TL;DR
This paper introduces a novel "Deep Basis Fitting" approach for image-guided depth completion, replacing the final convolutional layer of standard deep networks with a learnable least-squares fitting module. This method significantly improves depth prediction accuracy by explicitly fitting learned "depth bases" to sparse depth measurements, leading to more consistent and precise results.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Estimating a dense, pixel-wise depth map from a single color image is a challenging task, often referred to as depth estimation. A related, even harder problem is depth completion, where the goal is to infer a dense depth map given a color image and a sparse set of depth measurements (e.g., from a LiDAR sensor). Standard deep learning approaches for depth completion typically use a final convolutional layer to map learned features to depth values. However, these methods can struggle to precisely enforce consistency with the sparse input measurements, especially in the presence of noise or outliers. This paper aims to bridge this gap by proposing a more principled way to integrate sparse depth information into the deep learning pipeline, leading to more accurate and robust depth completion.
Methods
The core innovation is the replacement of the final 1x1 convolutional layer in a standard depth completion network with a Least-Squares Fitting (LSF) module. Instead of learning fixed weights for this final layer, the LSF module learns to fit a set of "depth bases" (learned features from earlier network layers) to the sparse depth measurements using a least-squares optimization.
Here's a breakdown of the key methodological aspects:
- Depth Bases: The features from the penultimate layer of the deep network are treated as "depth bases." These bases are learned through standard backpropagation.
- Least-Squares Fitting: The LSF module performs a linear least-squares fit to map these depth bases to the sparse depth measurements. This can be formulated as solving $Bw = t$, where $B$ is a matrix of stacked depth bases, $w$ are the weights to be learned, and $t$ are transformed sparse depth targets.
- Robustified Nonlinear Fitting: To handle real-world noise and outliers in the sparse depth data, the authors extend the linear least-squares approach to a robustified nonlinear fitting method using M-estimators (specifically, the Huber loss). This allows the model to be less sensitive to erroneous measurements.
- Multi-scale Prediction: For improved self-supervised training, the LSF module is adapted to predict depth at multiple scales. Instead of predicting full depth maps at each scale independently, the method predicts multi-scale bases that are then combined to reconstruct the full-resolution depth map. This approach is more parameter-efficient and leads to more coherent multi-scale predictions.
Datasets
The paper evaluates its method on several standard datasets for depth estimation and completion:
- KITTI: A widely used dataset for autonomous driving, providing both image and LiDAR data. The authors use the KITTI Depth Completion dataset.
- Virtual KITTI (V-KITTI): A synthetic dataset generated from simulated environments, offering dense ground truth depth.
- Synthia: Another synthetic dataset with urban scenes and dense ground truth.
- NYU Depth V2 (NYU-V2): An indoor dataset with RGB-D images.
The sparse depth maps are generated by projecting LiDAR measurements onto the closest image or by randomly sampling pixels from the ground truth depth maps, with specific depth caps applied for some datasets.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Explicitly fitting to sparse data matters: The core insight is that directly optimizing a least-squares fit between learned features (depth bases) and sparse measurements is more effective than relying solely on a final convolutional layer. This explicit constraint enforces better consistency with the input data.
- Retraining is crucial: The authors emphasize that retraining the entire network with the LSF module integrated leads to significantly better performance than simply replacing the final layer of a pre-trained network. This allows the network to learn depth bases that are better suited for the fitting process.
- Robustness to noise is achievable: The extension to robust nonlinear fitting demonstrates that deep learning models can be made more resilient to noisy and outlier-ridden sparse depth data, a common issue in real-world applications.
- Multi-scale bases are more efficient: The multi-scale basis prediction approach for self-supervised learning is more parameter-efficient and leads to better depth maps compared to independent multi-scale predictions.
Key Results
The proposed Deep Basis Fitting method consistently outperforms baseline methods across various datasets and training scenarios.
- Supervised Training: The LSF module, when retrained, shows significant improvements in MAE (Mean Absolute Error) and RMSE (Root Mean Squared Error) compared to baseline convolutional approaches, especially for RGB-only input where the baseline has no sparse depth information. For RGBD input, improvements are also observed, indicating better utilization of sparse depth.
- Robustness: The robustified nonlinear fitting (lsf2+) shows strong performance even when trained on noisy and outlier-corrupted data, often approaching the performance of models trained on clean data.
- Self-Supervised Training: The multi-scale LSF approach also yields consistent improvements in self-supervised settings, outperforming the baseline with fewer parameters.
- Comparison to PnP: While PnP offers similar benefits without retraining, the authors found their method to yield larger improvements and be more efficient.
Limitations and Future Work
- Underdetermined Systems: The paper acknowledges that for extremely sparse points, the linear system becomes underdetermined, requiring strong regularization.
- Future Work: The authors suggest adopting a full Bayesian approach to handle cases with extremely sparse points. They also propose further exploration of the multi-scale prediction scheme and its application to other regression problems.
Summary updated