Detection of Five Types of HPV Genotypes Causing Anogenital Warts (Condyloma Acuminatum) Using PCR-Tm Analysis Technology

Lixia Wu, Wei-Feng Wang, Jie Zhang, Xuan Wu, Yan Chen, Xiaoping Gu, Shao Hua-qing, Hongsheng Li, Weiwei LiuFrontiers in Microbiology 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel, high-throughput, and cost-effective PCR-Tm analysis method for detecting and differentiating five common HPV genotypes responsible for anogenital warts (condyloma acuminatum). This technique offers a simpler, faster, and more accurate alternative to existing methods, potentially improving clinical diagnosis and management of HPV infections.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Condyloma acuminatum (CA), commonly known as genital warts, is a widespread sexually transmitted infection caused by the human papillomavirus (HPV). While many HPV genotypes can cause CA, persistent infections with specific low-risk types like HPV-6 and HPV-11 are most common. Accurate and efficient HPV genotyping is crucial for diagnosis, understanding disease progression, and monitoring recurrence, especially since CA can be associated with higher-grade lesions. Current HPV detection methods, such as conventional PCR, nested PCR, and real-time PCR, often suffer from limitations like low throughput, time-consuming procedures, high costs, or the risk of laboratory contamination due to open-tube detection. The researchers aimed to develop a superior method that overcomes these challenges.

Methods

The core innovation presented is the PCR-Tm (Polymerase Chain Reaction-Melting Temperature) analysis technology. This is a closed-tube, multiplex PCR assay that combines PCR amplification with melting curve analysis. Here's how it works:

  • Tagging Primers: Specific DNA sequences, called "tags," are added to the upstream primers used for amplifying HPV DNA.
  • Complementary Probes: A fluorescently labeled probe is designed to be complementary to these tags.
  • Melting Curve Analysis: After PCR amplification, the sample is heated, and the melting temperature (Tm) of the probe-tag complex is measured. Each unique tag sequence has a distinct Tm value.
  • Genotype Identification: By designing multiple tags with different Tm values, the assay can simultaneously detect and differentiate multiple HPV genotypes in a single reaction tube. The Tm of the tag-complement complex is specific to each HPV type.

The researchers designed specific primers and a FAM-labeled probe for five HPV genotypes (HPV-6, HPV-11, HPV-16, HPV-42, and HPV-43) and a reference gene (HBB/D). They optimized various reaction parameters, including primer and probe concentrations, and Mg2+ concentration, to achieve optimal performance. The results from the PCR-Tm assay were validated against Sanger sequencing and compared with a flow fluorescence hybridization assay.

Datasets

The study utilized a dataset of 280 cervical scraping samples. These samples were pre-characterized using a flow fluorescence hybridization assay and included:

  • Positive samples for specific HPV types: HPV-6 (26), HPV-11 (12), HPV-16 (22), HPV-42 (18), HPV-43 (25).
  • Samples with multiple HPV infections (19).
  • Samples positive for other HPV types (58).
  • HPV-negative samples (100).

Additionally, plasmid DNA containing amplicons of the target HPV types and the HBB/D gene was used to establish the specificity and sensitivity of the PCR-Tm assay.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Simultaneous Detection in a Single Tube: The PCR-Tm assay's ability to detect multiple HPV genotypes in one closed tube is a significant advantage, reducing hands-on time and the risk of contamination.
  • Distinct Melting Temperatures: The careful design of tag sequences with sufficiently different Tm values (greater than 3°C difference) is crucial for accurate differentiation, especially in mixed infections.
  • Cost-Effectiveness: The paper highlights that PCR-Tm analysis is significantly more economical than the flow fluorescence hybridization assay, making it more accessible for widespread clinical use, particularly in resource-limited settings.
  • High Throughput Potential: The authors suggest that by increasing the number of tags and fluorescent channels, the PCR-Tm assay could potentially detect over 30 genes simultaneously, offering immense scalability.

Key Results

  • Specificity: The PCR-Tm analysis demonstrated high specificity for each of the five HPV genotypes tested, with no cross-reactivity observed.
  • Sensitivity: The cutoff sensitivities for the tested HPV types ranged from 10^2 to 10^4 copies/reaction, indicating good sensitivity. For example, HPV-43 and HBB/D had a sensitivity of 10^2 copies/reaction.
  • Agreement with Gold Standard: The PCR-Tm analysis showed excellent agreement with Sanger sequencing for validation.
  • Comparison with Flow Fluorescence Hybridization: The PCR-Tm assay exhibited a high kappa coefficient (0.940) and a 95% confidence interval of 90.3–97.7% when compared to the flow fluorescence hybridization assay, indicating strong concordance.
  • Improved Detection of Multiple Infections: The PCR-Tm assay detected more multiple HPV infections (19) compared to the flow fluorescence hybridization assay (10), suggesting it is more accurate in identifying coinfections.
  • Cost Savings: The estimated cost per sample for PCR-Tm analysis was significantly lower (approximately US$1.42) compared to the flow fluorescence hybridization assay (approximately US$21.52).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Sample Size: The authors acknowledge that the number of clinical samples (280) was relatively small, and they recommend expanding the sample size for further validation.
  • Limited Genotype Coverage: The study focused on only five HPV genotypes. The authors suggest that the method's capacity can be expanded to detect more genotypes by incorporating additional tags and fluorescent channels.
  • Future Work: The researchers envision that this PCR-Tm technology could be valuable for large-scale CA screening and diagnosis, especially in grassroots hospitals, due to its high-throughput nature, low cost, simple equipment requirements, and closed-tube operation, which minimizes contamination risks. They also suggest its potential for diagnostic transformation and reducing patient burden.

Summary updated

Abstract

PCR-Tm analysis enabled the detection of HPV-6, HPV-11, HPV-16, HPV-42, and HPV-43, including single and multiple infections.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wu2022detection,
  author = {Lixia Wu and Wei-Feng Wang and Jie Zhang and Xuan Wu and Yan Chen and Xiaoping Gu and Shao Hua-qing and Hongsheng Li and Weiwei Liu},
  title = {{Detection of Five Types of HPV Genotypes Causing Anogenital Warts (Condyloma Acuminatum) Using PCR-Tm Analysis Technology}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Microbiology},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3389/fmicb.2022.857410},
}
Figure