Design and testing of a mechanized brush-screen cooperative vibration harvester for mudflat-buried shellfish based on the discrete element method

Hangqi Li, Gang Mu, Hanbing Zhang, Hao Wu, Fawei Liu, Zhenyin Sun, Qian Zhang, Yizhou Wang, Yurui Wang, Xiuchen Li, Guochen ZhangFrontiers in Marine Science 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have developed a novel mechanized harvester for mudflat-buried shellfish that combines a double-layer vibrating screen with a two-stage rolling brush system. By optimizing the design using Discrete Element Method (DEM) simulations and field testing, the team achieved a harvesting efficiency of 114 pieces/m² with a remarkably low shellfish crushing rate of under 7%.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In China, shellfish aquaculture is a massive industry, yet harvesting mudflat-buried species like the white clam (Mactra veneriformis) remains stuck in the past. Traditional manual harvesting is backbreaking, labor-intensive, and inefficient. While mechanical dredges exist, many are banned in China due to their high energy consumption and destructive impact on the marine environment (such as sediment loss and poor selectivity).

The challenge lies in the mudflat itself: the high water content causes sediment to clump, making it difficult to separate shellfish from mud without damaging the catch. This paper introduces a "brush-screen cooperative" harvester designed to work effectively in these "dry" mudflat environments while minimizing the "crushing rate"—the percentage of shellfish damaged during the process.

Methods

The authors employed a multi-stage approach combining mechanical design, theoretical physics, and computer simulation:

  1. Mechanical Design: The harvester features a unique three-part system: a crank-rocker double-layer vibrating screen to sift sediment, a two-stage rolling brush (stainless steel and plastic) to break up mud clumps and sweep shellfish, and a conveyor chain for collection.
  2. Kinematic Modeling: The team established mathematical models to analyze the motion of a single shellfish on a vibrating screen, categorizing movement into "forward sliding," "backward sliding," and "jumping" states.
  3. Discrete Element Method (DEM): Using EDEM software, they created a virtual environment to simulate the complex interactions between the harvester's components, the shellfish, and the mudflat sediment. This allowed them to test variables without the cost of building dozens of physical prototypes.
  4. Response Surface Methodology (RSM): They used this statistical technique to find the optimal "sweet spot" for three key operating parameters: vibrating screen amplitude, brush rotation rate, and travel speed.

Datasets

While this is a mechanical engineering study rather than a pure data science paper, the "datasets" involved include:

  • Mudflat DEM Models: Specifically calibrated models for white clams and mudflat sediment based on previous literature (e.g., Poisson’s ratio, elasticity modulus, and density).
  • Simulation Experiments: A series of 17 response surface simulation tests used to generate the optimization equations.
  • Field Validation Data: Collected from a 15m x 1m test area in a sandy mudflat in Panjin City, Liaoning Province, China.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Cooperative" Advantage: The standout feature is the synergy between the brushes and the screen. The brushes don't just move the shellfish; they actively crush large mud clumps that would otherwise clog the vibrating screen, a common failure point in previous designs.
  • Quantifying Motion: The researchers used a "motion index" ($D$) to characterize how shellfish behave on the screen. They found that to improve efficiency, the backward motion index ($D_b$) must be greater than the forward index ($D_f$), ensuring the shellfish spend enough time on the screen to be cleaned but move toward the conveyor eventually.
  • Crushing is Cumulative: A key insight from the discussion is that crushing isn't caused by a single mechanism. It happens in stages: initial penetration of the shovel, pressure from the brush bristles, and the final drop into the collection basket. This suggests that future improvements should focus on "cushioning" these specific transition points.

Key Results

The study successfully identified the optimal operating parameters for the harvester:

  • Optimal Settings: 1.4 mm screen amplitude, 40 rpm brush rotation, and a travel speed of 10 m/min.
  • Simulation vs. Reality:
    • Efficiency: The simulation predicted 125 pieces/m², while the field test achieved 114 pieces/m² (an 8.8% relative error).
  • Crushing Rate: The simulation projected a 2.82% loss, while the field test resulted in 6.97%.
  • Significance: Statistical analysis (ANOVA) showed that screen amplitude and travel speed were the most significant factors ($p < 0.01$) affecting the quantity of shellfish harvested.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors noted that the crushing rate in the field (6.97%) was significantly higher than in the simulation (2.82%). They attribute this to the increased complexity of real-world environments, such as varying sediment density and the presence of debris.

Future directions include: * Structural Optimization: Redesigning the "drop" points between the conveyor and the collection basket to reduce impact damage. * Environmental Adaptability: Testing the harvester in different types of mudflats (e.g., higher clay content vs. sandy) to see how the "brush-screen" cooperation holds up. * Automation: Integrating sensors to automatically adjust brush speed and screen amplitude based on real-time sediment conditions.

Summary updated

Abstract

Introduction To enhance the application of mechanized harvesting and supplement research on harvesting theory in mudflat-buried shellfish harvesting in China, a brush-screen cooperative mudflat-buried shellfish vibration harvester was designed. Methods The harvester is primarily composed of a crank rocker double-layer vibrating screen, two stage rolling brush, and a conveyor chain. White clams ( Mactra veneriformis ) cultured in mudflats were used as the research objects in this paper, and the mechanics and motion states of the shellfish on the vibrating screen were analyzed. The shellfish harvesting simulation response surface experiments based on the discrete element method (DEM) were conducted to analyze the influence of the main operating parameters on the quantity of shellfish harvested. Results The results revealed that the number of shellfish harvested was significantly influenced ( p &amp;lt; 0.01) by vibrating screen amplitude, first-stage spiral rolling stainless steel brush rotation rate, and harvester travel speed. The optimal combination of key parameters was 1.4 mm, 40 rpm, and 10 m/min, respectively. With these values, the projected shellfish crushing rate was 2.82% and the shellfish harvesting efficiency was 125 pieces/m 2 . The equipment was then manufactured and the shellfish harvesting verification test was performed under the same operating parameters as the simulation. Test results indicated that the harvesting efficiency of the equipment was 114 pieces/m 2 and the shellfish crushing rate was 6.97%. Discussion The shellfish harvesting work could be completed by the equipment effectively and with low loss. The results of this study provide a theoretical reference for a novel mechanized method of harvesting mudflat-buried shellfish.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2023design,
  author = {Hangqi Li and Gang Mu and Hanbing Zhang and Hao Wu and Fawei Liu and Zhenyin Sun and Qian Zhang and Yizhou Wang and Yurui Wang and Xiuchen Li and Guochen Zhang},
  title = {{Design and testing of a mechanized brush-screen cooperative vibration harvester for mudflat-buried shellfish based on the discrete element method}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Marine Science},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3389/fmars.2023.1134888},
}
Figure