TL;DR
This paper introduces "Viscoelastic McKibben Actuators" (VMAs) by adding polymer sheaths to traditional McKibben artificial muscles. They demonstrate that these sheaths can effectively tune the force-velocity response of the actuators, making them more adaptable for bioinspired robotics and assistive devices. A simplified model is presented to connect material properties to actuator dynamics.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Pneumatic artificial muscles, specifically McKibben actuators, are popular in soft robotics due to their lightweight and high force-to-weight ratio. While their static force-length properties are well-understood, their dynamic behavior, particularly the force-velocity relationship, is less explored. This is a critical gap because this relationship is fundamental to mimicking biological muscle and for robust dynamic modeling of robotic systems. Existing methods to tune this relationship often rely on specialized materials or complex auxiliary equipment. This paper aims to address this by investigating a simpler method: adding viscoelastic sheaths to modify the force-velocity response.
Methods
The researchers fabricated four types of actuators: a control (plain McKibben) and three VMAs with different viscoelastic sheaths (Ecoflex-30, Urethane, and a Carbopol/Ecoflex composite). These actuators were characterized using iso-velocity experiments, a technique adapted from muscle physiology studies. The core of the experimental setup involved an Instron universal testing system to measure force and length while a microcontroller controlled inflation pressure.
A simplified 1D model was developed using parallel chains of Standard Linear Solid elements (SLSEs) to represent the McKibben actuator and its sheath. This model allows for the analytical derivation of force-velocity curves and relates them to material properties like stiffness and damping. The model was then used to fit experimental data and understand how the sheaths influence the actuator's dynamic behavior.
Datasets
Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on experimental characterization of custom-built actuators.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Sheaths as Tunable Dampers: The addition of viscoelastic sheaths provides a straightforward way to modify the force-velocity characteristics of McKibben actuators, offering a more accessible tuning mechanism than previous methods.
- Material Properties Dictate Dynamics: The choice of sheath material directly impacts the force-velocity curve. For instance, urethane sheaths tended to create a more viscous-dominant response, while Ecoflex sheaths led to a more elastic-dominant response.
- Asymmetric Force-Velocity Response: A key finding is the inherent asymmetry in the force-velocity curves, with extension responses differing from shortening responses. This is attributed to the nonlinear stiffness of the McKibben actuators themselves, which the linear model doesn't fully capture.
- Pressure Dependence: Increasing inflation pressure generally leads to a stiffer actuator, which, according to the model, should decrease the height of the force-velocity curve. This was observed experimentally, though the effect diminished at higher pressures, possibly due to changes in the bladder-mesh contact state.
- Model Utility: The simplified SLSE model, while having limitations, proved effective in capturing the main trends of the experimental force-velocity curves and providing insights into how sheath properties influence actuator dynamics.
Key Results
- The study successfully demonstrated the ability to tune the force-velocity response of McKibben actuators by adding viscoelastic sheaths.
- Urethane sheaths generally increased the height of the force-velocity curve, indicating a more viscous-dominant behavior, while Ecoflex sheaths decreased it, suggesting a more elastic-dominant response.
- The developed 1D SLSE model achieved a good fit to experimental data (R² = 0.94±0.05), successfully explaining trends related to material properties and pressure.
- The model highlighted that the height of the force-velocity curve is primarily governed by stiffness ratios (k) and the steepness by damping time constants (γ).
Limitations and Future Work
- Model Limitations: The current linear SLSE model does not fully capture the observed asymmetry in force-velocity curves (extension vs. shortening) due to the nonlinear elasticity of the McKibben actuators. It also doesn't account for the pressure dependence of sheath properties, which is likely influenced by the McKibben's deformation.
- Experimental Limitations: The iso-velocity tests were conducted at relatively high speeds, making it difficult to accurately characterize the force-velocity curve near the zero-velocity discontinuity. Higher test rates also led to extension and shortening overshoot, complicating peak force measurements.
- Future Work: The authors suggest conducting iso-velocity tests at slower speeds to better understand the steep portion of the curve. They also propose incorporating more accurate quasi-static McKibben models and 3D geometric information to better capture nonlinearities and pressure-dependent sheath properties. Future characterization should include cyclic testing to investigate hysteresis. The inclusion of non-linear friction models is also recommended.
Summary updated