Designing Fully Distributed Consensus Protocols for Linear Multi-agent Systems with Directed Communication Graphs

Zhongkui Li, Guanghui Wen, Zhisheng Duan, Wei RenarXiv 2013 · DOI · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel fully distributed adaptive consensus protocol for multi-agent systems with linear dynamics and directed communication graphs. Unlike previous methods requiring global graph information, this protocol relies solely on local agent dynamics and neighbor states, making it practical for real-world distributed systems. The work also extends to handle multiple leaders for containment control.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Achieving consensus, where all agents in a network agree on a common value or state, is a fundamental problem in multi-agent systems. This is crucial for applications like coordinated robotics, sensor networks, and distributed computing. A key challenge is designing distributed protocols, meaning each agent only uses information from its immediate neighbors and its own internal state, without needing a central coordinator or global knowledge of the entire network's structure.

Previous approaches to leader-follower consensus (where one agent, the leader, dictates the target state) often required knowledge of global graph properties, specifically eigenvalues of the graph's Laplacian matrix. This is a significant limitation because obtaining such global information in a distributed manner is often impossible or impractical. This paper tackles the problem of designing a consensus protocol that is truly distributed, even when the communication network is directed (meaning information doesn't necessarily flow both ways between agents).

Methods

The core of this paper is the design of a distributed adaptive consensus protocol. The protocol uses time-varying coupling weights that adapt based on the consensus error. Specifically, for a system of $N$ followers and one leader, the control input for follower $i$ is given by:

$u_i = c_i(t) \rho_i(\xi_i^T P^{-1} \xi_i) K \xi_i$

where:

  • $c_i(t)$ is the adaptive coupling weight for agent $i$.
  • $\xi_i$ represents the difference between agent $i$'s state and its neighbors' states (weighted by the adjacency matrix).
  • $\rho_i(\cdot)$ are monotonically increasing functions that provide design flexibility.
  • $K$ is a feedback gain matrix.
  • $P$ is a positive definite matrix obtained by solving a Linear Matrix Inequality (LMI) related to the agent dynamics.

The adaptation of the coupling weights $c_i(t)$ is governed by:

$\dot{c}_i = \xi_i^T \Gamma \xi_i$

where $\Gamma$ is another feedback gain matrix. This adaptive mechanism allows the agents to adjust their influence on each other to achieve consensus, even without knowing the global graph structure. The paper proves that this protocol achieves leader-follower consensus for any directed graph that contains a directed spanning tree rooted at the leader.

The paper also extends this framework to the containment control problem with multiple leaders. In this scenario, the followers' states are driven to lie within the convex hull spanned by the leaders' states. The adaptive protocol is adapted to handle this, requiring that each follower has a directed path from at least one leader.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical design and simulation, not on training or evaluating on specific datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • True Distribution: The most significant insight is the development of a consensus protocol that is fully distributed, relying only on local information (agent dynamics and neighbor states). This overcomes a major hurdle in applying consensus algorithms to real-world systems.
  • Adaptive Coupling: The use of adaptive coupling weights ($c_i(t)$) is key. These weights dynamically adjust to drive the consensus error to zero, effectively compensating for unknown or changing network conditions.
  • Flexibility with Monotonic Functions: Introducing monotonic functions $\rho_i(\cdot)$ provides additional design freedom, allowing for tailored convergence properties.
  • Directed Graphs are Tractable: The paper demonstrates that achieving distributed consensus is possible even with directed communication graphs, which are more challenging than undirected ones due to their asymmetry.
  • Extension to Containment Control: The successful extension to multiple leaders for containment control showcases the robustness and broad applicability of the proposed adaptive framework.

Key Results

  • The proposed distributed adaptive consensus protocol (5) is shown to achieve leader-follower consensus for linear multi-agent systems with general directed communication graphs, provided the graph has a directed spanning tree with the leader as the root.
  • The coupling weights $c_i(t)$ are proven to converge to finite steady-state values.
  • The protocol is extended to solve the containment control problem for multiple leaders, where follower states converge to the convex hull of leader states, under a similar connectivity assumption.
  • A simulation example with third-order integrators demonstrates the effectiveness of the protocol, showing consensus errors converging to zero and coupling weights stabilizing.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Leader's Control Input: The current work assumes the leader has a zero control input. A natural extension is to consider cases where the leader has a bounded control input or acts as a reference signal with bounded derivatives.
  • Relative Output Information: The protocol relies on relative state information. Future work could explore extending it to cases where only relative output information is available.
  • Leaderless Consensus: The paper focuses on leader-follower and multi-leader scenarios. Extending the adaptive approach to leaderless consensus problems would be valuable.
  • General Directed Graphs: While the paper handles directed graphs with a spanning tree, exploring consensus for directed graphs without a spanning tree is an open area.

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper addresses the distributed consensus protocol design problem for multi-agent systems with general linear dynamics and directed communication graphs. Existing works usually design consensus protocols using the smallest real part of the nonzero eigenvalues of the Laplacian matrix associated with the communication graph, which however is global information. In this paper, based on only the agent dynamics and the relative states of neighboring agents, a distributed adaptive consensus protocol is designed to achieve leader-follower consensus for any communication graph containing a directed spanning tree with the leader as the root node. The proposed adaptive protocol is independent of any global information of the communication graph and thereby is fully distributed. Extensions to the case with multiple leaders are further studied.
BibTeX
@misc{li2013designing,
  author = {Zhongkui Li and Guanghui Wen and Zhisheng Duan and Wei Ren},
  title = {{Designing Fully Distributed Consensus Protocols for Linear Multi-agent Systems with Directed Communication Graphs}},
  year = {2013},
  eprint = {1312.7377},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1312.7377},
}
Figure