Design and Application of Quadrature Compensation Patterns in Bulk Silicon Micro-Gyroscopes

Yunfang Ni, Hongsheng Li, Libin Huang2014 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a novel design and application of quadrature compensation patterns for bulk silicon micro-gyroscopes, a critical issue for high-performance inertial sensing. By employing system stiffness matrix diagonalization through carefully designed comb capacitors and applied voltages, they successfully reduced quadrature error, achieving a compensation of 357 °/s in experiments.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Silicon micro-gyroscopes are essential for navigation and consumer electronics due to their small size and low power consumption. However, a significant challenge in their design is the "quadrature error," a parasitic vibration response that mixes with the true Coriolis signal, leading to inaccurate measurements. This error arises from imperfections in the mechanical structure, specifically off-diagonal stiffness in the stiffness matrix. Existing methods for reducing this error either operate in the signal processing domain (signal nulling) or attempt to correct it at the source (movement correction). While movement correction is preferred, previous approaches like mechanical stiffness matrix diagonalization are difficult to implement, and force feedback balancing requires precise control. This paper addresses the need for a more practical and effective movement correction method for bulk silicon micro-gyroscopes.

Methods

The core of this paper's solution is system stiffness matrix diagonalization. This method involves introducing an artificial electrostatic stiffness that precisely counteracts the inherent mechanical stiffness causing the quadrature error. The authors propose using comb capacitors for quadrature compensation patterns in bulk silicon micro-gyroscopes, as they offer better compensation capability compared to parallel plate capacitors in a limited area.

Key methodological aspects include:

  • Four Basic Structural Units: They define four types of basic structural units (Type-A, B, C, D) that, when actuated by DC voltages, generate specific electrostatic forces and stiffness matrices. These units are designed to provide either positive or negative electrostatic coupling stiffness.
  • Novel Layout Design: To eliminate unwanted static forces and torques introduced by these compensation patterns, a specific layout is proposed. This design strategically places different types of units to cancel out static forces and torques, ensuring only the desired dynamic forces contribute to compensation.
  • Parameter Optimization: The paper emphasizes optimizing structural parameters, particularly the gap ratio of the comb capacitors, to maximize compensation capability within limited voltage and area constraints.
  • Voltage Loading Methods: Two methods for applying DC voltages are discussed:
  • Single Group Loading: Applying voltage to only one group of compensation patterns (either positive or negative stiffness) for off-line compensation. This method leads to a non-linear relationship between the compensation voltage and the quadrature signal.
  • Double Group Loading: Applying voltages to both groups of patterns. This method allows for on-line compensation and results in a more linear relationship between the compensation voltage and the quadrature signal, with less impact on the sense mode's natural frequency.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The experiments were conducted on a self-developed dual-mass silicon micro-gyroscope prototype.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Comb Capacitors for Bulk Gyros: The paper highlights that comb capacitors are superior to parallel plate capacitors for quadrature compensation in bulk silicon micro-gyroscopes due to better area utilization and overall compensation capability.
  • Canceling Static Disturbances: The proposed novel layout design is crucial for eliminating parasitic static forces and torques, which could otherwise interfere with the gyroscope's operation. This is achieved by carefully balancing the forces and torques generated by different compensation units.
  • Trade-offs in Voltage Loading: The choice between single and double group voltage loading depends on the application's requirements for on-line vs. off-line compensation, linearity, and impact on sense mode dynamics. Double group loading offers advantages in linearity and stability.
  • Theoretical vs. Experimental Voltage: The experimental results show that the actual compensation voltages required were slightly larger than theoretically predicted, suggesting that real-world fabrication imperfections and unmodeled effects might necessitate slightly higher voltages.

Key Results

  • Theoretical Compensation Capability: The design theoretically achieved a compensation capability for a quadrature equivalent angular rate of no more than 412 °/s.
  • Experimental Compensation: In experiments on a packaged micro-gyroscope prototype, an actual quadrature equivalent angular rate of 357 °/s was successfully compensated.
  • Voltage Accuracy: The actual compensation voltages used were slightly larger than the theoretical values.
  • Validation: The experimental results closely matched the theoretical predictions, validating the design and analytical models presented in the paper.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Residual In-phase Error: The paper notes that even after quadrature compensation, a residual "in-phase error" of about 100 mV was observed. This is attributed to other coupling mechanisms, such as viscous coupling between the drive and sense modes, which are not addressed by the quadrature compensation method.
  • On-line Compensation: While double group loading is presented as suitable for on-line compensation, the paper focuses on off-line compensation in its experimental validation. Further work could explore the practical implementation and performance of on-line compensation.
  • Fabrication Tolerances: The slight discrepancy between theoretical and experimental voltages suggests that future work could investigate the impact of fabrication tolerances on the compensation performance and potentially incorporate adaptive or self-tuning mechanisms.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{ni2014design,
  author = {Yunfang Ni and Hongsheng Li and Libin Huang},
  title = {{Design and Application of Quadrature Compensation Patterns in Bulk Silicon Micro-Gyroscopes}},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.3390/s141120419},
}
Figure