Detection Prospects for GeV Neutrinos from Collisionally Heated Gamma-ray Bursts with IceCube/DeepCore

I. Bartos, Andrei M. Beloborodov, K. Hurley, Szabolcs MárkaPhysical 2013 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Jet reheating via nuclear collisions has recently been proposed as the main mechanism for gamma-ray burst (GRB) emission. In addition to producing the observed gamma rays, collisional heating must generate 10-100 GeV neutrinos, implying a close relation between the neutrino and gamma-ray luminosities. We exploit this theoretical relation to make predictions for possible GRB detections by IceCube + DeepCore. To estimate the expected neutrino signal, we use the largest sample of bursts observed by the Burst and Transient Source Experiment in 1991-2000. GRB neutrinos could have been detected if IceCube + DeepCore operated at that time. Detection of 10-100 GeV neutrinos would have significant implications, shedding light on the composition of GRB jets and their Lorentz factors. This could be an important target in designing future upgrades of the IceCube + DeepCore observatory.

Introduction

While gamma-ray observations of Gamma-Ray Bursts (GRBs) have been conducted for decades, the underlying dissipation mechanism—how the jet's kinetic energy is converted into radiation—remains a subject of intense debate. Standard models like internal shocks often fail to reproduce observed spectra. A compelling alternative is "collisional heating," where nuclear collisions between protons and neutrons within the jet drive the emission. A critical prediction of this model is the production of 10–100 GeV neutrinos alongside gamma rays. Detecting these neutrinos would provide definitive evidence for this model and a direct measurement of the jet's Lorentz factor ($\Gamma$).

Theoretical Framework and Neutrino Production

In the collisional heating model, the luminosities of neutrinos and gamma rays are fundamentally coupled because neutral pions decay into gamma rays while charged pions produce neutrinos. The ratio of neutrino energy to gamma-ray energy, denoted as $w$, is theoretically predicted to be between 3 and 10.

The energy of these neutrinos reaching Earth scales with the jet's Lorentz factor: $\epsilon \approx 0.1 \Gamma$ GeV. This relationship makes neutrino detection a powerful proxy for $\Gamma$, which is otherwise difficult to constrain. Figure 1 illustrates the relationship between the isotropic energy $E_{iso}$, the luminosity distance $D_L$, and the Lorentz factor $\Gamma$ within this framework.

Isotropic energy $E_{iso}$ as a function of luminosity distance $D_L$ and Lorentz factor $\Gamma$.

Methodology and Datasets

To evaluate detection prospects, the study modeled the performance of the IceCube/DeepCore observatory, a high-density sub-array designed for GeV-scale neutrino detection. Because the signal from a single GRB is typically weak, the researchers employed a "statistical stacking" approach, summing the expected signals from hundreds of bursts. Background noise from atmospheric neutrinos is suppressed by approximately 99.5% by restricting the search to the specific time and spatial coordinates of known GRBs.

The analysis utilized two primary datasets to simulate detector response:

  1. BATSE (1991–2000): A historical sample of nearly 3,000 bursts used to estimate long-term detection probabilities.
  2. Fermi/Swift (2010–2012): A modern sample used to calculate expected signals from current satellite operations.

Figure 2 shows the cumulative distribution of net fluence for the BATSE sample, highlighting the statistical basis for the stacking analysis.

Cumulative distribution of net fluence $S_{net}$ for the BATSE sample compared to a theoretical fit.

Results and Discussion

The study finds that for the large BATSE sample, the expected mean number of detected neutrinos is $\langle n \rangle \approx 1 \cdot w$. With $w$ in the range of 3–10, a decade of BATSE-era observations would likely have yielded a statistically significant detection. For the more recent Fermi/Swift sample, the expectation is lower ($\langle n \rangle \approx 0.13$), primarily due to the smaller sample size and the geographic distribution of the bursts relative to IceCube's sensitivity.

While individual "average" bursts are unlikely to be detected, exceptionally bright and nearby events (within $\sim 1$ Gpc) could potentially yield single-event detections. The focus remains on muon neutrinos due to their superior directional reconstruction, which is vital for background rejection.

Conclusion

The 10–100 GeV energy range represents a critical "sweet spot" for probing the sub-photospheric physics of GRB jets. There is a strong probability of a definitive detection within 5–10 years of continuous IceCube/DeepCore operation. Such a discovery would not only confirm the collisional heating model but also provide a direct handle on the Lorentz factors of the most powerful explosions in the universe. Future upgrades to IceCube that increase the density of optical modules will further enhance sensitivity in this crucial energy regime.

Summary updated

Abstract

Jet reheating via nuclear collisions has recently been proposed as the main mechanism for gamma-ray burst (GRB) emission. In addition to producing the observed gamma rays, collisional heating must generate 10-100 GeV neutrinos, implying a close relation between the neutrino and gamma-ray luminosities. We exploit this theoretical relation to make predictions for possible GRB detections by IceCube + DeepCore. To estimate the expected neutrino signal, we use the largest sample of bursts observed by the Burst and Transient Source Experiment in 1991-2000. GRB neutrinos could have been detected if IceCube + DeepCore operated at that time. Detection of 10-100 GeV neutrinos would have significant implications, shedding light on the composition of GRB jets and their Lorentz factors. This could be an important target in designing future upgrades of the IceCube + DeepCore observatory.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{bartos2013detection,
  author = {I. Bartos and Andrei M. Beloborodov and K. Hurley and Szabolcs Márka},
  title = {{Detection Prospects for GeV Neutrinos from Collisionally Heated Gamma-ray Bursts with IceCube/DeepCore}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevlett.110.241101},
}
Figure