Density of states of chaotic Andreev billiards

Jack Kuipers, Thomas Engl, Gregory Berkolaiko, Cyril Petitjean, Daniel Waltner, Klaus RichterPhysical 2011 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper uses a semiclassical approach to understand the density of states in "Andreev billiards" – hybrid systems of normal metals and superconductors. They show how quantum interference effects, arising from electron-hole reflections at the superconductor interface, create a "hard gap" in the energy spectrum, and how this gap is modified by factors like magnetic fields, phase differences between superconductors, and the finite time electrons spend in the system (Ehrenfest time).

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

When a normal metal is brought close to a superconductor, a phenomenon called the "proximity effect" occurs, where the superconductor influences the normal metal's properties. In systems with chaotic classical dynamics, this proximity effect leads to a striking feature: a "hard gap" in the density of electronic states just above the Fermi energy. This gap, predicted by Random Matrix Theory (RMT), is a signature of the system's quantum nature. However, understanding this gap from a semiclassical perspective, which connects quantum behavior to classical trajectories, has been challenging. Traditional semiclassical methods only predict an exponential suppression of states, not a true gap. This paper aims to bridge this gap by developing a semiclassical framework that can accurately describe the density of states in these "chaotic Andreev billiards" across various regimes, including the influence of external parameters.

Methods

The authors employ a semiclassical approach based on the scattering matrix formalism. This involves analyzing the trajectories of electrons and holes within the billiard. They extend previous work by developing a diagrammatic technique to represent correlations between these trajectories. These diagrams, visualized as "trees," allow them to systematically calculate contributions to the density of states. A key aspect is the ability to incorporate the effects of:

  • Andreev Reflection: The fundamental process where electrons are reflected as holes (and vice versa) at the superconductor interface.
  • Quantum Interference: Subtle correlations between classical electron and hole paths that lead to constructive or destructive interference, ultimately shaping the density of states.
  • Ehrenfest Time: The characteristic time scale separating classical-like wave packet evolution from longer-time interference effects.
  • Magnetic Fields: Investigated by breaking time-reversal symmetry in the semiclassical treatment.
  • Phase Differences: Explored in systems with two superconductors.

They also leverage algebraic techniques to derive and solve complex equations for generating functions that describe these correlations.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study is theoretical and relies on analytical calculations and numerical simulations of the derived equations.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Semiclassical Origin of the Hard Gap: The paper provides a detailed semiclassical explanation for the formation of the hard gap, attributing it to the interference of electron and hole trajectories that are "almost identical" due to chaotic dynamics.
  • Ehrenfest Time's Dual Role: The finite Ehrenfest time has a dual effect: it shrinks the primary gap but, intriguingly, can lead to the appearance of a second hard gap at intermediate values. This second gap is a clear signature of the Ehrenfest time's influence.
  • Sensitivity to Parameters: The density of states is shown to be highly sensitive to the phase difference between superconductors and the strength of an applied magnetic field, offering potential avenues for controlling quantum transport properties.
  • Unified Framework: The developed semiclassical framework successfully unifies different regimes, from the RMT limit (zero Ehrenfest time) to the classical Bohr-Sommerfeld limit (infinite Ehrenfest time), and accounts for the influence of external parameters.

Key Results

  • The paper successfully reproduces the hard gap predicted by RMT using a semiclassical approach.
  • It demonstrates that a finite Ehrenfest time leads to a shrinking of the main gap and the emergence of a second, distinct hard gap.
  • The density of states is shown to be suppressed by magnetic fields and phase differences between superconductors, with the gap closing at specific critical values.
  • The authors provide explicit equations and figures illustrating these effects, showing how the density of states evolves under varying conditions.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Subleading Order Contributions: The current work focuses on leading-order contributions in the inverse channel number. Extending the theory to subleading orders, which would involve more complex diagrams and potentially new phenomena, is identified as a significant challenge.
  • Heisenberg Time Regime: The semiclassical treatment is limited to energy scales above the Heisenberg time. Accessing the density of states at even smaller energy scales, where RMT predicts a microscopic gap, remains an open question.
  • Disorder and Scarring: The paper acknowledges that other effects like scarring and classical Lyapunov exponent fluctuations can influence the density of states, which are not explicitly addressed in this work.
  • Experimental Verification: While the theoretical predictions are detailed, direct experimental verification of all the nuances, particularly the second gap due to Ehrenfest time, would be a crucial next step.

Summary updated

Abstract

Quantum cavities or dots have markedly different properties depending on whether their classical counterparts are chaotic or not. Connecting a superconductor to such a cavity leads to notable proximity effects, particularly the appearance, predicted by random matrix theory, of a hard gap in the excitation spectrum of quantum chaotic systems. Andreev billiards are interesting examples of such structures built with superconductors connected to a ballistic normal metal billiard since each time an electron hits the superconducting part it is retroreflected as a hole (and vice versa). Using a semiclassical framework for systems with chaotic dynamics, we show how this reflection, along with the interference due to subtle correlations between the classical paths of electrons and holes inside the system, is ultimately responsible for the gap formation. The treatment can be extended to include the effects of a symmetry-breaking magnetic field in the normal part of the billiard or an Andreev billiard connected to two phase-shifted superconductors. Therefore, we are able to see how these effects can remold and eventually suppress the gap. Furthermore, the semiclassical framework is able to cover the effect of a finite Ehrenfest time, which also causes the gap to shrink. However, for intermediate values this leads to the appearance of a second hard gap---a clear signature of the Ehrenfest time.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{kuipers2011density,
  author = {Jack Kuipers and Thomas Engl and Gregory Berkolaiko and Cyril Petitjean and Daniel Waltner and Klaus Richter},
  title = {{Density of states of chaotic Andreev billiards}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2011},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevb.83.195316},
}
Figure