Design and Practice of Deep Foundation Pits for Large Storage Ponds in Complex Environments

Zhihang Lin, Sen-hua Xie, Chang Xia, Hongqiang DouSustainability 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper details the design and construction of a large, deep foundation pit for a storage pond in a complex urban environment. By combining field measurements with a novel approach using both open-cut and cover-cut excavation methods, the study demonstrates effective deformation control and waterproofing, crucial for sponge city initiatives.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Urbanization leads to increased impervious surfaces, exacerbating urban flooding. Sponge city concepts, which utilize features like storm detention ponds, are vital for managing urban runoff and improving water quality. However, constructing these large, deep storage ponds in dense urban areas presents significant engineering challenges. These include dealing with complex geological conditions, limited construction space, and the need to protect adjacent sensitive structures and underground utilities. Traditional deep foundation pit construction often struggles with deformation control and waterproofing in such demanding environments, and there's a lack of systematic approaches specifically for large storage pond projects. This paper addresses this gap by presenting a case study of a challenging project and analyzing its successful implementation.

Methods

The study employs a multi-faceted approach:

  • Integrated Excavation Strategy: The project utilized a combination of open-cut excavation for the initial shallow levels, allowing for faster construction and easier deformation control, and cover-cut excavation for deeper levels. This latter method, where upper slabs are constructed before excavation, provides significant structural support and helps manage deformation in confined spaces.
  • Advanced Support System: A robust support system was designed, featuring a diaphragm wall (1.0m thick, 47.6m deep) as the primary enclosure, supplemented by double-row bored piles and corner bracing where space was limited. Internal support included two beam slabs and three structural beams, which also served as permanent structural elements for the storage pond and parking facility.
  • Waterproofing Measures: A layered approach was taken, including the diaphragm wall as a water-stop curtain, in-pit dewatering wells, and out-pit recharge wells to manage groundwater. Additional measures like a reinforced concrete retaining wall at the pit's edge and specialized construction joint treatments (e.g., steel plate waterstops, slurry treatment) were implemented to ensure water tightness.
  • Comprehensive Monitoring: A detailed monitoring plan was established, tracking horizontal and vertical displacements of the diaphragm wall, surrounding ground settlement, building deformation, support stress, and pore water pressure. A "three-stage warning" system (yellow, orange, red) was implemented to provide real-time feedback and trigger contingency measures.
  • Field Measurement Analysis: The core of the study lies in analyzing the extensive field measurement data collected during construction to evaluate the effectiveness of the chosen methods and identify critical stages for deformation.

Datasets

The paper utilizes field measurement data collected during the construction of a specific large storage pond project in Fuzhou City, China. This includes:

  • Horizontal and vertical displacement data for the diaphragm wall at various excavation stages and depths.
  • Ground settlement data at monitoring points around the pit.
  • Deformation data for adjacent buildings.
  • Groundwater level changes outside the pit.
  • Support stress and pore water pressure data.

No new benchmark datasets were introduced; the study focuses on analyzing data from a single, complex real-world project.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Synergy of Excavation Methods: The combination of open-cut and cover-cut excavation proved highly effective. While open-cut is faster, cover-cut offers superior deformation control, especially in later stages and confined spaces.
  • Critical Deformation Stages: The most significant horizontal displacement of the diaphragm wall and surrounding ground settlement occurred during the dismantling of temporary support structures after the first basement level excavation and during the construction of the first and second slabs. This highlights the importance of managing these transition periods.
  • Support System Effectiveness: The robust diaphragm wall, coupled with bored piles and internal bracing, provided excellent stiffness and effectively controlled lateral displacements, keeping them well within design limits and significantly better than some published benchmarks.
  • Waterproofing Success: Despite the challenges of potential leakage from construction joints and the pressurized aquifer, the implemented waterproofing measures, including specialized joint treatments, were successful in preventing leaks in the completed underground structure.
  • Importance of Monitoring: The "three-stage warning" system was crucial for real-time risk assessment and allowed for timely interventions, ensuring the safety of the pit and surrounding structures.

Key Results

  • Maximum lateral displacement of the diaphragm wall was within 0.05%-0.11% of the excavation depth (He), significantly less than the typical 1%He requirement and even lower than some stricter benchmarks (0.12%He).
  • Maximum ground settlement around the pit was less than the 10 mm yellow warning value, indicating effective control of surrounding soil deformation.
  • Settlement of adjacent buildings was also maintained below the 15 mm standard requirement.
  • The groundwater level outside the pit fluctuated but remained within a 600 mm warning range, demonstrating effective drainage and recharge control.
  • The entire basement construction was completed in 14 months, meeting safety and operational requirements, including zero leakage issues in the storage pond.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Uncertainty in Temporary Structure Removal: The paper notes an uncertainty in deformation control during the removal of temporary structures, particularly with the open-cut excavation method.
  • Single Case Study: The findings are based on a single, albeit complex, project. While providing valuable insights, broader applicability might require more case studies.
  • Optimization Potential: The authors suggest that there is scope for optimizing pit design for similar projects, implying that while the design was conservative and safe, further refinement could lead to more economical solutions.

Future work could involve comparative studies of different support systems and excavation sequences in similar complex environments, as well as further research into optimizing temporary structure removal strategies to minimize deformation.

Summary updated

Abstract

Storage ponds (storm detention ponds) are an important part of sponge city construction, and the construction process involves deep and large pit excavation in a complex and sensitive environment. Combined with a large storage pond pit engineering design and practice process, in this study, the complex environment of the design of the large storage pond pit method has been explored, using the field measurement data to test the support design of the deformation control effect and to summarize the practice of the key, difficult points of treatment measures. The results show that the procedure adopted in this project is a successful practice for using the pit characteristics, and the special treatment carried out for addressing the difficult points can effectively control the deformation, thus achieving waterproofing and deformation requirements of large-capacity water storage ponds. The design of the support is very effective in controlling the duration and deformation. The cover-cut excavation method, in combination with the support system, is highly effective in deformation control, whereas the open-cut excavation method is more likely to shorten the duration. However, there is an uncertainty in the deformation control during the removal of temporary structures in this method. The deformation characteristics of the pit enclosure and the surrounding ground surface are within the design requirements. The horizontal displacement of the wall and the surrounding settlement are mainly developed during the stage of dismantling the temporary support structure after excavating the first basement level and during the construction of the first and second slabs. The other stages benefit from the strong integrity of the support system, which can efficiently control the deformation. The treatment measures, support types, and component connection methods summarized in this article can provide a reference for the construction of similar underground storage ponds.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{lin2022design,
  author = {Zhihang Lin and Sen-hua Xie and Chang Xia and Hongqiang Dou},
  title = {{Design and Practice of Deep Foundation Pits for Large Storage Ponds in Complex Environments}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/su142114046},
}
Figure