Detection of heart rate using smartphone gyroscope data: a scoping review

Wenshan Wu, Mohamed Elgendi, R. Fletcher, Hagen Bomberg, Urs Eichenberger, Cuntai Guan, Carlo MenonFrontiers in Cardiovascular Medicine 2023 · DOI

Abstract

Heart rate (HR) is a critical indicator of cardiovascular health, traditionally measured via electrocardiograph (ECG). However, ECG's practical limitations in daily settings have led to the rise of smartphone-based alternatives like photoplethysmography (PPG). This scoping review investigates gyrocardiography (GCG)—an emerging method that uses a smartphone’s built-in gyroscope to detect heart rate through chest vibrations. Analyzing seven key studies from the last decade, this review evaluates data collection, pre-processing, and HR estimation algorithms. While GCG shows promise due to its hardware-free nature and relative immunity to gravity-induced bias, the field currently faces challenges regarding standardized performance metrics and the need for algorithms that function beyond a supine position.

Introduction

Monitoring heart rate is essential for diagnosing conditions like Atrial Fibrillation (AFib) and Coronary Artery Disease (CAD). While traditional ECGs are the gold standard, they are often impractical for long-term daily use. Smartphone-based PPG is a popular alternative but remains highly sensitive to ambient light and motion artifacts.

Gyrocardiography (GCG) offers a compelling solution by measuring the angular vibrations of the chest wall caused by cardiac activity. Unlike accelerometers, gyroscopes are theoretically more robust against device tilt relative to gravity. Despite this potential, GCG remains a relatively overlooked sensor in mobile health. This paper reviews the current state of research to determine the clinical readiness of smartphone-based GCG.

Methodology

The authors conducted a scoping review following PRISMA guidelines, filtering an initial pool of 114 papers down to seven core studies published between December 2012 and January 2023.

PRISMA flow diagram of the study selection process.

The selection process focused on studies that utilized smartphone gyroscope data for HR estimation, excluding review papers, posters, and conference abstracts to ensure a high standard of technical detail.

Technical Pipeline

The reviewed studies generally follow a three-stage technical pipeline:

  1. Data Collection: Participants typically place a smartphone on their sternum while in a supine (lying down) position.
  2. Pre-processing: To isolate the faint heartbeat signal from breathing noise and sensor drift, studies employ bandpass filters (typically 1–45 Hz). Advanced techniques like Singular Spectrum Analysis (SSA) and Successive Mean Quantization Transform (SMQT) are used to balance the signal's dynamic range.
  3. HR Estimation: Researchers primarily use two algorithmic approaches: Short-term Auto-Correlation (S-AC), which identifies repeating patterns in the signal, and Peak Detection, which counts heartbeats by identifying local maxima in the processed waveform.

Datasets and Participant Diversity

The core studies utilized datasets ranging from 11 to 435 participants. These cohorts often included individuals with pre-existing conditions such as AFib and heart failure to test the algorithms' diagnostic utility.

Evolution and demographics of datasets across the reviewed studies.

A notable trend in the literature is the concentration of research; five of the seven analyzed studies originated from the same research group, leading to significant reuse and expansion of the same core datasets. Validation was typically performed against "gold standards" such as clinical-grade ECGs or PPG sensors.

Key Insights and Results

The "Feature" vs. "Metric" Gap

A critical finding of this review is that five out of the seven studies did not report the raw accuracy of heart rate detection. Instead, they treated the derived heart rate as a feature for machine learning models designed to classify diseases (e.g., detecting AFib) rather than a standalone metric.

Gravity and Orientation

GCG’s primary advantage over seismocardiography (accelerometer-based) is its inherent robustness against gravity. Because gyroscopes measure angular velocity, they are less biased by the phone's orientation. Research indicates that the Y-axis (the longitudinal axis of the phone) often provides the most reliable data for HR estimation.

Quantitative Performance

Due to a lack of standardization, quantitative results are sparse. However, the studies that did report metrics showed high potential:

  • Accuracy: One study reported a Median Absolute Error (MedAE) of 1.03 beats per minute (bpm).
  • Reliability: Another study cited a total error rate of 1.18%, consisting of minimal missed beats and false detections.

Challenges and Future Directions

For GCG to move from the lab to clinical practice, several hurdles must be overcome:

  • Posture Constraints: Current research is almost entirely limited to supine subjects. Future algorithms must account for the noise introduced when users are sitting or standing.
  • Hardware Variance: There is no universal algorithm that accounts for the varying sensor sensitivities across different smartphone models.
  • Standardization: The authors advocate for a standardized protocol using ECG as a reference and Mean Absolute Error (MAE) as a primary metric to allow for fair comparison between emerging algorithms.

Summary updated

Abstract

Heart rate (HR) is closely related to heart rhythm patterns, and its irregularity can imply serious health problems. Therefore, HR is used in the diagnosis of many health conditions. Traditionally, HR has been measured through an electrocardiograph (ECG), which is subject to several practical limitations when applied in everyday settings. In recent years, the emergence of smartphones and microelectromechanical systems has allowed innovative solutions for conveniently measuring HR, such as smartphone ECG, smartphone photoplethysmography (PPG), and seismocardiography (SCG). However, these measurements generally rely on external sensor hardware or are highly susceptible to inaccuracies due to the presence of significant levels of motion artifact. Data from gyrocardiography (GCG), however, while largely overlooked for this application, has the potential to overcome the limitations of other forms of measurements. For this scoping review, we performed a literature search on HR measurement using smartphone gyroscope data. In this review, from among the 114 articles that we identified, we include seven relevant articles from the last decade (December 2012 to January 2023) for further analysis of their respective methods for data collection, signal pre-processing, and HR estimation. The seven selected articles' sample sizes varied from 11 to 435 participants. Two articles used a sample size of less than 40, and three articles used a sample size of 300 or more. We provide elaborations about the algorithms used in the studies and discuss the advantages and disadvantages of these methods. Across the articles, we noticed an inconsistency in the algorithms used and a lack of established standardization for performance evaluation for HR estimation using smartphone GCG data. Among the seven articles included, five did not perform any performance evaluation, while the other two used different reference signals (HR and PPG respectively) and metrics for accuracy evaluation. We conclude the review with a discussion of challenges and future directions for the application of GCG technology.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wu2023detection,
  author = {Wenshan Wu and Mohamed Elgendi and R. Fletcher and Hagen Bomberg and Urs Eichenberger and Cuntai Guan and Carlo Menon},
  title = {{Detection of heart rate using smartphone gyroscope data: a scoping review}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Cardiovascular Medicine},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3389/fcvm.2023.1329290},
}
Figure