Design of Bus Bridging Routes in Response to Disruption of Urban Rail Transit

Yajuan Deng, Xiaolei Ru, Ziqi Dou, Guohua LiangSustainability 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper tackles the critical challenge of designing efficient bus bridging routes to mitigate disruptions in urban rail transit. It introduces a novel optimization model that considers passenger route choices and station capacity constraints, ultimately aiming to minimize passenger travel time and improve emergency transport efficiency.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Urban rail transit is a cornerstone of modern urban mobility, but it's susceptible to disruptions (e.g., equipment failures, power outages) that can last from minutes to days. These disruptions lead to significant passenger congestion at stations, impacting the entire transit system. While bus bridging is a common solution, current practices often rely on operator experience, lacking a systematic and optimized approach. This paper addresses the need for a robust methodology to design bus bridging routes that effectively reroute passengers, considering various route options and the critical constraint of station capacity.

Methods

The authors propose a multi-stage approach to design bus bridging routes:

  1. Feasible Route Generation: They first identify three types of feasible routes for disrupted Origin-Destination (OD) pairs:
  2. Urban rail transit transfers (where possible).
  3. Direct bus bridging.
  4. Indirect bus bridging (combining bus bridging with undamaged rail transit segments in various sequences). This generation process is initially performed without considering station capacity.

  5. Capacity-Constrained Route Generation (k-short alternative routes): To address station capacity limitations, the paper employs a "k-short alternative routes" strategy. This involves iteratively generating an increasing number of shortest feasible routes (increasing 'k') for each disrupted OD pair. This process continues until passenger flow can be assigned without exceeding station capacities, effectively identifying alternative routes that bypass potential bottlenecks.

  6. Route Merging and Filtering: After generating initial bus bridging routes, a merging and filtering process is applied. This step aims to consolidate similar routes, eliminate redundant ones, and optimize resource utilization by considering whether merging routes can reduce overall passenger travel time.
  7. Optimization Model: The core of the methodology is an optimization model that minimizes the total travel time of blocked passengers. This model incorporates constraints related to passenger flow assignment, station capacity, and the total number of available bus bridging resources.

Datasets

The paper uses an illustrative example of the urban rail transit network in Tianjin, China, comprising four lines and 82 stations. Passenger flow data for OD pairs during peak hours was obtained from historical data. Travel times for rail transit and bus bridging were calculated based on operation velocity and distance.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Beyond Direct Connections: The paper emphasizes that disruptions can impact a wide range of OD pairs, not just those immediately adjacent to the disruption. This necessitates considering a broader set of feasible routes, including indirect bus bridging and urban rail transit transfers.
  • The Criticality of Station Capacity: Ignoring station capacity can lead to unrealistic routing plans. The model's incorporation of station capacity constraints is crucial for ensuring the feasibility and effectiveness of bus bridging.
  • Distance Matters for Route Choice: The study reveals a clear preference for direct bus bridging on shorter travel distances, while indirect bus bridging becomes more advantageous for longer distances. This is attributed to the speed advantage of urban rail transit over longer stretches.
  • Urban Rail Transit Transfer Preference: For incomplete disruptions, urban rail transit transfers are frequently chosen, likely due to passengers' familiarity with the mode and potentially shorter travel times compared to bus bridging.

Key Results

  • The proposed bus bridging design scheme significantly reduces travel delay for blocked passengers.
  • When station capacity constraints are considered, the passenger's total travel time increases by 3.49% compared to a scenario without these constraints, highlighting their importance.
  • Direct bus bridging routes are preferred for short travel distances (0-6 km), accounting for 91.4% of alternative routes in this category.
  • Indirect bus bridging routes are more prevalent for longer distances (over 6 km), making up 72% of all alternative routes.
  • The study estimates significant financial benefits (CNY 2,419,830) from passenger time savings in Tianjin due to the implemented bus bridging strategy.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Generalizability: The authors acknowledge that the current model is based on an illustrative example and suggest collecting more origin-destination travel and disruption data from larger cities like Beijing and Shanghai to further validate the method.
  • Depot Location Influence: The paper notes that the location of bus bridging depots can influence route design results. Future work should focus on developing a route design model that explicitly considers depot layout.
  • Passenger Perception: While a dependent factor for urban rail transit transfer routes was introduced to reflect passenger perception, further in-depth research on perceived travel cost is suggested.

Summary updated

Abstract

Bus bridging has been widely used to connect stations affected by urban rail transit disruptions. This paper designs bus bridging routes for passengers in case of urban rail transit disruption. The types of urban rail transit disruption between Origin-Destination stations are summarized, and alternative bus bridging routes are listed. First, the feasible route generation method is established. Feasible routes for each pair of the disruption Origin-Destination stations include urban rail transit transfer, direct bus bridging, and indirect bus bridging. Then the feasible route generation model with the station capacity constraint is established. The k-short alternative routes are generated to form the bus bridging routes. Lastly, by considering the bus bridging resource constraints, the final bus bridging routes are obtained by merging and filtering the initial bridging routes. Numerical results of an illustrative network show that the bus bridging routes generated from the proposed model can significantly reduce travel delay of blocked passengers, and it is necessary to maintain the number of passengers in the urban rail transit below the station capacity threshold for ensuring a feasible routing design. One more important finding of this work is that the direct bridging route is preferred for short travel distances, while the indirect bridging route is preferred for longer travel distances. After the bridging bus routes are taken, the passenger’s total travel time is significantly lower than when no measures are taken. However, after the capacity constraint of a station is considered, the passenger’s total travel time will be increased by 3.49% compared with not considering a capacity constraint.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{deng2018design,
  author = {Yajuan Deng and Xiaolei Ru and Ziqi Dou and Guohua Liang},
  title = {{Design of Bus Bridging Routes in Response to Disruption of Urban Rail Transit}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.3390/su10124427},
}
Figure