TL;DR
This paper models and analyzes the impact of fluctuating material prices and trade agreements like the Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP) on global supply chain network design. It uses mixed-integer programming to optimize costs, revealing how TPP and material price volatility influence supplier selection and factory location decisions.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
In today's globalized economy, manufacturing firms increasingly rely on complex supply chains that span multiple countries to reduce costs and access new markets. Designing these networks is challenging due to several factors:
- Customs Duties: International trade involves tariffs that add to the cost of parts and finished products.
- Trade Agreements: Treaties like Free Trade Agreements (FTAs) and the Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP) can alter these customs duties, impacting cost-effectiveness.
- Fluctuating Material Prices: Global commodity prices, particularly for oil and its derivatives like plastics, are volatile. These fluctuations directly affect the cost of raw materials and, consequently, the price of manufactured parts.
The paper aims to address the gap in understanding how these dynamic factors – trade policies and material price volatility – interact and influence the optimal design of global supply chain networks. Specifically, it investigates how to best select suppliers and locate factories to minimize costs under these changing conditions.
Methods
The study employs a mixed-integer programming (MIP) model to represent and optimize the global supply chain network. This is a standard approach for complex optimization problems with discrete (integer) and continuous variables.
Key aspects of their methodology include:
- Network Modeling: The global supply chain is modeled as a network comprising suppliers, factories, and markets. The model incorporates transportation costs, procurement costs, manufacturing costs, fixed factory opening costs, and fixed route opening costs.
- Customs Duty Integration: The model explicitly includes customs duties on both parts and finished products during international transportation.
- TPP Regime: The impact of the TPP is analyzed by considering scenarios where customs duties are reduced or eliminated between specific member countries (e.g., Japan and Malaysia).
- Bill of Materials (BOM): The study utilizes a detailed BOM, which lists all parts, their materials, quantities, weights, and procurement costs. This allows for a granular analysis of how material price fluctuations affect individual components.
- Sensitivity Analysis: The core of the analysis involves conducting sensitivity analysis on material prices (specifically polypropylene and aluminum alloy) to observe how changes affect the optimal supply chain configuration and total cost.
- Scenario-Based Comparison: Two main scenarios are compared: "With TPP" and "Without TPP," to isolate the impact of the trade agreement.
The novelty lies in the integrated analysis of fluctuating material prices in conjunction with the TPP regime, using a detailed BOM for component-level analysis, and performing sensitivity analysis on specific material types.
Datasets
- Bill of Materials (BOM) for a Vacuum Cleaner: The paper uses a BOM for a vacuum cleaner, adapted from previous research [10, 22]. This BOM provides detailed information on parts, materials, suppliers, quantities, weights, and procurement costs.
- Geographical Data: Distances between suppliers, factories, and markets are based on data from [10], reflecting locations in Japan, China, and Malaysia.
No new benchmarks were introduced; rather, existing data was leveraged to model a specific product and its supply chain.
Key Insights and Ideas
- TPP's Influence on Supplier Switching: The TPP can significantly alter supplier selection patterns. When customs duties are reduced or eliminated between TPP partners, it becomes more advantageous to source from suppliers within those partner countries, even if their base material costs are slightly higher, to avoid tariffs.
- Material Weight Matters: The impact of material price fluctuations is more pronounced for parts with higher weights. This is because the procurement cost is calculated by multiplying material cost by weight, making heavier components more sensitive to price changes.
- Material Type Sensitivity: Different materials exhibit varying degrees of susceptibility to price fluctuations. Polypropylene, with a wider range of part weights in the BOM, showed a greater impact on the supply chain network compared to aluminum alloy, where part weights were more uniform.
- Factory Location is Crucial: The location of the factory plays a significant role in supplier selection, especially when considering transportation costs. Suppliers closer to the chosen factory are often preferred to minimize logistics expenses.
- Cost Minimization Drives Decisions: Ultimately, the goal of cost minimization drives the selection of suppliers and factory locations, balancing procurement costs, transportation costs, customs duties, and fixed operational costs.
Key Results
- TPP and Total Cost: When polypropylene prices doubled, the total cost with TPP was only 0.1% higher than without TPP, indicating a relatively small difference in total cost but significant shifts in supplier patterns.
- Supplier Switching with TPP: With TPP, when polypropylene prices doubled, Chinese suppliers for heavier polypropylene parts were replaced by Malaysian suppliers to leverage reduced customs duties.
- Material Price Fluctuation Impact: Fluctuations in polypropylene prices had a more significant impact on the supply chain network than aluminum alloy price fluctuations, primarily due to the wider range of part weights for polypropylene components.
- Redesign vs. No Redesign: The study highlights that considering a "redesign problem" (allowing for factory relocation) can lead to different supplier selections compared to a scenario without redesign, emphasizing the importance of factory location in cost optimization.
Limitations and Future Work
Limitations:
- Exchange Rate Ignored: The study explicitly states that the influence of exchange rates was not considered to clarify the impact of TPP and material price fluctuations.
- Single Product Focus: The analysis is based on a single product (vacuum cleaner), and the findings might not generalize to all product types without further investigation.
- Limited Countries: The study focuses on Japan, China, and Malaysia, and expanding to other countries and FTAs could provide broader insights.
Future Work:
- Expand Country and FTA Coverage: Conduct numerical experiments covering more countries and various FTAs.
- Incorporate Exchange Rates: Add exchange rate fluctuations to the model to provide a more comprehensive analysis.
- Multi-Objective Optimization: Extend the model to a multi-objective problem that includes factors like CO2 saving rates, alongside cost minimization.
Summary updated