Descriptive Epidemiology of Pathogens Associated with Acute Respiratory Infection in a Community-Based Study of K–12 School Children (2015–2023)

Cristalyne Bell, Maureen Goss, Derek Norton, Shari Barlow, Emily Temte, Cecilia He, Caroline Hamer, Sarah Walters, Alea Sabry, Kelly Johnson, Guanhua Chen, Amra Uzicanin, Jonathan L. TemtePathogens 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study provides a comprehensive, decade-long epidemiological overview of common respiratory pathogens in school-aged children, revealing distinct seasonal patterns and age associations for various viruses. The findings highlight the utility of school-based surveillance for tracking respiratory illness trends and informing public health responses, especially in the context of emerging threats like SARS-CoV-2.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Acute Respiratory Infections (ARIs) are a significant public health burden, leading to clinical care, missed school days, and potential severe outcomes. While influenza has historically been a focus of surveillance, understanding the broader spectrum of circulating respiratory pathogens, their seasonal dynamics, and their impact on school-aged children is crucial for effective public health interventions. Traditional surveillance often relies on medically attended cases, potentially missing community-level trends. This paper addresses the need for a detailed, community-based, laboratory-confirmed understanding of ARI etiologies in a pediatric population, particularly within the school setting, which acts as a key hub for transmission.

Methods

The study employed the ORegon CHild Absenteeism due to Respiratory Disease Study (ORCHARDS), a longitudinal, school-based surveillance program. Children aged 4-18 experiencing ARIs (defined by symptom criteria and a Jackson score) were eligible. Nasal or oropharyngeal swabs were collected and tested using multiplex reverse-transcription polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) for 18 respiratory viruses and 2 atypical bacterial pathogens. The study design allowed for continuous monitoring over an extended period, capturing pre- and post-SARS-CoV-2 emergence data. Statistical analyses included descriptive statistics, temporal trend analysis, and pairwise comparisons of median ages for different pathogen detections.

Datasets

The study utilized data collected from the ORegon CHild Absenteeism due to Respiratory Disease Study (ORCHARDS) between January 5, 2015, and June 9, 2023. This dataset comprises demographic, epidemiologic, and symptom data from 3498 participating K-12 students, along with laboratory results from collected respiratory specimens. No new benchmark datasets were introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Schools as Early Warning Systems: The study reinforces the idea that schools are critical environments for respiratory virus transmission and that school-based surveillance can serve as an early indicator of broader community outbreaks.
  • Distinct Viral Fingerprints: Different respiratory pathogens exhibit unique temporal patterns and age predilections, allowing for a more nuanced understanding of their epidemiology. For instance, SARS-CoV-2 showed year-round circulation and a higher median age of affected children compared to other viruses.
  • Impact of COVID-19 Interventions: The data clearly illustrate the disruption caused by COVID-19 pandemic mitigation strategies (school closures, masking, etc.) on ARI incidence and pathogen detection patterns, highlighting the influence of public health measures.
  • Comprehensive Pathogen Profiling: The use of multiplex RT-PCR allowed for the simultaneous detection of a wide array of pathogens, providing a more complete picture of ARI etiologies than single-pathogen testing.

Key Results

  • A total of 3498 children participated, with pathogens detected in 70.3% of specimens.
  • Rhinovirus/enteroviruses (36%) and influenza viruses A/B (35%) were the most frequently detected pathogens.
  • Rhino/enteroviruses and parainfluenza viruses typically circulated early in the academic year, followed by seasonal coronaviruses, RSV, influenza viruses, and human metapneumovirus.
  • SARS-CoV-2, detected from March 2020 onwards, circulated year-round and was associated with a higher median age (12.4 years) compared to other viruses.
  • Seasonal coronaviruses and rhino/enteroviruses were more common in older students (around 10-11 years), while RSV, parainfluenza, influenza A, human metapneumovirus, and adenoviruses were more prevalent in younger children (<10 years).
  • Cough, nasal congestion, and fatigue were the most commonly reported symptoms across all viruses.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Limited Diversity: The study population was primarily White and non-Hispanic, limiting the generalizability of findings to more diverse racial/ethnic groups or densely populated urban settings.
  • Protocol Changes: The implementation of no-contact specimen collection due to COVID-19 led to some missing data for certain participants.
  • Age Restriction: Conclusions are limited to the school-aged population (4-18 years).
  • Self-Reported Data: Some data, such as illness severity and source of infection, relied on self-assessment, introducing potential for mischaracterization.
  • School Attendance Bias: Recruitment was influenced by school absenteeism, potentially underrepresenting milder illnesses or those occurring during school breaks.

Future work could involve expanding surveillance to more diverse populations and settings. The study's long duration and comprehensive data collection provide a valuable foundation for further epidemiological analyses and for informing targeted public health strategies.

Summary updated

Abstract

School-based outbreaks often precede increased incidence of acute respiratory infections in the greater community. We conducted acute respiratory infection surveillance among children to elucidate commonly detected pathogens in school settings and their unique characteristics and epidemiological patterns. The ORegon CHild Absenteeism due to Respiratory Disease Study (ORCHARDS) is a longitudinal, laboratory-supported, school-based, acute respiratory illness (ARI) surveillance study designed to evaluate the utility of cause-specific student absenteeism monitoring for early detection of increased activity of influenza and other respiratory viruses in schools from kindergarten through 12th grade. Eligible participants with ARIs provided demographic, epidemiologic, and symptom data, along with a nasal swab or oropharyngeal specimen. Multipathogen testing using reverse-transcription polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) was performed on all specimens for 18 respiratory viruses and 2 atypical bacterial pathogens (<i>Chlamydia pneumoniae</i> and <i>Mycoplasma pneumoniae</i>). Between 5 January 2015 and 9 June 2023, 3498 children participated. Pathogens were detected in 2455 of 3498 (70%) specimens. Rhinovirus/enteroviruses (36%) and influenza viruses A/B (35%) were most commonly identified in positive specimens. Rhinovirus/enteroviruses and parainfluenza viruses occurred early in the academic year, followed by seasonal coronaviruses, RSV, influenza viruses A/B, and human metapneumovirus. Since its emergence in 2020, SARS-CoV-2 was detected year-round and had a higher median age than the other pathogens. A better understanding of the etiologies, presentations, and patterns of pediatric acute respiratory infections can help inform medical and public health system responses.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{bell2024descriptive,
  author = {Cristalyne Bell and Maureen Goss and Derek Norton and Shari Barlow and Emily Temte and Cecilia He and Caroline Hamer and Sarah Walters and Alea Sabry and Kelly Johnson and Guanhua Chen and Amra Uzicanin and Jonathan L. Temte},
  title = {{Descriptive Epidemiology of Pathogens Associated with Acute Respiratory Infection in a Community-Based Study of K–12 School Children (2015–2023)}},
  booktitle = {Pathogens},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3390/pathogens13040340},
}
Figure