Detector optimization to reduce the cosmogenic neutron backgrounds in the TAO experiment

Ruhui Li, G. F. Cao, Jun Cao, Yufeng Li, Y. F. Wang, Zhimin Wang, Liang ZhanJournal of Instrumentation 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper tackles the significant challenge of cosmogenic neutron backgrounds in the TAO experiment, a shallow-underburden reactor antineutrino detector. By employing detailed simulations, the researchers propose and evaluate several optimization strategies, including doping the buffer liquid with Gadolinium, adding a polyethylene layer, and refining the veto strategy. These combined efforts successfully reduce the neutron background-to-signal ratio from an initial ~10% to a promising ~2%.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Reactor antineutrino experiments, especially those designed for short-baseline measurements, often operate with very shallow overburden (e.g., 10 meters of water equivalent). This lack of shielding makes them highly susceptible to backgrounds from cosmic ray-induced neutrons, known as cosmogenic neutron backgrounds. These neutrons can mimic the signal of an antineutrino interaction, leading to misinterpretations of the data. The TAO experiment, aiming to precisely measure the reactor antineutrino spectrum for the JUNO experiment and to test nuclear databases, faces this challenge directly. With an estimated ~10% of its signal being due to cosmogenic neutrons, reducing this background is crucial for achieving the experiment's high-precision goals.

Methods

The core of this study relies on detailed Monte Carlo simulations using the Geant4 toolkit. The researchers meticulously modeled the TAO detector's geometry and its surrounding laboratory environment. They simulated the production of neutrons from cosmic ray muons interacting with various detector components and the surrounding rock.

To combat these neutron backgrounds, they investigated three primary optimization strategies:

  • Doping the buffer liquid with Gadolinium (Gd): Gadolinium has a high neutron capture cross-section, significantly shortening the neutron capture time. This helps to reduce the probability of a neutron being captured and producing a delayed signal that could be mistaken for an antineutrino event.
  • Adding a High-Density Polyethylene (HDPE) layer: HDPE is rich in hydrogen, which is an effective moderator for neutrons. Adding a layer of HDPE between the lead shielding and the detector aims to slow down neutrons produced by interactions with the lead, making them less likely to enter the sensitive detector volume.
  • Optimizing the veto strategy: The experiment employs a veto system to reject events correlated with cosmic ray muons. This involves defining time windows after a muon detection during which subsequent signals are considered background. The paper explores different veto time durations for various types of muon-related backgrounds to balance background rejection efficiency with detector live time.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on simulated data generated through Monte Carlo simulations.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Copper Shell is a significant neutron source: Simulations revealed that the Copper Shell surrounding the detector is a primary source of neutrons contributing to the double-neutron background. This is likely due to its proximity to the neutrino target and its high-Z material composition.
  • Gadolinium doping is highly effective for double-neutron backgrounds: Adding Gadolinium to the buffer liquid dramatically reduces the neutron capture time, effectively suppressing double-neutron events, particularly those originating from the Copper Shell.
  • HDPE shielding is crucial for lead-induced neutrons: The addition of an HDPE layer between the lead shielding and the detector significantly mitigates neutron backgrounds originating from the lead, which is a potent neutron producer.
  • Veto strategy optimization is a delicate balance: The choice of veto time is a trade-off between rejecting neutron backgrounds and minimizing detector dead time. The optimal strategy involves different veto durations for different types of muon-related events.
  • Fiducial volume cuts are powerful: Applying a fiducial volume cut (rejecting events near the detector edge) is highly effective in rejecting double-neutron backgrounds, as many of these events originate from the outer regions of the detector.

Key Results

The study successfully reduced the cosmogenic neutron background-to-signal ratio from an initial estimate of ~10% to approximately 2%. Specifically:

  • Adding 0.1% Gd to the buffer liquid and applying a fiducial volume cut reduced double-neutron backgrounds by over 40%.
  • Adding a 10-cm HDPE layer above the lead shielding reduced neutron backgrounds from lead by about 75%.
  • Optimizing the veto strategy balanced detector live time and background rejection.
  • The final optimized detector design and veto strategy, combined with a fiducial volume cut, resulted in a background-to-signal ratio of 2% for cosmogenic neutron backgrounds. This is a significant improvement over the ~10% estimated in the TAO Conceptual Design Report.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Simplified simulation: The simulations did not include optical simulation, electronics simulation, or reconstruction. While the authors expect this simplification not to significantly alter the conclusions, a full simulation would provide a more complete picture.
  • Conservative background uncertainty estimation: The background uncertainty was estimated conservatively using reactor-off data. Real data analysis might allow for a more refined estimation.
  • Pulse shape discrimination: The paper mentions that pulse shape discrimination could further suppress fast-neutron backgrounds, suggesting this as a potential avenue for future improvement.
  • Further optimization of veto strategy: While optimized, the veto strategy could potentially be further refined with real data.

The paper concludes that the proposed optimizations significantly improve the performance of the TAO experiment in mitigating cosmogenic neutron backgrounds, paving the way for precise measurements of the reactor antineutrino spectrum.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Short-baseline reactor antineutrino experiments with shallow overburden usually have large cosmogenic neutron backgrounds. The Taishan Antineutrino Observatory (TAO) is a ton-level liquid scintillator detector located at about 30 m from a core of the Taishan Nuclear Power Plant. It will measure the reactor antineutrino spectrum with high precision and high energy resolution to provide a reference spectrum for JUNO and other reactor antineutrino experiments, and provide a benchmark measurement to test nuclear databases. Background is one of the critical concerns of TAO since the overburden is just 10 meter-water-equivalent. The cosmogenic neutron background was estimated to be ∼10% of signals [1]. With detailed Monte Carlo simulations, we propose several measures in this work to reduce the neutron backgrounds, including doping Gadolinium in the buffer liquid, adding a polyethylene layer above the bottom lead shield, and optimization of the veto strategy. With these improvements, the neutron background-to-signal ratio can be reduced to ∼2%, and might be further suppressed with pulse shape discrimination.
BibTeX
@article{li2022detector,
  author = {Ruhui Li and G. F. Cao and Jun Cao and Yufeng Li and Y. F. Wang and Zhimin Wang and Liang Zhan},
  title = {{Detector optimization to reduce the cosmogenic neutron backgrounds in the TAO experiment}},
  journal = {Journal of Instrumentation},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1088/1748-0221/17/09/p09024},
}
Figure