorectal neoplasia (any type) and advanced colorectal neoplasia.
  • Covariates: A comprehensive set of covariates was collected, including sociodemographic information (age, sex, education, income), lifestyle factors (smoking, alcohol), medical history (hypertension, diabetes), and risk assessment scores (APCS).
  • Statistical Modeling: Multivariate regression models were used to control for confounding factors. Sensitivity analyses were performed to account for inter-physician variability.

Datasets

The study utilized data from 5470 participants in a colorectal cancer screening program in Hong Kong. This dataset is unique as it represents a large, prospective cohort from the Asia Pacific region undergoing screening colonoscopies. The data collected included detailed participant characteristics, colonoscopy findings, and bowel preparation quality ratings. No new benchmarks were introduced; rather, the study contributes to understanding these relationships within a specific demographic and geographic context.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Predictable Poor Prep: It's not entirely random who gets poor bowel prep. Factors like being older (≥60), male, and a current smoker significantly increase the odds of having a less-than-ideal colon cleanse. This suggests targeted interventions for these groups could be beneficial.
  • Prep Quality Matters for Detection: The study strongly links poor bowel preparation to a significantly lower chance of detecting polyps, including advanced ones. This isn't just about a slightly less clear view; it's a substantial reduction in the ability to find potentially cancerous lesions.
  • Quality Indicator Confirmed: The findings reinforce the idea that bowel preparation quality is a crucial, auditable outcome for colonoscopy. It's not just a procedural step but a direct determinant of the screening test's effectiveness.
  • Asian Cohort Specifics: While many studies are Western-based, this research provides valuable insights into these associations within an Asian population, which may have different lifestyle factors and genetic predispositions.

Key Results

  • Prevalence of Poor Prep: 34.6% of participants had poor or fair bowel preparation.
  • Predictors of Poor Prep:
    • Older age (≥60 years): Adjusted Odds Ratio (AOR) 1.19-1.38.
  • Male sex: AOR 1.38.
  • Current smoking: AOR 1.41.
  • Impact on Adenoma Detection:
    • Compared to excellent preparation, good preparation was associated with a 65% lower detection rate of any colorectal neoplasia (AOR=0.354).
  • Poor/fair preparation was associated with a 60% lower detection rate of any colorectal neoplasia (AOR=0.406).
  • Similar significant reductions were observed for advanced colorectal neoplasia.
  • Procedure Times: Poorer bowel preparation was associated with longer cecal intubation and colonoscopy withdrawal times.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Subjectivity: Bowel preparation quality assessment, while standardized, can still be subjective, leading to potential interobserver bias.
  • Procedure Time Measurement: The exact time spent on lesion removal was not specifically measured, only the overall withdrawal time.
  • Lack of Follow-up: The study did not include follow-up procedures to assess the actual incidence of interval cancers or missed lesions.
  • Observational Design: The study design is observational, meaning it can show associations but not definitively prove causation.
  • Single Preparation Agent: Only polyethylene glycol (PEG) was tested, and other bowel preparation agents might have different efficacy and tolerability profiles.

Future work suggested includes:

  • Developing more intensive preparation protocols for individuals identified as high-risk for poor bowel prep.
  • Implementing strategies to improve patient understanding and compliance with preparation instructions.
  • Further research to understand the underlying reasons for poor bowel preparation in specific groups and to devise targeted interventions.
  • Evaluating the impact of different bowel preparation agents.

Summary updated

Abstract

The predictors of poor bowel preparation in colorectal cancer screening participants have not been adequately studied, and the association between the quality of bowel preparation and adenoma detection has not been firmly established. This study examined the determinants of poor bowel preparation, and evaluated its relationship with adenoma detection.We included subjects aged between 50 and 70 years who received colonoscopy between 2008 and 2014 in a colorectal cancer screening program in Hong Kong. The quality of the bowel preparation was assessed by colonoscopists, and the factors associated with poor bowel cleansing were evaluated by a binary logistic regression analysis. A multivariate regression model was constructed to evaluate if poor bowel preparation was associated with detection of colorectal neoplasia.From 5470 screening participants (average age 57.7 years, SD 4.9), 1891 (34.6%) had poor or fair bowel preparation. The average cecal intubation time was 7.0 minutes (SD 5.4; range 1.22-36.9 minutes) and the average colonoscopy withdrawal time was 10.8 minutes (SD 6.9; range 6.0-107.0 minutes). Among all, 26.5% had colorectal neoplasia and 5.5% had advanced neoplasia. Older age (≥60 years; adjusted odds ratio [AOR] = 1.19-1.38, P = 0.02-0.04), male sex (AOR = 1.38, 95% confidence interval [CI] 1.19-1.60, P < 0.001), and current smoking (AOR = 1.41, 95% CI 1.14-1.75, P = 0.002) were significantly associated with poor/fair bowel preparation. Poorer cleansing resulted in significantly lower detection rate of neoplasia (AOR = 0.35-0.62) and advanced neoplasia (AOR = 0.36-0.50) irrespective of polyp size.Steps to improve proper procedures of bowel preparation are warranted, especially among subjects at risk of poor bowel preparation. Strategies should be implemented to improve bowel cleansing, which is now demonstrated as a definite quality indicator.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wong2016determinants,
  author = {Martin C. S. Wong and Jessica Y. L. Ching and Victor Chan and Thomas Y. Lam and Arthur K.C. Luk and Raymond S. Tang and Sunny H. Wong and Siew C. Ng and Simon S.M. Ng and Justin C. Wu and Francis K.L. Chan and Joseph J.�Y. Sung},
  title = {{Determinants of Bowel Preparation Quality and Its Association With Adenoma Detection}},
  booktitle = {Medicine},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.1097/md.0000000000002251},
}
Figure