Design and fabrication of bimodal meso-mesoporous WO3 thin films and their electrochromic properties

Wei Wang, Yongxin Pang, Simon HodgsonJournal of Materials Chemistry 2010 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel two-step sol-gel coating process to create bimodal mesoporous tungsten oxide (WO3) thin films. By chemically modifying one layer to be more sensitive to heat, the researchers achieved stable bimodal structures that exhibit superior electrochromic properties compared to their single-porosity counterparts.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The development of advanced materials with tailored nanostructures is crucial for improving the performance of various devices. Mesoporous materials, with their high surface area and ordered pore structures, offer unique advantages for applications like catalysis and energy storage. Specifically, bimodal mesoporous materials, possessing two distinct pore size distributions, are of great interest for applications requiring efficient transport and high surface area. However, fabricating stable bimodal mesoporous transition metal oxides, particularly tungsten oxide (WO3) thin films, has been challenging due to their tendency to crystallize and collapse during synthesis and thermal treatments. Existing methods for creating bimodal structures often struggle with thermal stability, limiting their practical use. This paper aims to address this by developing a robust and controllable method for fabricating thermally stable bimodal mesoporous WO3 thin films with enhanced electrochromic performance.

Methods

The core of this research lies in a novel two-step sol-gel coating process.

  • Sol-Gel Preparation: Tungstic acid was converted to peroxotungstic acid (PTA). The coating sol was prepared using PTA, the non-ionic surfactant Brij56, water, and ethanol.
  • Chemical Modification: A key innovation is the chemical modification of the sol using a small amount of H2O2. This modification enriches the peroxo tungsten oxide species in the hybrid framework, making the resulting film more flexible and thermally sensitive (prone to shrinkage) upon heating.
  • Two-Step Coating: The process involves sequentially coating the substrate. The first layer (C1) is subjected to a specific heat treatment (170 °C for 1 hour) to solidify its structure and impart a distinct thermal history. This is crucial for creating a mesostructural difference between the layers. The second layer (C2) is then coated on top.
  • Thermal Treatment: Both layers undergo subsequent thermal treatments at higher temperatures (up to 400 °C) to remove the organic template and solidify the film. The differential thermal sensitivity of the two layers, achieved through the H2O2 modification, allows for the preservation of the bimodal structure even after high-temperature annealing.
  • Characterization:
    • Low-angle X-ray Diffraction (XRD): Used to determine d-spacings and assess mesoporosity and pore arrangement.
  • Transmission Electron Microscopy (TEM): Provided direct visualization of the mesostructures and pore arrangements.
  • Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM): Used for film thickness measurements.
  • Electrochromic Measurements: Chronoamperometry and optical transmittance measurements were performed to evaluate the color-changing properties.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Differential Thermal Sensitivity is Key: The most significant insight is that by chemically modifying one layer to have a different thermal sensitivity (shrinkage behavior) than the other, stable bimodal mesostructures can be achieved. This is achieved by incorporating more peroxo tungsten oxide species via H2O2 addition.
  • Heat Treatment as a Tailoring Tool: The specific heat treatment of the first layer (C1) is critical. It solidifies the first layer and provides it with a distinct thermal history, ensuring it behaves differently from the second layer during subsequent annealing.
  • Preserving Bimodality at High Temperatures: The method successfully preserves the bimodal structure even after heating to 400 °C, a temperature that often causes structural collapse in less robust mesoporous materials.
  • Tailorable Mesostructural Difference: The difference in the unit cell parameter 'a' between the two layers can be tailored in the range of 0.2-0.6 nm by adjusting heat treatments.
  • Superior Electrochromic Performance: The bimodal WO3 films exhibit significantly improved electrochromic properties, including better coloration efficiency and faster response times, compared to monomodal counterparts.

Key Results

  • Successful Fabrication of Bimodal WO3 Films: The two-step coating process, combined with differential thermal sensitization, reliably produced bimodal mesoporous WO3 thin films.
  • Enhanced Electrochromic Properties:
    • Coloration Efficiency (CE): Bimodal CH1+CM2 films achieved a CE of up to 42 cm²/mC, which is significantly higher than previously reported mesoporous WO3 films.
  • Transmittance Change: Transmittance decreased from over 90% to 16% at -0.4 V (vs Ag) in 30 seconds for the bimodal films.
  • Response Times: Bimodal films showed shorter response times compared to monomodal films, attributed to wider pore openings facilitating proton diffusion.
  • Structural Stability: The bimodal mesostructures remained stable even after heat treatment at 400 °C.
  • Tailorable Pore Sizes: The mesostructural difference between the layers could be controlled between 0.2-0.6 nm.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Response Times: While improved, the response times of the developed materials are still somewhat slower compared to some non-mesoporous WO3 films. The authors suggest that etching techniques used for electrochemically grown films could potentially be applied for further enhancements.
  • Mixed Surfactant Limitations: The paper briefly explores a mixed surfactant approach (P123 + Brij56) but found that these templated films lacked satisfactory thermal stability, with mesostructures collapsing at 250 °C. This suggests that the two-step coating method is superior for achieving stable bimodal structures.
  • Future Work: The authors propose that this synthesis strategy, by modifying inorganic "building materials," could be extended to prepare a range of transition metal oxides with controlled bimodal mesostructures for applications beyond electrochromics, such as catalysis. Further investigations into the applicability of this synthesis strategy for other transition metal oxide systems are underway.

Summary updated

Abstract

Based on a novel, facile and reliable two-step coating process, tungsten oxide films (TOFs) with bimodal mesoporous-mesoporous structure (BMM) were designed and realised in terms of a bilayered mesostructural configuration. The key step for successful fabrication of these BMM TOFs is the selective thermal sensitisation of the tungstic acid/Brij 56 derived sol–gel TOFs by different chemical modification to the inorganic tungsten oxide species. Moreover, one striking advantage of this process lies in that it also allows delicate tailoring of the resulting BMM structures by simple heat-treatment at different temperatures. According to the initial test results on the electrochromic properties, the obtained BMM TOFs demonstrate superior performance over their monomodal counterparts.
BibTeX
@article{wang2010design,
  author = {Wei Wang and Yongxin Pang and Simon Hodgson},
  title = {{Design and fabrication of bimodal meso-mesoporous WO3 thin films and their electrochromic properties}},
  journal = {Journal of Materials Chemistry},
  year = {2010},
  doi = {10.1039/c0jm01446j},
}
Figure