DESIGNING A DIGITAL TOOLCHAIN FOR PROSTHETICS: A RETROSPECTIVE

Matt RattoCANADIAN PROSTHETICS & ORTHOTICS JOURNAL 2021 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper details the development of a novel, low-cost digital toolchain for creating prosthetic sockets in Lower and Middle Income Countries (LMICs). It emphasizes a human-centered design approach, integrating with existing clinical workflows and local expertise to ensure sustainability and impact, rather than simply introducing new technology.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper addresses the challenge of providing high-quality, affordable prosthetic and orthotic (P&O) devices in resource-limited settings. Traditional methods can be time-consuming and expensive, and many technology-driven solutions fail to integrate effectively into existing clinical practices or consider the diverse needs of stakeholders. The authors aim to bridge this gap by developing a digital toolchain that enhances, rather than replaces, the skills of local prosthetists and technicians, making prosthetic production more efficient and accessible.

Methods

The core of the methodology involved developing a novel CAD/CAM system for lower-limb prosthetic sockets. This system comprises:

  • NiaScan: A custom 3D scanning software.
  • NiaFit: Custom 3D design software.
  • 3D Printing Hardware: Modified commodity 3D scanners and printers.

The development process was guided by a set of "design values" that prioritized local needs, collaborative development, field testing, local adoption and adaptation, local management, and demonstrable benefits to local stakeholders. This approach contrasts with purely technology-driven solutions, focusing instead on integrating with existing clinical practices, such as the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC) polypropylene process.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on the development process and qualitative insights rather than quantitative evaluation on specific datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Health Economic Framing (HEF) as a Design Compass: The authors found that the HEF, which considers patients, prosthetists/orthotists, and payers within their specific contexts, provided a crucial framework for making design decisions. This holistic view ensured that the technology served the broader needs of the P&O ecosystem.
  • Empowering Local Expertise is Key: The project deliberately avoided outsourcing design to external CAD specialists. Instead, it focused on enhancing the skills and knowledge of local orthopaedic technicians and prosthetists, making them central to the design and production process. This approach fosters local ownership and sustainability.
  • "Lack of Fit" Over "Lack of Capacity": The paper argues that slow adoption of new technologies in P&O is often due to a "lack of fit" within the existing socio-technical context, rather than a lack of technical capacity or willingness from professionals. Innovations must be designed to integrate seamlessly into established workflows and address the complex relationships within healthcare settings.
  • Beyond the Patient: Valuing the Profession: The authors highlight that media coverage often focuses solely on patient benefits, neglecting the crucial role and professional development of prosthetists. Their digital toolchain aimed to recharacterize the work of prosthetists as more expert by providing them with advanced digital tools, thereby strengthening the profession.
  • Economic Evidence as a Tool for Sustainability: Generating economic evidence, by detailing situated material, labor, and support costs, was vital for securing funding and demonstrating the value of the innovation to funders and hospitals. This approach helped in securing ongoing support and even new funding streams for clinics.

Key Results

  • Successful Deployment: The system was deployed in four clinics: CoRSU (Uganda), CCBRT (Tanzania), TATCOT (Tanzania), and the Cambodian School of Prosthetics and Orthotics (CSPO). As of February 2021, the system remained in use at three of these sites.
  • Cost-Effectiveness: The complete system (software and hardware) costs under US$10,000, with prosthetic socket material costs less than $10 per unit.
  • Enhanced Clinical Capacity: The system increased existing clinical capacity by enabling prosthetists to produce devices more quickly, without reducing the need for their expertise.
  • Improved Professional Perception: The digital tools helped prosthetists be perceived as more expert by other healthcare professionals, partly by providing dedicated workstation areas that highlighted the digital aspects of their practice.
  • Qualitative Successes: The project fostered local agency and ownership, leading to a more sustainable integration of technology.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Incomplete Adoption: The paper acknowledges that the solution was not adopted in all settings despite concerted efforts, indicating challenges in achieving a perfect "fit" in every context.
  • Need for Deeper Contextual Understanding: The authors emphasize that successful innovation requires a deep understanding of the P&O context, including public health, private providers, LMIC clinics, and developed world contexts.
  • Ongoing Support: While the system is designed for local management, ongoing technical support remains a factor in sustained use.
  • Future Work: The authors encourage innovators to conduct deep dives into specific P&O contexts before developing solutions and to plan for iterative, direct collaboration with clinicians throughout the deployment process. This approach will help address the complexity of the P&O context and its stakeholders.

Summary updated

Abstract

From 2014 until 2020, I participated in the development of a novel CAD/CAM system for lower-limb prosthetic sockets for use in Lower and Middle Income Countries (LMIC) orthopaedic clinical settings. This article provides an overview of the value principles that guided that work and the ways in which we attempted to support the clinical needs of our prosthetists and others in the clinical contexts. It will highlight how the health economic framework that is key to this special issue well describes the design choices we made in order to attend to the multiple levels of concerns and stakeholders we identified as key to success. Article PDF Link: https://jps.library.utoronto.ca/index.php/cpoj/article/view/36188/28345 How To Cite: Ratto M. Designing a digital toolchain for prosthetics: A retrospective. Canadian Prosthetics & Orthotics Journal. 2021; Volume 4, Issue 2, No.16. https://doi.org/10.33137/cpoj.v4i2.36188 Corresponding Author: Matt Ratto, PhDFaculty of Information, University of Toronto, Canada.E-Mail: [email protected] ID: https://orcid.org/0000-0002-3554-4513
BibTeX
@article{ratto2021designing,
  author = {Matt Ratto},
  title = {{DESIGNING A DIGITAL TOOLCHAIN FOR PROSTHETICS: A RETROSPECTIVE}},
  journal = {CANADIAN PROSTHETICS \& ORTHOTICS JOURNAL},
  year = {2021},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=FhoXA12fn1},
}

Loading related content...

Figure