Design and Preliminary Evaluation of a Torso Stabiliser for Individuals with Spinal Cord Injury

Rejin John Varghese, Man-Yan Tong, Isabella Szczech, Peter Bryan, Magnus Aronson-Arminoff, Dario Farina, Etienne BurdetarXiv 2024 · arXiv

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel, low-cost, purely mechanical torso stabilizer for individuals with Spinal Cord Injury (SCI) that offers non-restrictive movement during daily activities and transitions to compliant blocking upon detecting an incipient fall. Early simulations and prototype validation demonstrate its potential to improve quality of life by addressing critical torso instability issues.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Spinal Cord Injury (SCI) frequently leads to significant torso instability, severely impacting an individual's ability to perform everyday tasks like reaching, and increasing the risk of secondary complications such as pressure sores. Existing assistive devices, like lateral trunk supports and thoracolumbosacral orthoses (TLSOs), are often rigid, restrictive, uncomfortable, or can exacerbate other issues. Wheelchair modifications offer limited support. There's a clear need for a device that provides on-demand support, is non-restrictive during normal movement, and can reliably prevent falls without causing undue discomfort or limitations.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-stage approach:

  1. Virtual Prototyping and Simulation: They used motion capture (MoCap) data from an individual with SCI performing ADL-like leaning movements. This data was used to create a subject-specific musculoskeletal model in OpenSim. Path actuators were added to the model to simulate the proposed cable-based device's behavior. This allowed them to identify key design parameters, specifically the required unrestricted cable travel and the cable velocity threshold for triggering the blocking mechanism.
  2. Mechanical Design and Prototyping: Based on simulation insights, they designed and built a 1-degree-of-freedom (DoF) mechanical torso stabilizer. The core mechanism is inspired by centrifugal clutches and seat-belt systems, utilizing pivoting flyweights with magnets. This design aims for transparency during normal movement and responsive, compliant blocking.
  3. MoCap-Based Validation: The prototype's behavior was validated using MoCap. The device was attached to a wheelchair, and a cable connected it to a vest worn by a subject. The MoCap system tracked markers on the device and the subject's body to quantify cable displacement and velocity during controlled pulling motions, simulating both normal movement and incipient falls.

Datasets

  • MoCap Data: Kinematic data was collected from an individual with SCI performing ADL-reaching tasks. This data was used for both the OpenSim simulation and the prototype validation.
  • Musculoskeletal Model: A subject-specific musculoskeletal model was generated in OpenSim, scaled from a publicly available model [8].

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Mechanical Simplicity for Robustness: The choice of a purely mechanical solution is a deliberate strategy to ensure robustness, simplicity, and cost-effectiveness, making the device potentially accessible in low- and middle-income countries.
  • Inspired by Proven Mechanisms: Leveraging principles from centrifugal clutches and seat-belts for the fall detection and locking mechanism offers a reliable and well-understood approach to a complex problem.
  • Two-Stage Fall Response: The device is designed to transition from a transparent mode to a compliant blocking mode, rather than an abrupt stop, which is crucial for user comfort and preventing secondary injuries.
  • Cable Velocity as a Trigger: The research identifies cable linear velocity as a viable parameter for triggering the blocking mechanism, with a simulated threshold of 80-100 cm/s.

Key Results

  • Simulated Requirements: The OpenSim simulations indicated that the device requires 55-60 cm of unrestricted cable travel and a locking threshold of 80-100 cm/s cable velocity.
  • Prototype Validation: MoCap validation of the prototype confirmed its ability to achieve non-restrictive travel of 55-60 cm during low-to-medium cable velocities.
  • Compliant Blocking: The prototype demonstrated a compliant but positive stop when the blocking mechanism was activated above a certain velocity threshold (observed around 62.8 cm/s in experiments, slightly lower than simulation).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Trigger Velocity Mismatch: The prototype's blocking mechanism activated at a lower velocity than predicted by simulations, leading to potential false positives. Further investigation is needed to tune this threshold.
  • Parameter Choice: The authors suggest exploring whether acceleration, rather than velocity, might be a more appropriate parameter for triggering the fall detection mechanism.
  • Robustness and Wearability: While the prototype is promising, further work is needed to enhance its robustness and ensure long-term wearability.
  • Clinical Trials: The current validation is preliminary. Future work requires more extensive testing with individuals without SCI to refine the system, followed by comprehensive trials with individuals with SCI.
  • Multi-DoF Extension: The current prototype is 1-DoF, but the authors note its potential to be extended to two DoFs for more comprehensive torso stabilization.

Summary updated

Abstract

Spinal cord injuries generally result in sensory and mobility impairments, with torso instability being particularly debilitating. Existing torso stabilisers are often rigid and restrictive. We present an early investigation into a non-restrictive 1 degree-of-freedom (DoF) mechanical torso stabiliser inspired by devices such as centrifugal clutches and seat-belt mechanisms. First, the paper presents a motion-capture (MoCap) and OpenSim-Based kinematic analysis of the cable-based system to understand the requisite device characteristics. The evaluation in simulation resulted in the cable-based device to require 55-60 cm of unrestricted travel, and to lock at a threshold cable velocity of 80-100 cm/s. Next, the developed 1-DoF device is introduced. The proposed mechanical device is transparent during activities of daily living, and transitions to compliant blocking when incipient fall is detected. Prototype behaviour was then validated using a MoCap-Based kinematic analysis to verify non-restrictive movement, reliable transition to blocking, and compliance of the blocking.Clinical relevance- This work establishes the need for torso stabilisation in individuals with Spinal Cord Injury (SCI) and proposes a low-cost passive platform to achieve the same.
BibTeX
@misc{varghese2024design,
  author = {Rejin John Varghese and Man-Yan Tong and Isabella Szczech and Peter Bryan and Magnus Aronson-Arminoff and Dario Farina and Etienne Burdet},
  title = {{Design and Preliminary Evaluation of a Torso Stabiliser for Individuals with Spinal Cord Injury}},
  year = {2024},
  eprint = {2403.17531},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17531},
}
Figure