Design Factors to Improve the Consistency and Sustainable User Experience of Responsive Interface Design

Wenjie Li, Yuxiao Zhou, Shijian Luo, Yenan DongSustainability 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates how to create consistent and sustainable user experiences across various devices (desktops, tablets, smartphones) by identifying and categorizing key design factors for responsive interfaces. The research proposes a framework for applying these factors to ensure visual and functional coherence, ultimately leading to better user satisfaction.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In today's multi-device world, users interact with websites and software on a growing range of screens, from large desktop monitors to small smartphone displays. This fragmentation poses a significant challenge for designers aiming to provide a seamless and consistent user experience. A lack of consistency can lead to confusion, increased learning curves, and a diminished overall user satisfaction. The paper addresses the need to understand and systematically apply design principles that ensure a unified and sustainable user experience across these diverse interfaces, moving beyond simply adapting layouts to truly maintaining brand identity and usability.

Methods

The research employed a multi-stage approach:

  1. Hierarchical Grouping Experiment: 40 existing responsive websites were analyzed by graduate students. Participants were asked to group these websites based on perceived similarities in interface layout and design elements. This helped identify typical interface layouts and initial design factors.
  2. Eye-Tracking Experiment: A subset of typical responsive interfaces was further analyzed using eye-tracking technology. This objective method recorded user gaze patterns, fixations, and saccades to identify which interface components attracted the most attention and were thus considered important. This was complemented by verbal protocols and questionnaire surveys to gather subjective user perceptions.
  3. Design Factor Classification: Based on the experimental data, design factors were categorized into three levels:
  4. General Design Factors: Elements that remain largely consistent across all devices (e.g., logo, copyright).
  5. Adaptive Design Factors: Elements that are adjusted based on device characteristics but maintain overall uniformity (e.g., navigation bar, search tool).
  6. Individual Design Factors: Elements that are specific to a particular terminal and may require entirely different implementations (e.g., language bar, sensor function controls).
  7. Wireframing and Prototyping: The identified design factors were used to create wireframe prototypes.
  8. Case Study Application: A sales management software tool (SA) was used as a practical example to apply the developed framework and create responsive interfaces for multiple terminals.
  9. Usability Testing: The final prototypes were evaluated through a usability test and subjective evaluation by sales management practitioners to assess their effectiveness and user experience.

Datasets

The study utilized a dataset of 40 existing responsive websites, collected from various categories including e-commerce, company, technology, media, and tools. These websites served as the stimuli for the hierarchical grouping and eye-tracking experiments. No new benchmarks were introduced; instead, existing websites were analyzed to derive design principles.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Beyond Layout Adaptation: The research emphasizes that true consistency in responsive design goes beyond simply resizing and rearranging elements. It involves understanding how different design factors contribute to a unified user experience.
  • Hierarchy of Design Factors: The classification of design factors into general, adaptive, and individual is crucial. It provides a structured approach for designers to prioritize and manage consistency across devices.
  • Visual Cognition Matters: Eye-tracking data revealed that certain elements, like the logo, are consistently high-attention areas, underscoring their importance for brand recognition and initial user engagement.
  • Subjective Experience is Key: While objective data from eye-tracking is valuable, subjective evaluations and user interviews are essential for understanding overall satisfaction and identifying areas for improvement, particularly in conciseness and ease of use.
  • Sustainable Design Integration: The paper links responsive design directly to sustainable user experience, highlighting how consistency and reduced learning curves contribute to longer product lifecycles and user loyalty.

Key Results

  • Six typical responsive website layouts were identified and classified.
  • Design factors were extracted and categorized into general, adaptive, and individual types.
  • A sales management software (SA) case study demonstrated the successful application of these factors, resulting in responsive interfaces for PC, tablet, and smartphone.
  • Usability testing showed that while both proposals maintained good operational continuity and visual consistency, Proposal B was significantly preferred for its simplicity of interface design and overall satisfaction, achieving higher scores in conciseness and overall satisfaction.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Focus on Homepage: The study primarily focused on homepage design. Future research should extend to other interface types and intelligent terminals like smartwatches and smart TVs to enhance the integrity of the study.
  • Limited Scope of Factors: While a comprehensive set of factors was identified, the study acknowledges that other controls exist (e.g., sequence maps, breadcrumbs) that were outside the scope of this research.
  • Exploratory Nature: The research is described as exploratory, suggesting that further validation and refinement of the proposed framework would be beneficial.

Summary updated

Abstract

Computers have been extended to a variety of devices, such as smart phones, tablets, and smart watches, thereby increasing the importance of responsive interfaces across multi-terminal devices. To ensure a consistent and sustainable user experience for websites and software products, it is important to study the layout, design elements, and users’ visual perception of different terminal interfaces. In this paper, the multi-terminal interfaces of 40 existing responsive websites were studied in a hierarchical grouping experiment, and six typical interface layouts were classified and extracted. Then, the main design factors affecting interface consistency of the responsive website were extracted and classified through eye tracking and a questionnaire survey. Finally, taking a sales management software tool (SA) as an example for design application, we successfully created responsive interfaces across multi-terminal devices with a consistent and sustainable experience.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2022design,
  author = {Wenjie Li and Yuxiao Zhou and Shijian Luo and Yenan Dong},
  title = {{Design Factors to Improve the Consistency and Sustainable User Experience of Responsive Interface Design}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/su14159131},
}
Figure