Detection of odorants in odour mixtures among healthy people and patients with olfactory dysfunction

Eva Drnovšek, Kristina Weitkamp, Venkatesh N. Murthy, Edanur Gurbuz, Antje Haehner, Thomas HummelEuropean 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how well people can detect a specific target odor within complex mixtures of scents, finding that detection becomes harder with more background odors but remains surprisingly robust even in mixtures of up to eight components. The research also highlights that individuals with olfactory dysfunction perform significantly worse than healthy controls, suggesting this task could be a valuable clinical tool for assessing olfactory health.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Our everyday experience with smells is rarely of single, pure scents. Instead, we encounter complex mixtures. While we understand how people identify individual components in simple mixtures, the ability to detect a specific target odorant within a more complex blend has been less explored. Previous research suggested that human detection of target odorants in mixtures becomes difficult beyond 12-16 components, falling below chance. This paper aims to systematically investigate this limit in healthy individuals and, crucially, to compare their performance with patients suffering from olfactory dysfunction. Understanding this analytical perception of odor mixtures is important for fields ranging from food science and perfumery to clinical diagnostics of olfactory disorders.

Methods

The researchers designed two tasks to assess target odorant detection. In both tasks, participants were presented with samples and asked to identify the one containing a specific target odorant.

  • Task 1 (3-alternative forced choice - 3-AFC): Participants chose one out of three jars, where two contained only background odorants and one contained the target odorant mixed with background odorants.
  • Task 2 (2-alternative forced choice - 2-AFC): Participants chose one out of two jars, where both contained mixtures, but only one had the target odorant.

These tasks were structured into four steps, with each step increasing the number of background odorants in the mixture. The mixtures progressed from containing two (Task 1) or three (Task 2) total odorants in Step I to seven (Task 1) or eight (Task 2) total odorants in Step IV. Eugenol ('clove') and phenylethanol (PEA, 'rose') were consistently used as target odorants, with a third, randomly assigned odorant also included in the mixtures. Participants were considered to have successfully detected the target if they made correct choices in all trials within a given step.

Datasets

The study utilized human participants as the "dataset."

  • Participants: 90 healthy individuals (controls) and 40 patients with olfactory dysfunction. A subgroup of 40 controls was matched for age and gender with the patient group for direct comparison.
  • Odorants: Ten pleasant or neutral monomolecular odorants were selected, including Eugenol and PEA as primary targets. Other odorants served as both targets and background components.
  • Mixtures: Carefully prepared mixtures of isointense odorants were used, with the number of components increasing across four steps in each task.

No new benchmark datasets were introduced; the study focused on experimental evaluation with human participants.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Robust Analytical Perception: Despite the increasing complexity of odor mixtures, humans can still analytically "pick out" a target odorant, even when it's present in a blend of up to eight other scents. This challenges the notion that our olfactory perception is purely "configural" (perceiving the mixture as a whole) at higher complexities.
  • Individual Olfactory Function Matters: A strong correlation was found between participants' overall olfactory function (measured by standard tests) and their ability to detect target odorants in mixtures. This suggests that difficulties in detecting odors in complex blends might be a symptom of underlying olfactory deficits.
  • Target Odorant Recognition is Key: The study hinted that whether a person has a "clear association" with a particular odorant (e.g., recognizing Eugenol as "clove") significantly impacts their ability to detect it in a mixture. This suggests that familiarity and learned associations play a role in analytical odor perception.
  • Clinical Potential: The significant differences observed between patients with olfactory dysfunction and healthy controls, coupled with the correlation between task performance and olfactory function, points towards the potential of these target odorant detection tasks as a diagnostic tool.

Key Results

  • Decreasing Detection with Complexity: As the number of background odorants increased across the four steps, the probability of successfully detecting the target odorant (Eugenol and PEA) significantly decreased for healthy controls.
  • Surprising Detection Rates: Even in the most complex mixtures (seven or eight odorants), approximately 50% of healthy individuals could still detect Eugenol, and around 30-40% could detect PEA.
  • Patients Lag Behind: Patients with olfactory dysfunction consistently performed worse than age- and gender-matched controls in detecting both Eugenol and PEA across all steps and tasks.
  • Statistical Significance: The distributions of successful target odorant detection in healthy controls differed significantly from chance (p < 0.001). For patients, the distributions for Eugenol were not significantly different from chance in the later steps, and for PEA, this was true for most steps.
  • Correlation with Olfactory Function: Total scores from the detection tasks showed significant positive correlations with measures of olfactory function (threshold and identification) in healthy controls.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Odorant Purity: The study acknowledges that most odorants used were not 100% pure and included racemic mixtures, which could introduce variability.
  • Step Order: The steps within each task were presented in a fixed order (increasing complexity). The authors suggest randomizing the steps in future studies to control for potential time-dependent effects.
  • Mixture Complexity Limit: While the study explored mixtures up to eight components, the authors suggest further investigation with up to 16 components to more precisely determine the upper limit of human target odorant detection, as hinted at by previous research.
  • Odorant Selection: The study used only pleasant and neutral odorants. Future work could explore how unpleasant odorants might influence detection in mixtures.
  • Training: The study did not involve extensive training, unlike some mouse studies that showed higher detection capabilities. Future research could explore the impact of training on human performance.

Summary updated

Abstract

Target odorant detection in mixtures has been shown to become more difficult as the number of background odorants increases and falls below chance level in mixtures with 16 components. Our aim was to investigate target odorant detection in mixtures among healthy people and compare it between dysosmic patients and age- and gender-matched controls. Participants underwent extensive olfactory testing and performed two target odorant detection tasks. Eugenol ('clove') and phenylethanol (PEA, 'rose') were target odorants for all participants, whereas a third target was randomised. For each target odorant in task one (task two), there were four steps. Mixtures contained two (three) odorants in the first step and up to seven (eight) odorants in the fourth step. In each step, participants were asked to choose the sample with the target odorant from the three (two) jars presented. The study included 90 healthy people and 40 patients. As expected, probability of successful target odorant detection decreased as the number of odorants in the mixture increased. However, even when there were seven (eight) odorants in the mixture, around 50% (50%) of healthy people detected Eugenol and around 30% (40%) detected PEA. Furthermore, both distributions of successful target odorant detection differed from the expected binominal distribution of chance (p < 0.001). Patients performed worse at detecting Eugenol or PEA at each step than controls. Furthermore, there were significant positive correlations between task scores and olfactory function. In conclusion, target odorant detection is influenced by the target odorant, number of background odorants, and individual olfactory function.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{drnovsek2025detection,
  author = {Eva Drnovšek and Kristina Weitkamp and Venkatesh N. Murthy and Edanur Gurbuz and Antje Haehner and Thomas Hummel},
  title = {{Detection of odorants in odour mixtures among healthy people and patients with olfactory dysfunction}},
  booktitle = {European},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1111/ejn.16633},
}
Figure