Designing a zero-order energy transition model: a guide for creating a Starter Data Kit

Carla Cannone, Lucy Allington, Karla Cervantes Barron, Flora Charbonnier, Miriam Zachau Walker, Claire Halloran, Rudolf Yeganyan, Naomi Tan, Jonathan M. Cullen, John Harrison, Long Seng To, Mark HowellsResearch Square 2022 · DOI

Abstract

192 Parties joined the Paris Agreement, which includes commitments to reduce emissions. However, developing national decarbonisation strategies requires significant analyses and investment. Analyses for such strategies are often delayed due to a lack of accurate and up-to-date data for creating energy transition models. Starter Data Kits address this issue by providing open-source, zero-level country datasets to accelerate the energy planning process. There is a strong demand for replicating the process of creating Starter Data Kits because they are currently only available for 69 countries in Africa, Asia, and South America. Using an African country as an example, this paper presents the methodology to create a Starter Data Kit from data collection to the creation of tool-agnostic data repositories. The paper illustrates the steps involved, provides additional information for conducting similar work in Asia and South America, and highlights the limitations of the current version of the Starter Data Kits. Future development is proposed to expand the datasets, including new and more accurate data and new energy sectors.

Introduction: Bridging the Energy Data Gap

The global commitment to the Paris Agreement necessitates robust national decarbonization strategies. However, the transition from policy goals to actionable investment plans is frequently hindered by a critical bottleneck: the lack of accessible, high-quality data for energy system modeling. Traditional data collection is often a resource-intensive process, involving months of searching through proprietary databases or fragmented national reports. This "data gap" disproportionately affects developing nations, stalling the creation of effective energy transition pathways.

To address this, the concept of "Starter Data Kits" (SDKs) has been developed. These kits provide a "zero-order" baseline—a functional, open-source starting point that allows researchers and policymakers to begin modeling immediately. By providing a standardized foundation, SDKs accelerate the energy planning process and democratize the ability to conduct sophisticated national analyses.

Methodology: The SDK Pipeline

The creation of a Starter Data Kit follows a rigorous, repeatable methodology centered on the DaCoMaTool (Data Collection and Manipulation Tool). This Excel-based workbook serves as the central hub for aggregating diverse energy system data into a consistent, modeling-ready format.

The workflow consists of four primary stages:

  1. Data Collection: Researchers gather regional and country-specific data on technology costs, fuel prices, and renewable energy potentials from reputable open-access sources.
  2. Standardization: The collected data is organized within the DaCoMaTool to ensure consistency across different countries and regions.
  3. Data Transfer and Mapping: Data is moved from the DaCoMaTool to the clicSAND interface, which supports the OSeMOSYS (Open Source energy Modelling SYStem). A detailed mapping ensures that parameters like discount rates, technology costs, and activity ratios are correctly assigned.
  4. Scenario Development: Three baseline scenarios are typically established for each kit: Fossil Future (FF), Least Cost (LC), and Net Zero (NZ).
Table 4: Mapping for transferring country-specific data to the modeling interface.

This pipeline offers both manual entry and automated Python-based pathways, ensuring the methodology is accessible to a broad spectrum of users, from policy analysts to data scientists.

Data Sources and Open Repositories

The SDKs leverage a variety of global and regional open-access databases. Key contributors include the International Renewable Energy Agency (IRENA) for renewable technology costs, Renewables Ninja for weather-dependent capacity factors, and the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) for emissions factors.

The resulting datasets are hosted as open-access, tool-agnostic repositories on Zenodo. This approach prevents "vendor lock-in," allowing the data to be used with any energy modeling software. Currently, SDKs are available for 69 countries across Africa, Asia, and South America.

Table 1: List of databases and scripts needed to repeat the SDK methodology.

Key Insights: Democratizing Energy Planning

The utility of SDKs lies in their ability to provide a "zero-order" functional model. While not intended to be final, perfect representations of a national energy system, they eliminate the initial months of data gathering, allowing experts to focus on refining assumptions and analyzing policy impacts.

By lowering technical and financial barriers, SDKs empower local experts in developing nations to lead their own national energy analyses. This shift from reliance on external consultants to local ownership is crucial for sustainable, long-term energy planning. Furthermore, the use of open scripts and standardized tools ensures transparency and allows for easy updates as more granular data becomes available.

Real-World Impact and Future Directions

The SDK methodology has already seen successful application in several national contexts:

  • Kenya: The SDK provided the foundation for the national Reference Energy System used in government planning.
  • Vietnam: Researchers used the kits to analyze the trade-offs between Fossil Fuel and Net Zero pathways.
  • Kyrgyzstan: The data supported investigations into the potential for accelerated Electric Vehicle deployment.

Despite these successes, the authors identify several areas for future improvement. These include increasing the granularity of country-specific data (moving away from regional averages), expanding the sectoral scope (e.g., more detailed agricultural and transport demand modeling), and increasing temporal resolution to better capture the variability of renewable energy. Future iterations will also aim to include a broader range of greenhouse gases beyond $CO_2$ and more detailed modeling of international energy trade and interconnectors.

Summary updated

Abstract

<title>Abstract</title> 192 Parties joined the Paris Agreement, which includes commitments to reduce emissions. However, developing national decarbonisation strategies requires significant analyses and investment. Analyses for such strategies are often delayed due to a lack of accurate and up-to-date data for creating energy transition models. Starter Data Kits address this issue by providing open-source, zero-level country datasets to accelerate the energy planning process. There is a strong demand for replicating the process of creating Starter Data Kits because they are currently only available for 69 countries in Africa, Asia, and South America. Using an African country as an example, this paper presents the methodology to create a Starter Data Kit from data collection to the creation of tool-agnostic data repositories. The paper illustrates the steps involved, provides additional information for conducting similar work in Asia and South America, and highlights the limitations of the current version of the Starter Data Kits. Future development is proposed to expand the datasets, including new and more accurate data and new energy sectors.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{cannone2022designing,
  author = {Carla Cannone and Lucy Allington and Karla Cervantes Barron and Flora Charbonnier and Miriam Zachau Walker and Claire Halloran and Rudolf Yeganyan and Naomi Tan and Jonathan M. Cullen and John Harrison and Long Seng To and Mark Howells},
  title = {{Designing a zero-order energy transition model: a guide for creating a Starter Data Kit}},
  booktitle = {Research Square},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-1403613/v1},
}
Figure