Design of two-photon molecular tandem architectures for solar cells by ab initio theory

Kristian B. Ørnsø, J. M. García‐Lastra, Gema de la Torre, F. J. Himpsel, Ángel Rubio, Kristian S. ThygesenChemical 2015 · DOI

Abstract

An extensive database of spectroscopic properties of molecules from ab initio calculations is used to design molecular complexes for use in tandem solar cells that convert two photons into a single electron-hole pair, thereby increasing the output voltage while covering a wider spectral range. Three different architectures are considered: the first two involve a complex consisting of two dye molecules with appropriately matched frontier orbitals, connected by a molecular diode. Optimized combinations of dye molecules are determined by taking advantage of our computational database of the structural and energetic properties of several thousand porphyrin dyes. The third design is a molecular analogy of the intermediate band solar cell, and involves a single dye molecule with strong intersystem crossing to ensure a long lifetime of the intermediate state. Based on the calculated energy levels and molecular orbitals, energy diagrams are presented for the individual steps in the operation of such tandem solar cells. We find that theoretical open circuit voltages of up to 1.8 V can be achieved using these tandem designs. Questions about the practical implementation of prototypical devices, such as the synthesis of the tandem molecules and potential loss mechanisms, are addressed.

Introduction

Standard molecular solar cells, such as Dye-Sensitized Solar Cells (DSSCs), often suffer from limited efficiency due to their transparency to the red and infrared regions of the solar spectrum. While conventional tandem designs stacking multiple cells can mitigate this, they often introduce physical interfaces prone to defects and charge recombination. This research proposes a shift from device-level to molecular-level tandem architectures. By engineering a single molecular complex to facilitate two-photon absorption, the authors aim to eliminate interface issues, achieve higher open-circuit voltages ($V_{oc}$), and improve spectral coverage.

Methodology

The study utilizes high-throughput computational screening and ab initio simulations:

  • Electronic Structure Calculations: Density Functional Theory (DFT) was performed using the GPAW code with the PBE functional. To ensure accuracy in predicting energy gaps, Highest Occupied Molecular Orbital (HOMO) and Lowest Unoccupied Molecular Orbital (LUMO) levels were determined via total energy differences between neutral and charged states.
  • Excitation and Optical Properties: Triplet excitation energies were calculated to approximate optical gaps. Time-Dependent DFT (TD-DFT) with the CAM-B3LYP functional was used to evaluate oscillator strengths.
  • Data-Driven Design: The researchers leveraged a public database containing quantum mechanical calculations for over 5,000 functionalized porphyrins. This allowed for the systematic identification of dye pairs with perfectly aligned energy levels.

Proposed Tandem Architectures

Three distinct schemes were developed to enable two-photon to one-electron conversion, as illustrated in the energy diagrams below:

Energy diagrams for the three proposed tandem architectures (A, B, and C) utilizing two-photon absorption.
  1. Two-Dye Tandem with Molecular Diode (Schemes A and B): Two dye molecules are connected via an asymmetric linker (e.g., an ester bond) that acts as a molecular diode. This ensures unidirectional electron flow and suppresses recombination. Calculations confirm that frontier orbitals remain localized on individual dyes, preserving their specific absorption properties.
  2. Single-Dye Triplet System (Scheme C): This design mimics an intermediate band solar cell. By incorporating heavy metals like Palladium (Pd) into the porphyrin core, Intersystem Crossing (ISC) is promoted. This populates a long-lived triplet state, which serves as an intermediate "waiting room" for a second photon to excite the electron further for injection into the electrode.

Key Results

  • Enhanced Voltage: The proposed designs predict theoretical $V_{oc}$ values up to 1.8 V, a significant increase over the 0.7–1.0 V typical of standard DSSCs.
  • Candidate Identification: Approximately 800 suitable dye pairs were identified from the database for the tandem architecture.
  • Design Blueprints: A concrete chemical blueprint for a Pd-porphyrin dye was developed, showing ideal alignment with the $TiO_2$ conduction band.

Discussion and Outlook

While the theoretical framework is robust, several challenges remain for practical implementation. Current electrolytes (e.g., Cobalt-based redox couples) may limit the achievable voltage to approximately 1.26 V, necessitating the development of new redox mediators. Furthermore, while the energetics are favorable, the kinetics of electron transfer across molecular bridges require experimental validation. The synthetic complexity of creating these multi-component "dyads" remains a significant hurdle. Nevertheless, these molecular machines offer a promising path toward high-voltage, high-efficiency solar energy conversion.

Summary updated

Abstract

An extensive database of spectroscopic properties of molecules from <i>ab initio</i> calculations is used to design molecular complexes for use in tandem solar cells that convert two photons into a single electron-hole pair, thereby increasing the output voltage while covering a wider spectral range. Three different architectures are considered: the first two involve a complex consisting of two dye molecules with appropriately matched frontier orbitals, connected by a molecular diode. Optimized combinations of dye molecules are determined by taking advantage of our computational database of the structural and energetic properties of several thousand porphyrin dyes. The third design is a molecular analogy of the intermediate band solar cell, and involves a single dye molecule with strong intersystem crossing to ensure a long lifetime of the intermediate state. Based on the calculated energy levels and molecular orbitals, energy diagrams are presented for the individual steps in the operation of such tandem solar cells. We find that theoretical open circuit voltages of up to 1.8 V can be achieved using these tandem designs. Questions about the practical implementation of prototypical devices, such as the synthesis of the tandem molecules and potential loss mechanisms, are addressed.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{rns2015design,
  author = {Kristian B. Ørnsø and J. M. García‐Lastra and Gema de la Torre and F. J. Himpsel and Ángel Rubio and Kristian S. Thygesen},
  title = {{Design of two-photon molecular tandem architectures for solar cells by ab initio theory}},
  booktitle = {Chemical},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.1039/c4sc03835e},
}
Figure