Designing MOOCs for the Support of Multiple Learning Styles

Franka Grünewald, Christoph Meinel, Michael Totschnig, Christian WillemsEc-tel 2013 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper explores how to design Massive Open Online Courses (MOOCs) to better accommodate diverse learning styles, moving beyond traditional lecture-based formats. By analyzing survey data from a German-language MOOC, the authors propose design guidelines that integrate experiential learning and a "culture of participation" to foster more active and engaging learning experiences.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Massive Open Online Courses (MOOCs) hold immense potential for democratizing access to high-quality education. However, the dominant "XMOOC" model, characterized by sequential video lectures and self-tests, primarily caters to the "assimilating" learning style (preferring theoretical models and reflective observation). This leaves learners with other styles, such as "divergers" (preferring to learn from examples and analyze from different perspectives) and "accommodators" (preferring to learn from experiments and match models to insights), underserved. The paper addresses this gap by investigating how MOOC design can be evolved to support a broader spectrum of learning styles and foster a more active, participatory learning culture.

Methods

The study employs a mixed-methods approach. The core of the research involves analyzing survey responses from participants of the "Internetworking with TCP/IP" MOOC offered on the openHPI platform. This quantitative data on satisfaction and usefulness of learning materials is complemented by qualitative feedback and recommendations for improvement. The authors then use this empirical data to inform their theoretical framework, which integrates Kolb's experiential learning cycle with Fischer's concept of a "culture of participation." Based on this integrated framework, they propose design guidelines for future MOOC development.

Datasets

The primary dataset consists of survey responses from 1153 participants of the "Internetworking with TCP/IP" MOOC, representing 42.3% of the active participants. This survey collected data on participant satisfaction with various learning materials, perceived usefulness, self-assessed knowledge gains, and qualitative feedback for course improvement.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • XMOOCs primarily serve assimilators: The traditional XMOOC format, with its emphasis on lectures and reflective observation, is well-suited for learners who prefer theoretical models.
  • Need for active experimentation: Learners desire more opportunities for active experimentation and to connect course concepts to their own experiences, indicating a need to move beyond passive consumption.
  • Integrating experiential learning: By incorporating elements that support concrete experience and active experimentation, MOOCs can become more holistic and cater to a wider range of learning styles.
  • The power of participation: A "culture of participation," where learners are motivated to contribute and interact, is crucial for enriching the learning experience and fostering social learning.
  • Levels of engagement: Supporting diverse levels of participation, from passive consumers to meta-designers, is essential for accommodating different motivations and skill sets.
  • Gamification as a motivator: Game elements like points, badges, and leaderboards can be leveraged to increase learner motivation, encourage contributions, and provide social incentives.

Key Results

The survey revealed high satisfaction with the existing learning materials (lecture videos, self-tests, slides, etc.), with over 85% of participants expressing satisfaction. The average self-assessed knowledge gain across five domains was significant, with users advancing approximately one level. However, the social features of the platform were not perceived as having a positive impact on learning success. Qualitative feedback highlighted a strong desire for more practical examples, exercises, and extensive hypertextual links for further exploration.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge a potential self-selection bias in their survey, as highly successful or positively experienced participants might have been more inclined to complete the questionnaire. Future work focuses on evolving the XMOOC model towards a hybrid approach that bridges the gap with CMOOCs. This involves:

  • Enriching learning materials: Incorporating concept maps and hypertextual links to allow for learner-defined paths.
  • Hands-on exercises: Developing scalable virtual laboratories for active experimentation and problem-solving.
  • Fostering social interaction: Enhancing discussion forums and introducing tools for collaborative knowledge construction.
  • Implementing gamification: Integrating game design elements to boost motivation and engagement.
  • Supporting diverse participation: Creating opportunities for learners to contribute their own content and evolve through different levels of participation.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{grunewald2013designing,
  author = {Franka Grünewald and Christoph Meinel and Michael Totschnig and Christian Willems},
  title = {{Designing MOOCs for the Support of Multiple Learning Styles}},
  booktitle = {Ec-tel},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.1007/978-3-642-40814-4\_29},
}
Figure