Detecting gravitational waves from cosmological phase transitions with LISA: an update

Chiara Caprini, M. Chala, Gláuber C. Dorsch, Mark Hindmarsh, Stephan J. Huber, Thomas Konstandin, Jonathan Kozaczuk, Germano Nardini, José Miguel No, Kari Rummukainen, Pedro Schwaller, Géraldine Servant, Anders Tranberg, David WeirJournal of Cosmology and Astroparticle Physics 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper provides an updated assessment of the potential for the Laser Interferometer Space Antenna (LISA) to detect gravitational waves (GWs) from cosmological phase transitions (PTs). It refines predictions for various Beyond the Standard Model (BSM) scenarios, incorporating recent theoretical developments and a new web-based tool, PTPlot, to aid the community in exploring these signals.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The early Universe, particularly the epoch between reheating and Big Bang nucleosynthesis, is largely opaque to electromagnetic radiation. Gravitational waves (GWs) offer a unique window into this era, and cosmological phase transitions (PTs) are predicted to be a significant source of a stochastic GW background. While the Standard Model (SM) itself doesn't strongly favor a first-order electroweak phase transition (EWPT) detectable by LISA, many extensions to the SM do. This paper aims to provide an up-to-date and comprehensive analysis of LISA's sensitivity to these GW signals from various BSM scenarios, addressing common misconceptions and clarifying open questions in the field.

Methods

The authors build upon previous work by refining the theoretical framework for predicting GW signals from PTs. Key aspects include:

  • Focus on Sound Waves: The analysis primarily considers GWs generated by sound waves in the cosmic fluid, as this is generally the dominant source for typical PTs.
  • Updated Parameterization: They use a refined understanding of PT parameters like the strength ($\alpha$), duration ($\beta/H_*$), and bubble wall velocity ($v_w$).
  • Hydrodynamic Simulations: The GW power spectra are largely informed by large-scale numerical simulations of bubble collisions and fluid motion.
  • PTPlot Tool: A new web-based tool, PTPlot, is introduced. This tool allows users to input PT parameters and obtain GW power spectra and LISA detection prospects, facilitating community-wide analysis.
  • Model-Specific Analysis: The paper examines a wide range of BSM scenarios, including extensions with scalar singlets, electroweak multiplets, supersymmetric models, effective field theories (EFTs), warped extra dimensions, composite Higgs models, and dark sector PTs.

Datasets

The paper does not utilize traditional "datasets" in the machine learning sense. Instead, it relies on:

  • Numerical Simulations: Results from existing large-scale numerical simulations of GW production from phase transitions are used.
  • Theoretical Calculations: Predictions are derived from perturbative and non-perturbative calculations of PT properties within various BSM models.
  • LISA Sensitivity Curves: Publicly available LISA sensitivity curves are used for estimating detection prospects.
  • Benchmark Points: The paper analyzes specific "benchmark points" within various theoretical models, often derived from previous literature, to illustrate detection prospects.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Scalar Field Contribution is Negligible: A significant update from previous work is the realization that the scalar field's contribution to GW production is generally negligible in thermal PTs, impacting the detectability of certain BSM scenarios.
  • Shock Formation Timescale Matters: The limited duration of the sound wave source, when the shock formation timescale is shorter than a Hubble time, is now accounted for, leading to reduced signal strength in many scenarios.
  • Turbulence Contribution is Conservative Neglected: Due to ongoing uncertainties and the difficulty in simulating turbulent motion, this contribution is conservatively neglected, meaning actual detection prospects might be even better.
  • PTPlot as a Community Resource: The development of PTPlot is a crucial step towards democratizing access to state-of-the-art GW predictions for BSM model builders.
  • LISA's Unique Probe: The analysis highlights LISA's crucial role in probing regions of parameter space inaccessible to current or near-future collider experiments, emphasizing its complementarity.

Key Results

  • Updated Detection Prospects: The paper provides updated predictions for LISA's ability to detect GWs from a variety of BSM scenarios, showing that LISA can probe many proposed benchmark scenarios, especially those with strong PTs and large wall velocities.
  • PTPlot Availability: The PTPlot tool is publicly available at ptplot.org, enabling users to explore GW power spectra and LISA detection prospects.
  • Clarification of Misconceptions: The authors address and clarify common misunderstandings in the literature regarding PT parameters and GW signal generation.
  • Model-Specific Insights: The analysis reveals specific sensitivities of LISA to different BSM models, highlighting where LISA offers unique discovery potential. For instance, in some models, LISA can probe regions that are difficult for the LHC to access.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Turbulence and Magnetic Fields: The paper acknowledges that the impact of turbulence and magnetic fields on the GW spectrum is not fully understood and remains an open question. Including these effects could improve detection prospects.
  • Bubble Wall Velocity Calculations: While assuming large wall velocities for strong PTs, the authors note that ab initio calculations of friction and wall velocity in many models are still lacking and are crucial for more accurate predictions.
  • Non-Perturbative Studies: For some models, perturbative calculations may have significant uncertainties. Dedicated non-perturbative studies are needed for more accurate predictions, especially for LISA detectability.
  • PTPlot Updates: The PTPlot tool will continue to be updated as new simulation results and LISA sensitivity estimates become available.
  • Higher Energy Scales: The paper briefly mentions the possibility of EWPTs occurring at significantly higher temperatures than typically considered, which would shift GW signals to higher frequencies, and suggests this warrants further investigation.

Summary updated

Abstract

MC was funded by the Royal Society under the Newton International Fellowship program. GD would like to thank CNPq (Brazil) for financial support. MH was supported by the Science and Technology Facilities Council (grant number ST/P000819/1), and the Academy of Finland (grant number 286769). SJH was supported by the Science and Technology Facilities Council (grant number ST/P000819/1). The work of JK was supported by Department of Energy (DOE) grant DE-SC0019195 and NSF grant PHY-1719642. TK and GS are funded by the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft under Germany's Excellence Strategy - EXC 2121 \\Quantum Universe" - 390833306. JMN is supported by Ramon y Cajal Fellowship contract RYC-2017-22986, and also acknowledges support from the Spanish MINECO's "Centro de Excelencia Severo Ochoa" Programme under grant SEV-2016-0597, from the European Union's Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under the Marie Sklodowska-Curie grant agreements 690575 (RISE InvisiblesPlus) and 674896 (ITN ELUSIVES) and from the Spanish Proyectos de I+D de Generacion de Conocimiento via grant PGC2018-096646-A-I00. KR is funded by the Academy of Finland grants 308791, 319066 and 320123. PS is supported by the Cluster of Excellence "Precision Physics, Fundamental Interactions, and Structure of Matter"(PRISMA+ EXC 2118/1) funded by the German Research Foundation(DFG). PS would like to thank Moritz Breitbach and Eric Madge for providing the data for figures (14), (15) and (16), and Eric Madge for checking the ptplot code. DJW (ORCID ID 0000-00016986-0517) was supported by an Science and Technology Facilities Council Ernest Rutherford Fellowship, grant no. ST/R003904/1, by the Research Funds of the University of Helsinki, and by the Academy of Finland, grant nos. 286769, 324882 and 328958. The original LISA Cosmology Working Group preprint number of this paper is \\LISA CosWG-19-04".
BibTeX
@article{caprini2020detecting,
  author = {Chiara Caprini and M. Chala and Gláuber C. Dorsch and Mark Hindmarsh and Stephan J. Huber and Thomas Konstandin and Jonathan Kozaczuk and Germano Nardini and José Miguel No and Kari Rummukainen and Pedro Schwaller and Géraldine Servant and Anders Tranberg and David Weir},
  title = {{Detecting gravitational waves from cosmological phase transitions with LISA: an update}},
  journal = {Journal of Cosmology and Astroparticle Physics},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1088/1475-7516/2020/03/024},
}
Figure