Detailed Assessment of the Spatial Distribution of Urban Parks According to Day and Travel Mode Based on Web Mapping API: A Case Study of Main Parks in Wuhan

Qiang Niu, Ye Wang, Yuan Xia, Hao Wu, Xi TangInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel method for assessing urban park accessibility and service efficiency by leveraging web mapping APIs to capture real-world travel behaviors across different times and modes. The study reveals significant spatial disparities in park access in Wuhan, categorizing problem areas and offering targeted improvement strategies for urban planning.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Urban parks are crucial for public health, environmental quality, and social well-being. However, traditional methods for evaluating their spatial distribution and accessibility often rely on simplified network analysis that doesn't accurately reflect how people actually travel. These methods can be data-intensive, require complex model building, and fail to account for variations in travel time due to different modes (walking, car, public transport) or daily/weekly traffic patterns. This gap means that park planning might not effectively address the real needs and travel habits of residents, leading to inequities in access. The paper aims to bridge this gap by providing a more realistic and dynamic assessment of park accessibility.

Methods

The core innovation of this study lies in its use of web mapping APIs, specifically AMap (a Chinese provider), to gather travel time data. Instead of building a road network model from scratch, the researchers directly queried the API for travel times between numerous origin points (500m x 500m grid cells) and park entrances. This approach offers several advantages:

  • Real-time Data: It utilizes up-to-date road network information and reflects current traffic conditions.
  • Mode and Time Specificity: It allows for the calculation of travel times for walking, car, and public transport, and distinguishes between workdays and weekends.
  • Efficiency: It bypasses the laborious process of manual road network modeling.

The study then calculated two key indicators:

  • Accessibility: Measured by the minimum travel time from an origin point to the nearest park entrance.
  • Effective Service Ratio (ESR): This measures the proportion of a research unit's area that is within an acceptable travel time to a park, excluding park and water areas. The acceptable travel times were determined through questionnaires (20 min walk, 30 min public transport, 15 min car).

Datasets

  • Study Area: Wuhan City, China, focusing on its most densely populated urban area (975.12 km²).
  • Administrative Data: District-level boundaries for Wuhan (92 districts).
  • Park Data: Catalogue of Main Parks in Wuhan, selecting 78 main parks based on level, size, and condition.
  • Origin Points: 2238 points derived from a 500m x 500m grid, excluding parks and water bodies.
  • Destination Points: 159 park entrances, identified through surveys and online inquiries.
  • Travel Time Data: Acquired via AMap's web mapping API for various travel modes (walking, car, public transport) and time buckets (workdays: 7 PM, Mon-Fri; weekends: 10 AM and 7 PM, Sat-Sun). Data was collected over three weeks in May 2017.
  • Questionnaire Data: 498 questionnaires to determine acceptable travel times for different modes.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Power of Real-World Travel Data: The study powerfully demonstrates how directly using web mapping API data can provide a much more accurate picture of park accessibility than traditional, static network analysis. The difference in car accessibility between weekdays and weekends, for instance, highlights the impact of traffic congestion, something often overlooked.
  • Day and Mode Matter: Accessibility is not a monolithic concept. The study's breakdown by travel mode and day of the week reveals nuanced patterns. For example, while car accessibility improves significantly on weekends due to reduced traffic, public transport accessibility remains relatively stable, suggesting the influence of fixed rail networks.
  • Beyond Simple Proximity: The ESR metric, by considering actual usable park area and acceptable travel times, offers a more refined measure of service efficiency than simple area-based metrics.
  • Typology of Park Access Issues: Categorizing districts into "absence of parks," "insufficiency with parks," and "separated by traffic" provides a clear framework for understanding and addressing park access challenges. This is a valuable contribution for targeted urban planning.

Key Results

  • Overall Walking Accessibility is Poor: The study area's walking accessibility to main parks is generally low, with only 28.34% of the area covered by a 20-minute walk.
  • Car Accessibility Varies Significantly: Car accessibility is higher, with ESRs of 72.85% on workdays and 79.07% on weekends (within 15 min drive). This improvement on weekends is attributed to reduced traffic congestion.
  • Public Transport Accessibility is Unsatisfactory: Despite ongoing development, public transport accessibility is limited, with an ESR of 43.17% on workdays and 43.67% on weekends (within 30 min).
  • District-Level Disparities:
    • Core vs. Outskirts: Inner districts often have better accessibility but can be hindered by traffic. Outskirt districts may have less park availability but potentially better car access due to fewer traffic obstructions.
  • Traffic as a Barrier: Districts like Zongguan, Zhongnan, and Luonan, despite having parks, suffer from low ESR on workdays due to traffic jams, which improves on weekends.
  • Three Types of Poor Park Accessibility Districts Identified:
    • Absence of Parks: Primarily on outskirts, requiring strict adherence to green space planning.
  • Insufficiency with Parks: Outside the Second Ring Road, needing more parks and better public transport integration.
  • Separated by Traffic: In older core areas, requiring infrastructure solutions like foot-bridges to overcome traffic barriers.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Grid Size Impact: The 500m x 500m grid for origin points might affect the accuracy of accessibility calculations. Denser grids would increase accuracy but also computational load.
  • Supply-Side Focus: The study primarily assesses park supply and distribution, not public demand. This could lead to overestimated ESR in sparsely populated areas.
  • Special Populations: The current accessibility model does not account for the specific needs of special populations like the disabled or elderly.
  • Future Work:
    • Narrowing the evaluation unit to the community level for more granular analysis.
  • Improving the ESR equation to incorporate resident population density.
  • Developing route planning APIs for special populations to assess their accessibility.
  • Integrating public demand data into the evaluation.

Summary updated

Abstract

This article employs two indexes-accessibility and effective service ratio (ESR)-to assess the spatial distribution of urban parks with the consideration of both equity and efficiency. Traditional approaches to calculate these two indexes are often based on the shortest distance to the park within its service radius by network analysis. Such approaches cannot reflect the actual travel behaviors of urban residents and require extensive data collection of road networks and complex parameter setting. To avoid these defects, this study directly acquires travel time data for various travel modes in a specific time period to the park through web mapping API (Application Program Interface), then calculates the accessibility and ESR of urban parks based on these detailed data. This method gets closer to actual park usage situation and avoids the cumbersome process of road network model building. At last, a case study is conducted on the assessment of spatial distribution of main parks in Wuhan, finding that districts with poor park accessibility in Wuhan can be divided into three types: districts with an absence of parks, districts with an insufficiency with parks, and districts separated from parks by traffic. Then, pertinent improvement suggestions are proposed, which provide some bases for decisions on future park planning and construction.
BibTeX
@article{niu2018detailed,
  author = {Qiang Niu and Ye Wang and Yuan Xia and Hao Wu and Xi Tang},
  title = {{Detailed Assessment of the Spatial Distribution of Urban Parks According to Day and Travel Mode Based on Web Mapping API: A Case Study of Main Parks in Wuhan}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph15081725},
}
Figure