Design of a switchable eliminase

Ivan V. Korendovych, Daniel W. Kulp, Yibing Wu, Hong Cheng, Heinrich Röder, William F. DeGradoProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 2011 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have engineered a novel enzyme, "AlleyCat," by making a single mutation in the calcium-binding protein calmodulin. This engineered protein can now catalyze a specific chemical reaction (Kemp elimination) only when calcium ions are present, demonstrating a powerful new approach to designing switchable, allosteric catalysts.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Designing enzymes with specific catalytic activities is a long-standing challenge in biochemistry and synthetic biology. While natural enzymes are highly optimized, creating new catalytic functions often requires extensive modification or complex computational redesign. A key aspect of enzymatic catalysis is the precise positioning of amino acid side chains within the active site to facilitate chemical transformations. For reactions like the Kemp elimination, which involves abstracting a proton from a carbon-hydrogen bond, a basic residue (like glutamate or aspartate) is crucial. However, in water, these residues are not basic enough. Enzymes overcome this by creating a dehydrated environment within their active sites, which significantly increases the basicity of these carboxylate groups. Furthermore, many enzymes are regulated allosterically, meaning their activity can be turned on or off by the binding of a small molecule at a site distinct from the active site. The challenge is to combine these features – creating a specific catalytic function and incorporating allosteric regulation – in a predictable and efficient manner, especially using simpler protein scaffolds.

Methods

The researchers employed a minimalist protein design strategy, focusing on a well-characterized protein scaffold: the C-terminal domain of calmodulin (cCaM). Calmodulin is known to bind calcium ions, which induces a conformational change that opens up hydrophobic pockets.

The core of their approach involved computational protein design:

  1. Identifying Catalytic Sites: They computationally scanned the hydrophobic pockets of cCaM to find positions where a carboxylate group (from a mutated glutamate or aspartate) could be optimally placed to act as a general base for the Kemp elimination reaction.
  2. Transition State Docking: A crucial step was to ensure that the proposed catalytic residue could not only bind the substrate but also stabilize the transition state of the reaction. This involved using a "superrotamer" library to explore various conformations of the catalytic residue in proximity to the substrate's transition state.
  3. Mutagenesis and Characterization: Based on computational predictions, they engineered a specific mutant, cCaM F92E, which they named "AlleyCat." They then experimentally characterized its catalytic activity, pH dependence, and allosteric regulation by calcium.
  4. Control Mutants: To confirm the specificity of their design, they created numerous control mutants, including mutating the active site residue to glutamine (which lacks a carboxylate) or histidine (a different basic residue).
  5. Structural Analysis: The solution structure of AlleyCat was determined using heteronuclear NMR to confirm the positioning of the engineered catalytic residue.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Single Mutation Power: The most striking insight is that a single amino acid substitution in a non-catalytic protein can confer significant catalytic activity for a specific reaction. This highlights the power of precisely engineering the microenvironment of a catalytic residue.
  • Dehydration and Basicity: The design leverages the principle that dehydrating a carboxylate group dramatically increases its basicity, making it an effective proton abstractor. The hydrophobic pocket created by calcium binding in calmodulin provides this necessary dehydrated environment.
  • Allosteric Control: By using calmodulin, a protein known for its calcium-dependent conformational changes, the researchers successfully created an allosterically regulated catalyst. The catalytic activity is directly linked to calcium binding, allowing for a "switchable" enzyme.
  • Minimalist Design Success: This work demonstrates the efficacy of a minimalist approach to protein design, using a small, stable scaffold and a minimal number of mutations, which simplifies characterization and design principles.
  • Computational Prediction Accuracy: The computational methods used were highly predictive, accurately identifying the optimal position for the catalytic residue and guiding the experimental design.

Key Results

  • AlleyCat Activity: The engineered protein, AlleyCat (cCaM F92E), exhibited Kemp elimination activity in the presence of 10 mM Ca²⁺.
  • Specificity: AlleyCat showed significant activity, while a related mutant (F92D) was 16-fold less active, and other control mutants had negligible activity, confirming the specificity of the Glu92 residue.
  • Allosteric Regulation: AlleyCat's catalytic activity was strictly Ca²⁺-dependent, with activity profiles consistent with tight, two-site calcium binding (Kd < 10 μM).
  • pH Profile: The pH-rate profile of AlleyCat indicated that Glu92 acts as a general base with an apparent pKa of 6.9 ± 0.1.
  • Catalytic Efficiency: The kcat/KM for AlleyCat was comparable to that of catalytic antibodies and significantly higher than many computationally designed enzymes targeting the same reaction.
  • Structural Confirmation: NMR structural analysis confirmed that the engineered Glu92 residue was well-positioned within the hydrophobic pocket to act as a general base.
  • Stability Trade-off: AlleyCat was found to be less thermodynamically stable than wild-type cCaM, consistent with the idea that enzymes often sacrifice some stability for enhanced function.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Substrate Specificity: While AlleyCat is active, its substrate specificity is limited to the specific benzisoxazole derivative used in the study. Future work could explore expanding this specificity.
  • Catalytic Efficiency Improvement: Although AlleyCat's activity is significant, there is potential for further improvement. The authors suggest that optimizing geometric complementarity with the substrate could enhance KM and catalytic efficiency.
  • Broader Applications: The authors propose that this strategy of linking ligand-induced conformational changes to catalytic activity could be applied to design a wide range of catalytically amplified sensors by using different ligand-binding proteins.
  • Directed Evolution: The authors note that directed evolution could be used to further enhance AlleyCat's catalytic efficiency, potentially leading to even more potent catalysts.

Summary updated

Abstract

The active sites of enzymes are lined with side chains whose dynamic, geometric, and chemical properties have been finely tuned relative to the corresponding residues in water. For example, the carboxylates of glutamate and aspartate are weakly basic in water but become strongly basic when dehydrated in enzymatic sites. The dehydration of the carboxylate, although intrinsically thermodynamically unfavorable, is achieved by harnessing the free energy of folding and substrate binding to reach the required basicity. Allosterically regulated enzymes additionally rely on the free energy of ligand binding to stabilize the protein in a catalytically competent state. We demonstrate the interplay of protein folding energetics and functional group tuning to convert calmodulin (CaM), a regulatory binding protein, into AlleyCat, an allosterically controlled eliminase. Upon binding Ca(II), native CaM opens a hydrophobic pocket on each of its domains. We computationally identified a mutant that ( i ) accommodates carboxylate as a general base within these pockets, ( ii ) interacts productively in the Michaelis complex with the substrate, and ( iii ) stabilizes the transition state for the reaction. Remarkably, a single mutation of an apolar residue at the bottom of an otherwise hydrophobic cavity confers catalytic activity on calmodulin. AlleyCat showed the expected pH-rate profile, and it was inactivated by mutation of its active site Glu to Gln. A variety of control mutants demonstrated the specificity of the design. The activity of this minimal 75-residue allosterically regulated catalyst is similar to that obtained using more elaborate computational approaches to redesign complex enzymes to catalyze the Kemp elimination reaction.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{korendovych2011design,
  author = {Ivan V. Korendovych and Daniel W. Kulp and Yibing Wu and Hong Cheng and Heinrich Röder and William F. DeGrado},
  title = {{Design of a switchable eliminase}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences},
  year = {2011},
  doi = {10.1073/pnas.1018191108},
}
Figure