Detection Rate Estimates of Gravity Waves Emitted during Parabolic Encounters of Stellar Black Holes in Globular Clusters

Bence Kocsis, Merse E Gáspár, Szabolcs MárkaThe Astrophysical Journal 2006 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

The rapid advance of gravitational wave (GW) detector facilities makes it very important to estimate the event rates of possible detection candidates. We consider an additional possibility of GW bursts produced during parabolic encounters (PEs) of stellar-mass compact objects in globular clusters (GCs). We estimate the rate of successful detections for specific detectors: the initial Laser Interferometric Gravitational-Wave Observatory (InLIGO), the French-Italian gravitational wave antenna VIRGO, the near-future Advanced-LIGO(AdLIGO), the space-based Laser Interferometric Space Antenna (LISA), and the Next Generation LISA (NGLISA). Simple GC models are constructed to account for the compact object mass function, mass segregation, number density distribution, and velocity distribution. We both calculate encounters classically and account for general relativistic corrections by extrapolating the results for infinite mass ratios. We also include the cosmological redshift of waveforms and event rates. We find that typical PEs with masses $m_1 = m_2 = 40M_\odot$ are detectable with matched filtering over a signal-to-noise ratio $S/N = 5$ within a distance $d_L \sim 200$ Mpc for InLIGO and VIRGO, $z = 1$ for AdLIGO, 0.4 Mpc for LISA, and 1 Gpc for NGLISA. We estimate single data stream detection rates of $5.5 \times 10^{-5}$ yr$^{-1}$ for InLIGO, $7.2 \times 10^{-5}$ yr$^{-1}$ for VIRGO, 0.063 yr$^{-1}$ for AdLIGO, $2.9 \times 10^{-6}$ yr$^{-1}$ for LISA, and 1.0 yr$^{-1}$ for NGLISA, for reasonably conservative assumptions. These estimates are subject to uncertainties in the GC parameters, most importantly the total number and mass distribution of BHs in the cluster core. In reasonably optimistic cases, we get $\ge 1$ detection for AdLIGO per year. We expect that a coincident analysis using multiple detectors and accounting for GW recoil capture significantly increases the detection rates. The regular detection of GWs during PEs would provide a unique observational probe for constraining the stellar BH mass function of dense clusters.

Introduction: The Challenge of Detecting Parabolic Encounters

Most gravitational wave (GW) astronomy focuses on "compact binary coalescences"—the terminal inspiral of black holes (BHs) or neutron stars (NSs) that have been orbitally bound for long periods. However, dense environments like globular clusters (GCs) act as crowded dynamical systems where unbound objects can interact. This paper investigates the potential for detecting GW "bursts" produced during parabolic encounters (PEs), where two stellar-mass black holes whip past each other in a single, high-energy flyby.

While earlier estimates suggested these events were too rare for detection, this study re-evaluates those claims by integrating modern detector sensitivity curves with sophisticated astrophysical models of cluster dynamics. The goal is to determine if these flyby bursts can serve as a viable signal for current and next-generation observatories.

Modeling Methodology: From Waveforms to Cluster Dynamics

The researchers employed a multi-step modeling approach to refine rate estimates. Waveform modeling began with classical Newtonian approximations for GW emission during a PE, subsequently enhanced with general relativistic corrections to account for the increased energy output and modified trajectories occurring at close proximity (within a few Schwarzschild radii).

Crucially, the study compared two distinct globular cluster models:

  • Model I: A baseline homogeneous sphere where all objects share uniform mass and velocity.
  • Model II: A realistic model accounting for mass segregation—where heavier BHs sink toward the cluster center—and a varied mass function for the BH population.

Detection simulations utilized matched filtering to calculate the Signal-to-Noise Ratio (SNR) across various detectors, including AdLIGO and NGLISA, while accounting for cosmological redshift effects that stretch signals and lower their frequency during transit.

Results: The Impact of Mass Segregation and Detector Sensitivity

A primary finding of the study is that mass segregation is a critical factor in event rate estimation. Transitioning from the homogeneous Model I to the segregated Model II increases the predicted event rate by approximately two orders of magnitude. Because BHs are significantly more massive than the average cluster star, they congregate in the dense core, dramatically increasing their collision cross-section.

Estimated event rates per globular cluster as a function of frequency for two different cluster models. Model II, which accounts for mass segregation, shows a rate increase of approximately two orders of magnitude over the simpler Model I.

The feasibility of detecting these events depends heavily on the sensitivity of the instruments. While initial detectors like InLIGO and VIRGO have limited range, next-generation facilities offer significant promise.

Strain sensitivity curves for various GW detectors. The plot highlights the frequency bands and sensitivity levels of InLIGO, VIRGO, AdLIGO, LISA, and NGLISA, which are critical for detecting parabolic encounter bursts.

Under reasonably optimistic conditions, AdLIGO is expected to achieve roughly 1 detection per year. NGLISA, a space-based detector, is even more capable, with an estimated rate of 1.0 detection per year. For encounters involving two $40 M_\odot$ black holes, AdLIGO can detect signals out to a redshift of $z=1$, effectively probing halfway across the observable universe.

Discussion: Probing the Invisible Populations of Globular Clusters

Despite the promising rates, several uncertainties remain. The retention of black holes within clusters is a major variable, as dynamical interactions often eject BHs from the system. Furthermore, if a cluster undergoes "core collapse," the density of BHs could increase detection rates by several orders of magnitude beyond current estimates.

Detecting GWs from parabolic encounters would provide a unique observational probe. Unlike traditional electromagnetic telescopes, which struggle to observe black hole populations in dense clusters, GW bursts offer a direct way to constrain the BH mass function. Future work incorporating full numerical relativity waveforms and modeling "recoil capture"—where GW emission binds the two objects into an eccentric orbit—may further increase the expected detection efficiency.

Summary updated

Abstract

The rapid advance of gravitational wave (GW) detector facilities makes it very important to estimate the event rates of possible detection candidates. We consider an additional possibility of GW bursts produced during parabolic encounters (PEs) of stellar-mass compact objects in globular clusters (GCs). We estimate the rate of successful detections for specific detectors: the initial Laser Interferometric Gravitational-Wave Observatory (InLIGO), the French-Italian gravitational wave antenna VIRGO, the near-future Advanced-LIGO(AdLIGO), the space-based Laser Interferometric Space Antenna (LISA), and the Next Generation LISA (NGLISA). Simple GC models are constructed to account for the compact object mass function, mass segregation, number density distribution, and velocity distribution. We both calculate encounters classically and account for general relativistic corrections by extrapolating the results for infinite mass ratios. We also include the cosmological redshift of waveforms and event rates. We find that typical PEs with masses m(1) = m(2) 40M(circle dot) are detectable with matched filtering over a signal-to-noise ratio S/N = 5 within a distance d(L) similar to 200 Mpc for InLIGO and VIRGO, z = 1 for AdLIGO, 0.4 Mpc for LISA, and 1 Gpc for NGLISA. We estimate single data stream detection rates of 5.5; 10(-5) yr(-1) for InLIGO, 7.2; 10(-5) yr(-1) for VIRGO, 0.063 yr(-1) for AdLIGO, 2.9; 10(-6) yr(-1) for LISA, and 1.0 yr(-1) for NGLISA, for reasonably conservative assumptions. These estimates are subject to uncertainties in the GC parameters, most importantly the total number and mass distribution of BHs in the cluster core. In reasonably optimistic cases, we get greater than or similar to 1 detection for AdLIGO per year. We expect that a coincident analysis using multiple detectors and accounting for GW recoil capture significantly increases the detection rates. The regular detection of GWs during PEs would provide a unique observational probe for constraining the stellar BH mass function of dense clusters.
BibTeX
@article{kocsis2006detection,
  author = {Bence Kocsis and Merse E Gáspár and Szabolcs Márka},
  title = {{Detection Rate Estimates of Gravity Waves Emitted during Parabolic Encounters of Stellar Black Holes in Globular Clusters}},
  journal = {The Astrophysical Journal},
  year = {2006},
  doi = {10.1086/505641},
}
Figure