Detection of Single-Nucleotide Polymorphism on uidA Gene of Escherichia coli by a Multiplexed Electrochemical DNA Biosensor with Oligonucleotide-Incorporated Nonfouling Surface

Gang Liu, Ruojun Lao, Li Xu, Qin Xu, Lanying Li, Min Zhang, Hao Shen, Sanjay Mathur, Chunhai Fan, Shiping Song2011 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a novel multiplexed electrochemical DNA biosensor for detecting single-nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) in the E. coli uidA gene. By combining a nonfouling surface with a ligation-based detection strategy, the biosensor achieves high specificity and sensitivity, enabling the detection of even low percentages of mutant DNA in complex samples.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Single-nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) are crucial genetic markers for understanding diseases, drug development, and diagnostics. However, accurately and efficiently detecting SNPs, especially in complex biological samples, remains a challenge. Existing electrochemical DNA biosensors often suffer from non-specific adsorption of proteins and other molecules, which can interfere with the detection signal and reduce specificity. This paper aims to overcome these limitations by developing a highly specific and practical electrochemical biosensor for SNP detection. Specifically, they focus on a SNP in the uidA gene of Escherichia coli (E. coli), which is important for identifying the highly pathogenic strain E. coli O157:H7.

Methods

The core of this work is a multiplexed electrochemical DNA biosensor that utilizes a ligation-based detection strategy on a nonfouling electrode surface (ONS).

Here's a breakdown of the key methods:

  • Oligonucleotide-Incorporated Nonfouling Surface (ONS): The researchers developed a nonfouling surface by co-assembling oligo(ethylene glycol) (OEG)-terminated thiols and thiolated DNA capture probes onto gold electrodes. This ONS is designed to repel non-specific adsorption of proteins and other molecules, a common issue in electrochemical biosensors.
  • Ligation-Based Detection: The detection strategy relies on a DNA-templated ligation reaction.
  • Capture Probes: Two capture probes (CP-W for wild-type and CP-M for mutant) were designed, differing only at their 3' terminal base. These probes are immobilized on the ONS.
  • Signal Probe: A signal probe with a biotin moiety is used.
  • Target DNA: The target DNA (either wild-type or mutant) acts as a template.
  • Ligation: If the target DNA perfectly matches a capture probe, it facilitates the ligation of the signal probe to the capture probe. This forms a stable "sandwich" structure. If there's a mismatch, ligation is significantly hindered.
  • Enzyme: Ampligase, a thermostable ligase, is used to catalyze the ligation reaction.
  • Signal Transduction:
    • Avidin-HRP Conjugation: After ligation and a stringent wash step to remove unbound probes, avidin conjugated with horseradish peroxidase (HRP) is added. The biotin on the signal probe binds to avidin.
  • Amperometric Detection: The immobilized HRP then catalyzes the reduction of a substrate (TMB), generating an electrochemical signal that is measured amperometrically. The current generated is proportional to the amount of ligated product, and thus to the presence of the perfectly matched target DNA.
  • Multiplexed Detection: A 16-electrode array was used to simultaneously detect both wild-type and mutant alleles on different electrodes.
  • PCR Amplification: For analyzing complex samples, asymmetric PCR was employed to generate single-stranded DNA (ssDNA) targets of 250 bp, which could be directly sensed by the probes.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study synthesized DNA targets and used E. coli genomic DNA for PCR amplification.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • ONS for Specificity: The ONS is a critical component, effectively preventing non-specific binding and significantly improving the signal-to-noise ratio, which is crucial for distinguishing between closely related DNA sequences like SNPs.
  • Ligation as a Specificity Enhancer: The DNA-templated ligation step acts as a powerful secondary screening mechanism. Only perfectly matched targets can efficiently template the ligation, making the system highly selective.
  • Multiplexing for Allele Discrimination: The use of a 16-electrode array allows for simultaneous detection of both wild-type and mutant alleles, providing a direct comparison and enabling robust SNP genotyping.
  • Practicality with PCR Products: Demonstrating the sensor's ability to detect SNPs in longer, complex PCR amplicons (250 bp) highlights its potential for real-world applications where direct genomic DNA analysis might be challenging.

Key Results

  • High Differentiation Ratio: The biosensor demonstrated a significant differentiation ratio (up to 4-fold) between perfectly matched targets and single-mismatched targets in initial experiments.
  • Sensitivity to Low Mutant Concentrations: The biosensor successfully detected a mixed DNA sample containing as little as 10% mutant DNA (T-M) when mixed with 90% wild-type DNA (T-W).
  • Optimization of Target Concentration: An optimized total DNA target concentration of 5 nM was identified for mixed samples to balance signal enhancement with discrimination.
  • Performance with PCR Amplicons: The multiplexed sensor array successfully analyzed PCR amplicons from mixed samples, showing a clear distinction between wild-type and mutant uidA gene sequences. The signal difference ratio was significantly higher (over 5-fold) between 100% mutant and 100% wild-type PCR amplicons.
  • Negligible Signal for Mismatched/Negative Controls: Negative controls and 100% wild-type amplicons (when analyzing mutant targets) produced negligible signals, confirming the high specificity.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Optimization of Total Target Concentration: While 5 nM was found to be optimal for mixed samples, further optimization might be needed for different sample types or concentrations.
  • Analysis of Complex Biological Fluids: Although the ONS is designed to repel non-specific adsorption, the paper mentions its successful application in complicated biological fluids like human sera in previous work. However, this specific study focused on synthesized DNA and PCR amplicons. Future work could involve more extensive testing in real-world biological samples.
  • Broader SNP Applications: The study focused on a single SNP in the uidA gene. Expanding the platform to detect multiple SNPs simultaneously in different genes or in other organisms would be a logical next step.
  • Integration with Portable Devices: The paper notes the advantage of electrochemical biosensors being miniaturized and portable. Future work could focus on integrating this ONS-based ligation biosensor into portable devices for point-of-care diagnostics or field applications.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{liu2011detection,
  author = {Gang Liu and Ruojun Lao and Li Xu and Qin Xu and Lanying Li and Min Zhang and Hao Shen and Sanjay Mathur and Chunhai Fan and Shiping Song},
  title = {{Detection of Single-Nucleotide Polymorphism on uidA Gene of Escherichia coli by a Multiplexed Electrochemical DNA Biosensor with Oligonucleotide-Incorporated Nonfouling Surface}},
  year = {2011},
  doi = {10.3390/s110808018},
}
Figure